Zombies -- Mafia #11

[Lady G]

Lady G and DeputyChiefJR posted within minutes of each other (three to be exact)!

Ahhh, yes we did...but it wasn't our first and only post of the game at that point, had it been I could see it being pointed out.

Alright folks, I've taken a close look at Lady G, and I've found some interesting things.
Yes you should take a close look at EVERYONE in this game Mad.Point 1

Some may recall that yesterday, BKW and I were exchanging posts. BKW voted for me claiming that he wanted some questions answered, but didn't ask any questions. As he didn't ask any questions, I didn't bother to respond...later he went on to say that I was scummy for not responding to his vote, I claimed he was scummy for voting without a real reason. Whatever.

The interesting thing to me, is how Lady G inserted herself into the exchange. Now keep in mind that anyone is free to jump into a conversation, and I always welcome discussion, so jumping in was not a problem. What interested me most was why she jumped in, and what she was saying. So here we go:
I didn't really "insert" myself into your exchange, I made mention that I asked a question and you replied...yes it was intended toward Bkw's post of you not responding to him, but I wasn't really inserting my self anywhere.

By this time BKW had voted for me to have questions answered, but asked no question. When he finally asked a question, I responded. He said I should have responded to the vote (without the question), I said it didn't make sense to respond when there was no question to respond to....Whatever.

Here's where Lady G jumps in.....Looks like she agrees with me, a question should have been asked if BKW wanted a response. She then goes on to dispute something else I said about being scum the last time BKW and I played together.


I explain that she misunderstood my post...


Here she understands that she misunderstood my earlier post. Goes on to apparently agree with me in the discussion that BKW had earlier...If you want an answer, ask a question.

Now BKW calls her on her response, and claims she never really asked a question.

Lady G responds to BKW saying 'yeah, I technically didn't ask a question, and it is weird that Madcrawdad didn't respond to the vote you cast for no reason..' Huh?
No I didn't say I technically didn't ask a question, you need to re read that one Mad I said it wasn't really in the form of a question "why did you say that" kind of a question but it was a question non the less and you answered it, it even had ? at the end. Please don't twist my meaning to try and make it fit your off base comment.

Whose side is Lady G really on in this discussion between myself and BKW? Whose side is not the real question, but why does she seem to be standing in the middle and flicking bits of scum in both directions?
I wasn't standing in the middle, I made a statement bkw responded to my statement I wouldn't really call that "standing in the middle" of anything. And at this point in time I am on my side, but if you looked at my posts you should know who came out on top of that whole scenario..let's see I had BKW on my list and not you so you tell me, how was that misread?

By this time our discussion had ended, and BKW even posted a little smiley face...maybe as if to say 'all is well between us'? But Lady G seems to be blowing on embers and trying to get something started. Why?

Point 2
Here's the same quote I used earlier, but I'm reposting it to make my second point.

Here she says that she would personally ask if someone voted for her for no reason. What if someone voted for you and gave a bogus reason, Lady G? Would you be interested?
I did not respond to DC because well even though it was a stupid reason, which I may of used later..at this time I saw no reason to bring attention upon it...it he had just said I vote Lady G I would of asked "may I ask why"

Here DC casts a vote for Lady G because she's fooled him in past games. Clearly an anti-town move on DC's part. Past games have absolutely no bearing on this game...
Agreed but so many do this, "Oh Mad isn't posting like normal he must be evil" not that I really think that at this point just an example.

Here's Lady G's response to DC's vote for her...not a very strong response.
It wasn't a very strong reason didn't deserve a strong response I figured others would realize it was weak to say the least, why bother?

Now in this quote she goes after Ogre for basically saying that he'd consider lynching Coler, because Coler would be dangerous to the town as a zombie. Keep in mind that DC said basically the same thing about Lady G (and even voted for her) that Ogre did about Coler. So why's she just picking out Ogre and floating his name out there as possible scum? DC never makes it onto her list of suspicious players, but now Ogre's her top candidate. Somethings just not right.
Yes and there was more to it then just he said that, and yes I believe that is a good reason to add him to my "list". DC hasn't made it there yet, simply because he has done nothing but make a nonsense vote at this time, which like I said I do not believe others would take in consideration to vote me...it's not really a good argument IMO.
I'm not saying that Ogre shouldn't be on her list, mind you, I'm saying that based on her reasoning, DC should be there also.

Ummm not really Mad, as I stated before there is alot more on Ogre than DC at this point in time. Are you mad because I didn't get all defencive at DC for that??? I saw no reason it wasn't worth the time and effort it would take.

IMO, Lady G is the best candidate for scum that I've seen all day...

I vote to lynch Lady G

If you really think I am the best candidate from what you have posted, so be it vote me, by all means you should vote who you think is evil. IMO it's pretty weak.

 

[Lady G]

My top three:

ewurm - for being a Vikings fan, living that close to Canada
Lady G - for bouncing all over the place with her posts
DeputyChiefJR - for posting 3 minutes after leaving Lady G's bedroom

It is day one.

I think I have made my thoughts about day one before. I have used the word random before and have caught lots of slack. This is a day of learning.

I have voted, was it random, no. For whatever reason, no one has role played yet. I voted ewurm, mostly because I think he has a sense of humor and has gotten a good grasp on the game. I am surprised he voted back at me.

At this point, I see no one as jumping out as a zombie and do not think we will. ewurm is as good as a target as anyone else. We are all pretty much suspects at this time. Someone has to go. Whoever it is, I hope we learn from it.

I bounce all over the place...true enough but isn't that better than picking one person putting blinders on and not looking anywhere else?

 

[Swayde]

No votes yet from Charlie, DD, Guppy, Jpap and KoTD. We only have 7 hours until nightfall. It's going to hurt us badly to lose that many people early on this game. We really cannot afford to lose townies for lack of voting/participation. This game is going to be very difficult for us to win, especially if we start off down several townies because clearly they can't all be zombies.

I seriously don't know who to vote for. So many people are looking kinda suspicious, but nothing that just screams evil out to me. All the power roles in the game really do make it confusing and then trying to pick 2 people out of 15 is hard too. I'd think the zombies would be trying not to draw attention to themselves and hope to float a few days with minimal interaction while more people get converted and townies lynch each other or die to lack of voting.

Anyhow, I am keeping my vote on Jpappy for now. He was the last person to post and I don't like that little but he had hanging on at the end of his post, which most likely would have gone totally unnoticed had he not tried to brush it off with a follow-up post.

 

[Dangerdoll]

I was trying to wait to see if there were going tobe anymore interesting and/or suspicious clues that we can be more sure about before going and finalizing my vote, I was in no way planning on not putting a vote in. After all, there is still 7 hours (about) to the nite. Why so pushy for the votes, sway?

If it will make you feel any better, I will enter my top suspect as listed above.

I vote to lynch Ogre

 

[Lady G]

Well, I too think votes need to be out there, so for now I am going to vote to lynch JL

My ewurm vote has generated a pay-back vote.

hmmm.....

Seems zombish to me.

Either way, it is just day one.

I hate this kind of statement, they way this game is set up I believe day 1 and day 2 may be the most important day of voting for the townies...we risk to loose alot for voting "just because it's day one it doesn't matter"

Lady G and DeputyChiefJR posted within minutes of each other (three to be exact)!

Being cynical, yes I made mention as did Swayde of him and Jpap posting within minutes of each other, but failing to acknowledge it was mentioned b/c they hadn't posted at all and was their only post's at the time.

My top three:

ewurm - for being a Vikings fan, living that close to Canada
Lady G - for bouncing all over the place with her posts
DeputyChiefJR - for posting 3 minutes after leaving Lady G's bedroom

It is day one.

I think I have made my thoughts about day one before. I have used the word random before and have caught lots of slack. This is a day of learning.

I have voted, was it random, no. For whatever reason, no one has role played yet. I voted ewurm, mostly because I think he has a sense of humor and has gotten a good grasp on the game. I am surprised he voted back at me.

At this point, I see no one as jumping out as a zombie and do not think we will. ewurm is as good as a target as anyone else. We are all pretty much suspects at this time. Someone has to go. Whoever it is, I hope we learn from it.

For adding me b/c I "jump" all over the place, which yes I do...but like I said MUCH better than putting on blinders and only looking at one person.

 

[Lady G]

Before I go, I just want it to be know I may/may not change my vote...I just want to state this so when/if I do, it won't be that I am "jumping" around it will be b/c someone else seems better to me at that point.

 

[Swayde]

I was trying to wait to see if there were going tobe anymore interesting and/or suspicious clues that we can be more sure about before going and finalizing my vote, I was in no way planning on not putting a vote in. After all, there is still 7 hours (about) to the nite. Why so pushy for the votes, sway?

If it will make you feel any better, I will enter my top suspect as listed above.

I vote to lynch Ogre

Because last game we lost 3 townies right off the bat because they did not vote on day one and I would hate to see that happen again. Votes can be changed, but you HAVE to have a vote in on someone so it's important to get at least something out there.

Reading through the rules it seems like this is going to be very hard for us to win and we're definitely going to need all of the townies working together and contributing. Losing several on day 1, especially avoidable ones, is just plain bad. We will absolutely lose 1 today because either the zombies will turn them, or we get insanely lucky and lynch the person the zombies try to change... most likely we lose 2 since odds are that we'll lynch a townie and the zombies will turn a townie...no reason to lose more than that. Just trying to make sure people realize the danger in not voting and how badly it will affect us.

 

[OgreMkV]

ewurm - for being a Vikings fan, living that close to Canada
Lady G - for bouncing all over the place with her posts
DeputyChiefJR - for posting 3 minutes after leaving Lady G's bedroom

At this point, I see no one as jumping out as a zombie and do not think we will. ewurm is as good as a target as anyone else. We are all pretty much suspects at this time. Someone has to go. Whoever it is, I hope we learn from it.

Wow, I think everyone else noticed at least a few zombie like things. I agree with you, but I think that the statement in blue is... odd. I didn't say wrong, just odd.

Alright folks, I've taken a close look at Lady G, and I've found some interesting things.

Now in this quote she goes after Ogre for basically saying that he'd consider lynching Coler, because Coler would be dangerous to the town as a zombie. Keep in mind that DC said basically the same thing about Lady G (and even voted for her) that Ogre did about Coler. So why's she just picking out Ogre and floating his name out there as possible scum? DC never makes it onto her list of suspicious players, but now Ogre's her top candidate. Somethings just not right.

I'm not saying that Ogre shouldn't be on her list, mind you, I'm saying that based on her reasoning, DC should be there also.

IMO, Lady G is the best candidate for scum that I've seen all day...

I like this for not only LadyG, but also DC. Notice I never voted for Coler, I wasn't planning to. I know I'd never get a prayer of getting the votes for that one, but also, he is a good player with lots of ideas... and if he's zombie, then we'll figure it out soon enough.

DC however, goes ahead and votes that with his gut in that direction.

So my top four candidates are
JL
LadyG
DC
DD - I think that she's kind of riding coattails again... something like she has been doing in the past as a bad guy.

for what it's worth.

I'd also like to point out something. I'm still not sure if this is good or bad for the town. Everyone is on their own track. I think only myself and JL have more than 1 vote. So everyone is thinking on their own and coming up with their own reasons... that's a good thing.

However, with the voting like this, the zombies can pretty much take out who they want with only one vote change (maybe two vote changes). That's bad.

If I am lynched, then (for the record) I do not think that Coler is a zombie at this point. I also like mad, sway, and ice as innocents.

BTW: This is valid for today only... stupid zombies.

 

[OgreMkV]

Guys, just so you know we'll lose at the end of the day (after the lynch) on day three if we do not hit a zombie before then. We basically have 3 chances to hit one.

Good
Bad
13
2
-2 (lynch & zombie turn)

+1 turn 1 11
3
-2 (lynch and zombie turn)

+1 turn 2 9
4
-1 (lynch)


turn 3 8 4 half the town is zombie, we lose.

 

[OgreMkV]

stupid excel