Mafia #7 -- The Play

[Rbishop]

thru post 1030...

to lynch....

Hooked (5) by KOTD 938 plant 943 jpap 968 Deputy 939 Mad 969 joan 1029

joan (1) by Hook 945

mysplr (2) by charlie 929 jl66 926 wata 1028

10 of 12 have voted....

Night Fall at 8 PM EST, Tonight, Monday, 09/03...

PMs or e-mails as required, please....

 

[jpappy789]

My case for mee-mee...not great because few posts and even fewer with substance...

what vote do you have and what mafia slip ups...


not reading all the posts


agreeing with ice and saying it makes sense


skimming over posts, that is why you need to read carefully


he agrees with ice, but no vote..everything as it says in read from him
[/color]


but still no vote if he does believe it is a valid point made by Ice...


I vote for Jo...

it is either one or the either, you agree or disagree. it cant be onesided and then not decide to vote for someone...

First and only "quote case" is for jo night one...agree with most things said here.

game off///
wow, I will bet he is excited and so are you...have fun shopping with him...
game on///

you need to try and read all of the posts just so you can see what is going on and what is being said..skimming isnt going to help you any at all....for there could be things said that you might miss and it doesnt help us townies if you are just going to skim and not help us out any...

Response to jo's response...a little weak for someone who just built a case and voted

The only thing I ever noticed about Sway's posting was her saying she bought a convenience store (50), and then saying she apparently inherited a convenience store (88),,,that is the only thing I saw a little peculiar about her postings...

and when someone is accused of being Mafia and they know they aren't, they tend to very defensive, I know when I was Mafia in game 4 and the game prior to this, I really didn't defend myself very well.. and maybe her multilple posts was just ranting...

My vote still stays on Jo, for the reasons I had posted earlier.....

MeeMee stops by Sway's house to see how she is holding up, and Sway looks scared for some reason, MeeMee brings her some of her eclairs and it seems to put a smile back on Sway's face....Don't worry Sway, meemee says, Me and Chi will look after your goldfish, if you have to leave town so suddenly...

States that she is staying on jo

Here is my next top 2...(besides knowing Ice is a Mafia, from King investigating him)

Wata-for trying to keep Ice in the game, and seeming to defend him alot...
Sploke- knowing that Ice is Mafia (by way of King investigation) and putting a wasted vote on Z..

Many useless posts later (which I will not quote) she posts her first list. Notice how jo isn't even mentioned again and also who else is on that list...now I know that many people had sploke as mafia at some point and were very suspcious of wata for her doubting King, but come on...no one else mee-mee?

My list

Sploke--saying in an earlier post he doesnt try to get led around by the nose but does anyway...

JP-really not contributing by the list he put, no reasons for who he has

Names sploke as top suspect now and claims my list isn't any help...how much of a help are your lists mee-mee? All two of them...

So for that I vote to lynch Sploke as stated in my post 867

Then votes sploke. If I read your reason correctly, you voted Sploke because he is a follower even though he said he wasn't? Correct me if I'm wrong but kind of odd seeing as he was the only one to vote Zsand (who ended up mafia) and then voted you...

edit: none of my stuff was posted, only quotes...

 

[mystery player]

Originally Posted by mystery player
# 3 Interesting you should mention this, i think you have a bigger role in this game, perhaps the thief or the doc, Hummm...i do believe for the lives of the innocents you must go....

Oh, I understand, CS might be the thief or the doc, so the innocents should lynch him.

Good plan.

The first phrase was meant to be a question to CS, The second phrase {note the periods} was what i believe CS to be, Mafia, sorry for the confusion .....

MP's post 1019 is absolutely ridiculous. . . charlie might be the thief or doctor, so lynch him for the sake of the innocents? U.S. Americans don't know where South Africa is so let's take away their maps. What?

On the other hand, is there anything concrete (i.e. from Rb) that explicitly says the Thief is innocent? Maybe we are only looking for the Doctor.

I vote to lynch the Mystery Player

for being confusing, useless, misinformation-mongering mafia scum.

Ouch, harsh language coming from a townie ........

------------------------------------------------------------------------

After going through the post's and weighing the responses, imo HN is likely Mafia, it appeared to me him and Z were close, and he has been wiggling his way around questions put to him, with less than adequate answers imo, all things considered CS still concerns me, but i think HN has tipped the scales as Mafia, I vote to lynch Hooked Newbie ......

 

[johnlarson66]

Originally Posted by mystery player
# 3 Interesting you should mention this, i think you have a bigger role in this game, perhaps the thief or the doc, Hummm...i do believe for the lives of the innocents you must go....




The first phrase was meant to be a question to CS, The second phrase {note the periods} was what i believe CS to be, Mafia, sorry for the confusion .....

So the question should be:

Interesting you should mention this, i think you have a bigger role in this game, perhaps the thief or the doc, Hummm?

What phrase was supposed to be a question? {note the question mark}

I am glad to see that you are sorry for the confusion, but so far your explaination just adds to it.

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

man..this MP looks more and more mafia each time they post..

i feel confident with the HN votes..i just really hope he and the person i am investigating are mafia..

 

[jpappy789]

man..this MP looks more and more mafia each time they post..

i feel confident with the HN votes..i just really hope he and the person i am investigating are mafia..

KOTD I hope that you haven't forgotten that if you find the doc you can communicate with them. Just a reminder!

 

[johnlarson66]

KOTD I hope that you haven't forgotten that if you find the doc you can communicate with them. Just a reminder!

Since it is no secret that KOTD is the Detective, them communicating outside of the thread almost makes no sense.

The Doctor needs to protect KOTD.

Anything else can be said in the thread.

 

[jpappy789]

Since it is no secret that KOTD is the Detective, them communicating outside of the thread almost makes no sense.

The Doctor needs to protect KOTD.

Anything else can be said in the thread.

Good point.

 

[jpappy789]

My list in case I am not on for the rest of the night...

Hooked Newbie - 3
DeputyChiefJR - 4
mee-mee -4
Plantling- 5
mystery player-4
Charlie_Stubbs – 6
MadCrawdad - 7
Wataugachicken-10
KingOfTheDeep – 10
johnlarson66 - 10

 

[mee-mee]

I have been working very long hours...16-18 hours a day...old job going out and new job coming in...

And reading all of HN's posts he is way off.....

I vote for HN