Mafia 9: The Bloody Coup

i vote to lynch deputyJR.

that is an absolutely ridiculous reason to lynch, and all he is doing is following DD. Even if he is only following DD because he thinks she is innocent, following this early in the game does the citizens (i got it right this time) no good, you have to come up with your own thoughts, which he doesnt seem to be doing.
 
Cory Lover said:
Well HN, if you look at how I've played all other games....I'm pretty much playing the same here.

Ok, I'm gonna tell everyone how I play Mafia games so people don't keep pinning me for not putting that much info out. I post what some people would call 'nonsense posts' because I don't have any good info yet and I don't want to make stupid posts. I do that for what ever time is needed before I feel like I have some info, and when I feel like I have found a rebel/wolf/mafia then I start posting (look at the last game). And.....I do feel that I may have found one....Ogre. I have a very bad gut feeling about him....like I did with Mike and Mal in the last game. People I know are going to have a hissy fit that I'm not putting much reasoning behind my vote.....but thats how I play. I let my gut feelings, most times, decide who I am going to vote for.

I vote to lynch Ogre.

CL
Click to expand...
Cory everytime a wolf was lynched you posted "i had a gut feeling since the beginning about them". Your "gut feeling" about Mike came last game when there were four players left, and was a controversial after death post. There are now twenty players. You wants us to lynch Ogre because of a gut feeling??? I have a gut feeling that following you would end in disaster. If you wants us to follow you post "EVIDENCE" not "GUT FEELINGS". Much obliged.
 
charlie_stubbs said:
Cory everytime a wolf was lynched you posted "i had a gut feeling since the beginning about them". Your "gut feeling" about Mike came last game when there were four players left, and was a controversial after death post. There are now twenty players. You wants us to lynch Ogre because of a gut feeling??? I have a gut feeling that following you would end in disaster. If you wants us to follow you post "EVIDENCE" not "GUT FEELINGS". Much obliged.
Click to expand...

I'm not asking people to follow me. You do what you want. I'm just stating on who I feel is suspicious. Period.

CL
 
My list #166 and #190 weren't much of lists, but I'd like to reiterate them here.

Charlie - posting very differently
Mad - somewhat different too... may be due to work, I'm very curious as to what today will bring from him.
JOhnLarson - also posting differently and the list-that-wasn't

rb - somewhat redeemed himself... I hope he and zsand stick around a while, because I'm not taking notes.

There are a few players that are also posting somewhat differently, I won't name them because I want to see what happens and who does what when I mention it. But there are some players with excellent, well thought out posts... that normally don't have them. A little mentoring going on?
 
heres something else i found strange. Plantling took the whole "vote for noone" scenario by JL and turned it into a case against him. Are you trying to find rebels or eliminate citizens Plantling??? You seem to be trying to turn what i thought to be only slightly suspicious and stretch it into a case.
 
charlie_stubbs said:
my list now as it stands:
mee mee- overall defensiveness
deputy- quick to hop on trains, but doesnt seem to be trying to find any evidence
i dont have a solid third now, but emma lack of posting yet concerns me
Note: when i was mafia i asked for people lists all the time, as i wanted to know if i was on their list. Are you asking because you wanna see if your on any lists yet RB?
Click to expand...

Doesn't really matter if I am or not. Just want to see where everyone stands. I asked back in post #272 about more activity, noting that I myself had not proposed any names, and thought I would try to be more active today.

We have about 9 hours to get the CC's to agree on the most reasonable choice, whatever the reason. I have only played in one other game, and the mafia took me out the first night for whatever reason.

I think getting lists and exchanging info is the best way to play this type of game. Being controversial causes folks to slip up...just ask Hooked....
 
With so few folks posting today and the complications of a split rebel team, tonight ought to be interesting. It may be hard to see a trend to a reasonable choice for us and some of the heated arguements could just be the rebels convincing one another to improve their chances, including convincing the other to prevent a loss on their team.

Maybe we should shorten the lists so not as many names are out there...?
 
Okay....8 hours and counting.....

I vote to lynch mee-mee
 
ok, im going to put my vote in, subject to change if anything else comes up

i vote to lynch Joander
 
I'm going with my number 1 and will change it ONLY if it would be wasted and would matter to someone else high on my list.

I vote to lynch mee-mee
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom