Mafia #12

[Hooked Newbie]

The towns plan of lynching RB was in question before nightfall. I can try to post when I started to distrust it. That is why I (an others) did not pull our vote off of ewurm.

Even if the town lynches judgemax, I still think the town will win. We will know for a fact if HN is telling the truth or not. I think he has just bought more time.

I am staying on sovran. If the town and mafia want to make it sovran vs judgemax and if one of those two are lynched, then I think we will be fine.

I could be wrong about sovran and HN. I will be curious if there is not a mad push to save judgemax for the next day and lynch rbishop first.

I think ZSandmann said it, if you trust HN vote for judgemax, if you do not trust HN, vote sovran.

I think there only 2 left. It is either HN and Sovran or judgemax and rbishop.

Does this seem contradictory to anyone else? Again, I'll vote for Rb but find Jmax a safer target. We need consensus too.

To each of you, who would you investigate and why?

 

[Hooked Newbie]

How is JL still watching the thread if he is on a plane?

The same way he forgot which timezone he was in and what time he had to be at the airport?

 

[Swayde]

The same way he forgot which timezone he was in and what time he had to be at the airport?

Between that and the fact every time it looks like people stop following what his plan is he keeps coming back and posting even though he keeps stressing that he's GOT to go...really makes me think...mafia scumbag.

Could be Ewurm, Mee-Mee, Judgemax, Rbiship and Johnlarson...I do think that it would be an interesting team since JL seems to think that is such a huge clue. Sovran could have just been an easy target with most people not really knowing how she plays.

I'm willing to go with RB or JM.

 

[Swayde]

Votes so far:

3 for RB = Swayde, Zsand, DD
2 for Sov = JM & JL
1 for JM = HN
1 for HN = Sov

No vote from Rbiship

 

[judgemax]

Actually it was very inconvenient and I'm really not concerned about YOUR opinion anymore. Sorry.

I am really Disappointed that you would sink this low, ..WHY ARE YOU BEGGING THE DOC TO SAVE YOU? If your hit, then everyone would know what the truth was, I think its all just a plan. Its a coniving one, but a plan at that, what worries me is they actually believe you, ..you who actually voted charlie over the don, late in the eve.

At this point, I trust HN more than I do JL. I may be crazy for it, we'll see. I'm going with instinct right about now and have a feeling HN is telling the truth. I'm still kind of worried about that timing and all though and I still am convinced that RB is mafia. Could JL and HN be a team, sure, but I think the real detective would have spoken up by now, it's clearly not JM, I know it's not me and it doesn't seem to be DD or Z, it could be RB, but if HN was mafia that would be truly stupid to do that because RB would likely be getting lynched, all he'd have to do is place his vote. If it was Sovran, I think she would have spilled it by now and if it was JL, well don't think HN would have been so stupid again as to claim it when it's not him especially if he had any thought that it could be the person taunting him to come out.

ALl that really does make sense to me, but I just woke up from a nap so if it's fuzzy logic, sorry.

I understand your dilemma, however, please understand, that he has bought himself another night, if you all let him live. If you want to vote me, go ahead, I have said through out the game that I did not trust him, and he has yet to answer half my questions, ..think about this, just for a minute, he has called on every one else to help the town, but if you actually look at most of his posts, they aren't near as helpful as you might think. I also want to point out, that when night fell many times, he was very aggressive, pushing these innocents to their death. I know this is shocking, but seriously, I even followed him. I am not saying I am the detective, but I do have a few good suspicions, and I am pretty sure, that the doc didn't save him. If you go back and look, you should be able to see who they did save, and who the doc is, ..Yes he knows who the doc is, how the hell do you think?..and he can claim he investigated anyone, DD looks clear lets name her innocent, and JM, has a little guilt lets name her guilty. worked well enough for him to get away with out scrutiny...doesn't it?...which is what he has been getting away with throughout the whole game, he has sat and thrown stones, and been a big part of the nights debacles, ...If you believe me fine, if not, please go look for yourselves.

I have to go but will be back on before night.


I unvote sov, and vote to lynch HN

 

[Swayde]

So we need to make a decision. Z, DD and I need to either all jump to JM, or HN needs to come to RB with us...I'm game for either. Sov, if you are innocent, you need to choose someone to believe because we really can't afford a townie going it alone.

 

[judgemax]

Between that and the fact every time it looks like people stop following what his plan is he keeps coming back and posting even though he keeps stressing that he's GOT to go...really makes me think...mafia scumbag.

Could be Ewurm, Mee-Mee, Judgemax, Rbiship and Johnlarson...I do think that it would be an interesting team since JL seems to think that is such a huge clue. Sovran could have just been an easy target with most people not really knowing how she plays.

I'm willing to go with RB or JM.

I am not going to threaten and say youll be sorry, its childish. but please do stop and think about what your going to do.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Between that and the fact every time it looks like people stop following what his plan is he keeps coming back and posting even though he keeps stressing that he's GOT to go...really makes me think...mafia scumbag.

Could be Ewurm, Mee-Mee, Judgemax, Rbiship and Johnlarson...I do think that it would be an interesting team since JL seems to think that is such a huge clue. Sovran could have just been an easy target with most people not really knowing how she plays.

I'm willing to go with RB or JM.

I'm liking that list quite alot.

JL has been putting a ton of emphasis on 2 things... Ogre's opening game comment and Ewurm's list.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Votes so far:

3 for RB = Swayde, Zsand, DD
2 for Sov = JM & JL
1 for JM = HN
1 for HN = Sov

No vote from Rbiship

I'll move to Rb if that's the consensus of those I still trust.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I am really Disappointed that you would sink this low, ..WHY ARE YOU BEGGING THE DOC TO SAVE YOU? If your hit, then everyone would know what the truth was, I think its all just a plan. Its a coniving one, but a plan at that, what worries me is they actually believe you, ..you who actually voted charlie over the don, late in the eve.




I understand your dilemma, however, please understand, that he has bought himself another night, if you all let him live. If you want to vote me, go ahead, I have said through out the game that I did not trust him, and he has yet to answer half my questions, ..think about this, just for a minute, he has called on every one else to help the town, but if you actually look at most of his posts, they aren't near as helpful as you might think. I also want to point out, that when night fell many times, he was very aggressive, pushing these innocents to their death. I know this is shocking, but seriously, I even followed him. I am not saying I am the detective, but I do have a few good suspicions, and I am pretty sure, that the doc didn't save him. If you go back and look, you should be able to see who they did save, and who the doc is, ..Yes he knows who the doc is, how the hell do you think?..and he can claim he investigated anyone, DD looks clear lets name her innocent, and JM, has a little guilt lets name her guilty. worked well enough for him to get away with out scrutiny...doesn't it?...which is what he has been getting away with throughout the whole game, he has sat and thrown stones, and been a big part of the nights debacles, ...If you believe me fine, if not, please go look for yourselves.

I have to go but will be back on before night.


I unvote sov, and vote to lynch HN

Good attempt. I'll say it again, ask me the questions you want answers to. IF you were a townie, why not go with the town's plan and cast a revenge vote? I tend to think I'll catch a few votes and that you all (a.k.a. Mafia scumbags) will try to sway an innocent to your side since the Doc can only protect against hits and not lynchings.