Mafia #6.....The Play

Madcrawdad said:
well, the snitch has spoken....

Mee-mee
Plantling
KOTD
Madcrawdad

one of them is definitely mafia, and it ain't me..... two on the list have already piqued my interest though.
Click to expand...

I wasn't put on anyone's list at all, where do you find this list of the snitch's...

IceH2O said:
I understand the 1st 3 deaths but was Clown hit by the Vig or did he quit? I guess DP decided not to PM Rb.

Guess what we need to do now is decide which of the 4 are mafia? Should we also add DP to that list?
Click to expand...

and remember this...
FOR THE FIRST 6 DAY/NIGHTS, THE DON WILL SHOW AS AN INNOCENT ON ANY INVESTIGATION OR UPON LYNCHING.

and if the Vig would have hit any of them it would have stated it..
 
OgreMkV said:
So, at least one of mee-mee, plantling, KOTD, and Mad is mafia.

Now, I'll add in a bit. I think that two people now know I'm innocent. I think that the detective investigated either Ice, Mad or myself. If the detective investigated me, he knows. I also think that the doctor knows I'm innocent... why, because he's still alive.

Doc, I hope you know.
Click to expand...

How can 2 people know your innocent? The Det might but no one else has investigating powers. Why would the Dr know you're innocent?

Why don't we put it to the test and see if the Dr saves you from a lynching.
 
he's claiming to be the snitch.... the rule says one of the mafia is the snitch and then Mad says it's not him. Then it says "The Snitch will PM rb a list of 4 names, their choosing, whenever he asks. At least one member of this list will be a Mafia member. These names will be worked into the night time story line. None of it has happened. Mad seems to be playing the same card played last game when 2 people claimed to be the detective.
 
I think it proves Mad is NOT Mafia!

Think of it this way. The Mafia don't know who the snitch is, but the snitch IS Mafia so they still want the Mafia to win. They name four players, one MUST be Mafia. Mad was the number two vote tonight, why would the snitch name someone we already suspect? I think we have a 1 in 3 choice on Mafia here, not one in 4. This almost clears Mad from my list in my mind. Thoughts?
 
Mark waves goodbye to most of the ACVille crew.. He tells them that this thread has taken to much of his time and has endagered things within his private life and that is where he needs to place his concentration.. He also says, its been real, but it hasn't been fun this time..

To all a good night...
 
mee-mee said:
I wasn't put on anyone's list at all, where do you find this list of the snitch's...



and remember this...
FOR THE FIRST 6 DAY/NIGHTS, THE DON WILL SHOW AS AN INNOCENT ON ANY INVESTIGATION OR UPON LYNCHING.

and if the Vig would have hit any of them it would have stated it..
Click to expand...

I don't think Mike was Don lol.

The rest were untimely or mafia hits
 
Here's a theory... just a theory for consideration

The snitch (who is still mafia) gave us a list of 4 players where three of them have so few posts that we have no way of making a valid judgment and another that is on several lists.

The snitch could very easily have turned to the rest of the mafia for help in making the list.

This list is tailor made to lynch Madcrawdad. I'm not saying he's automatically innocent, but anyone of those other three would be a perfect stealth mafia. Neither Jensons, nor KOTD post very much... ever. Mee-mee is almost uncharacteristically quiet as well.

I reall don't see mad as mafia.
 
OgreMkV said:
Here's a theory... just a theory for consideration

The snitch (who is still mafia) gave us a list of 4 players where three of them have so few posts that we have no way of making a valid judgment and another that is on several lists.

The snitch could very easily have turned to the rest of the mafia for help in making the list.

This list is tailor made to lynch Madcrawdad. I'm not saying he's automatically innocent, but anyone of those other three would be a perfect stealth mafia. Neither Jensons, nor KOTD post very much... ever. Mee-mee is almost uncharacteristically quiet as well.

I reall don't see mad as mafia.
Click to expand...

Bingo Ogre, I posted basically the same thing a few posts up.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom