Mafia #13 - The Witches of ACville- the play

[Rbishop]

I did vote for plant RB

Sorry, you are right....it is lady that has not voted....

 

[IceH2O]

Wow! Some early votes already. Though Ice and Lady G do seem to know a bit about witches. Hmmmm...

If I was witchy I don't think I'd throw out a list like that and be so obvious.

You're making my list is more for the following posts:

You just signed on and therefore just got your PM or you got your PM late?

I'm not even sure what you're insinuating here. Why would RB forget to PM KOTD and even if he did why would KOTD wait 4 hours to PM Rb asking for it?

Alright, just some notes of interest:

Ice saying he'll vote for low posters in post 11, then in post 28 he votes for Lady G.

Throwing suspicion my way early.

Lady G is all over the place again and maybe kicking in doors but also accusing someone of not noticing her misspelling is a bit strange as she misspells all the time.



Charlie, the chicken-choker seems to be kicking in doors as well, but is chicken choker a promotion from shoe-shine boy?

This makes you suspicious?

JMax, who has been questioned many times about her supposed thoughts but still yet to appear w/ an answer.


That's all for now, have to go fix and have lunch and the kids have been wanting to go to the park. BBL w/more thoughts. Hopefully the other newbie will have posted by then.

For now just for vote=reaction=answers sake, I vote to burn Ice at the stake, subject to change.

Interesting that you would think I was on a team w/King just because I questioned the timing of his post. I was the second to comment on his arrival, so really, why would I wanna draw more attention to his showing up late if he were in cahoots w/me? Glad you finally shared your suspicions with us, though.

Throwing suspicion on JM, JMs posting has been a little off but not to the point I think she is hiding anything.

I knew it was your philosophy when I voted you. I was just wondering why you voted for who is prolly the highest poster when in fact you had said you'd do the opposite. No worries as my vote will most likely change also.




Watch it Jmax, it's words like these that got you in trouble last game, so if you are indeed a townie, then you'd best align yourself w/us by using US's and WE's.

Again throwing suspicion at JM

A feeling eh? After I got your answer about why you voted for Lady G when you had said otherwise I had you leaning innocent as well as those on your list, but does this "feeling" have anything to do w/something you've been brewing?

games 4,5, and 12, I believe. I'm not stalking you I just have a weird memory. It's been ages, but while in France I was able to utilize French I'd learned in highschool.

Ice, I was going to change my vote but the more you post the more I think you may indeed be witchy. Ogre, Z, and Lady G are indeed good players and does look like a list that the witch's may want gone. I suppose I'm on there because I voted for you and even though it was just for a reaction, it must have hit a nerve. A witchy nerve.

Aa I pointed out earlier in the post it has nothing to do with your vote on me.

I don't care about 1st day votes on myself. I wouldn't panic because of your vote and weak reasoning for that vote.

I haven't lasted long in any of the past few games. I have nothing to lose by throwing out lists and suspicions.

All I ask is that the townies watch their posts, the witches seem a bit more aggressive this round so I'm leaning it to better players. They are all moderate to high posters so having them lay low isn't an option.

I don't care if my lists contain the better players. Just because they are the top tier doesn't mean they are all innocent. If anything because they are top players their posts should be taken with a grain of salt until they are known innocents.

 

[IceH2O]

Sorry.I missed the top quote.

Wow! Some early votes already. Though Ice and Lady G do seem to know a bit about witches. Hmmmm...

Wanted to point out one of her 1st posts are already throwing suspicion my way. I know she mentions LG also but it could be distancing.

 

[jpappy789]

just come home from a long day out plus part of the evening at theme park as october has fright nights throughout the month, and i have you 'll never believe been dressed as a witch. by putting myself in this position all day under the watchfull eye of hundreds of people have discovered that by looking the obvious you are often ignored....so are the understated often the under estimated

I am trying to figure out what this post meant...epsecially the lat part in red

bluerat is now on my list because I can't figure out what this post means and why the heck it was posted

My list...I will probably be grilled for including both newbs but I don't really care because its all I got...and no particular order...

bluerat- reason above
brk- a newb but vote for Chas out of left field is quite troubling
DC- I usually have to jump on him at some point so why not now didn't really like his first post directed towards lady g because all he had to do was read...then he realized his mistake and agreed with everyone about jm's posting trying to appear friendly
DD- posting differently than other games and isn't even being questioned by a lot of people yet, but nothing else is different so if anything dd just needs further watching imo
lady g- see below...

I know this sounds really paranoid but for some reason the whole warlock thing bothers me in this post...the warlock is on the towns side lady g...not part of the coven...did you not read the rules or was this a tiny slip?

Well, if she sticks with it and doesn't look elsewhere THEN I would worry more about her reasoning, but at this time for a day 1 vote I did think it was a cleaver little post. Of coarse all this also depends on if you end up seeming innocent or warlock too...woudn't that be ironic if she pulled this post off and you were a warlock:

 

[ZSandmann]

Ogre and Z more or less for how they are on Brk.

9 times out of 10 we lynch a newb and they are innocent. They make themselves look guilty because they are inexperienced posters. If they are in fact witches they will continue to mess up and we can get them later. Less chance of them leading the town against us.

Not trying to blow heat off of him. B could very well be witch and I could be wrong about Z and Ogre.

It could also be newbie jitters on Bs part and Ogre and Z find him easy pickings.



Nope just a gut, thought I'd throw a list out to get reactions.

I don't really know what to think of Brk to be honest. I'm not going to vote for him on Day 1, I would like to see how he plays both for the benefit of this round and the future games he may play in. But you can't say that room comment didn't send some kind of tingle your way.

 

[plantling]

Sorry.I missed the top quote.



Wanted to point out one of her 1st posts are already throwing suspicion my way. I know she mentions LG also but it could be distancing.

Ice, the post you quoted w/a lot of names were just "notes of interest" while I was reading through the thread. It clearly got to you and JMax a little more than the others. And LG was on that list also, so think what you want about it being distancing.

I am trying to figure out what this post meant...epsecially the lat part in red

bluerat is now on my list because I can't figure out what this post means and why the heck it was posted

My list...I will probably be grilled for including both newbs but I don't really care because its all I got...and no particular order...

bluerat- reason above
brk- a newb but vote for Chas out of left field is quite troubling
DC- I usually have to jump on him at some point so why not now didn't really like his first post directed towards lady g because all he had to do was read...then he realized his mistake and agreed with everyone about jm's posting trying to appear friendly
DD- posting differently than other games and isn't even being questioned by a lot of people yet, but nothing else is different so if anything dd just needs further watching imo
lady g- see below...

I know this sounds really paranoid but for some reason the whole warlock thing bothers me in this post...the warlock is on the towns side lady g...not part of the coven...did you not read the rules or was this a tiny slip?

Good catch, Jp. As I stated earlier, I think the Warlock is a townie and why would Lady G assume that they were evil?

 

[Lady G]

Here is a post that is bugging me.

I have bolded the part that strikes me as suspicious.

King has already been unreceptive to Sways vote, and as far as first day random voting goes, it's not bad.

Now Lady seems to aknowledge it's not bad, but goes out of her way to suggest there isn't anything witchy about King. She fails to point out there isn't anything innocent about him either.

I just wanted to comment...ummm so? I saw nothing suspicious and didn't want it to look like I did at that point, so what?

Alright, just some notes of interest:

Ice saying he'll vote for low posters in post 11, then in post 28 he votes for Lady G.

Lady G is all over the place again and maybe kicking in doors but also accusing someone of not noticing her misspelling is a bit strange as she misspells all the time.

Charlie, the chicken-choker seems to be kicking in doors as well, but is chicken choker a promotion from shoe-shine boy?

JMax, who has been questioned many times about her supposed thoughts but still yet to appear w/ an answer.

That's all for now, have to go fix and have lunch and the kids have been wanting to go to the park. BBL w/more thoughts. Hopefully the other newbie will have posted by then.

For now just for vote=reaction=answers sake, I vote to burn Ice at the stake, subject to change.

For one I don't think I have really been all over the place, so not sure where that came from. Also I find it odd that you mention 3 different ppl here but vote for someone not on your "suspisions"? I agree w/ question answer theory but....it just seemed odd in this post. Also did you read the posting that lead up to the mis spelling comment???

i forgot to add question. you questioned deputychiefjr and lynched on ice. who are both seem innocent to me right now.

i am in my room myself. didnt post sooner cus i wasnt sure of what to do.

gotta go get ready for work. but i have mobile internet on my phone so i may be here. ttyl

Ok, I wasn't going to pick on you much the first day b/c of you being new and all, but this just jumped out at me and I HAVE to say something here. I highlighted the part I found "odd" now typing mistakes happen (believe me I do my share and get reamed for it) but where you ready to say Ice and Dep ARE innocent???
Hmmm...this just doesn't sit well w/ me B.

well, since no one is posting, I am going to play in my fish tank.

I just added this cause well, I wanted to ask how is the tank coming along!

Not trying to blow heat off of him. B could very well be witch and I could be wrong about Z and Ogre.
It could also be newbie jitters on Bs part and Ogre and Z find him easy pickings.
But, you couldn't be wrong about the others?? Ice I just find it interesting that you say you could be wrong about Z and Ogre..but not any of the others why these 2?

Nope just a gut, thought I'd throw a list out to get reactions.

If I was witchy I don't think I'd throw out a list like that and be so obvious.

You're making my list is more for the following posts:






I'm not even sure what you're insinuating here. Why would RB forget to PM KOTD and even if he did why would KOTD wait 4 hours to PM Rb asking for it?





Again throwing suspicion at JM






Aa I pointed out earlier in the post it has nothing to do with your vote on me.

I don't care about 1st day votes on myself. I wouldn't panic because of your vote and weak reasoning for that vote.

I haven't lasted long in any of the past few games. I have nothing to lose by throwing out lists and suspicions.

All I ask is that the townies watch their posts, the witches seem a bit more aggressive this round so I'm leaning it to better players. They are all moderate to high posters so having them lay low isn't an option.
And you know who the witches are how Ice???

I don't care if my lists contain the better players. Just because they are the top tier doesn't mean they are all innocent. If anything because they are top players their posts should be taken with a grain of salt until they are known innocents.

And with this post I would like to add Plant to my list. I can't shake the whole post to KOTD about his pm that is my biggest thing...I know it doesn't seem like much. Then added to that is the post where she say's I've been all over the place...yes I know most 1st day's I am and before the day is over I will of most likely seen something odd by each person, but at that point really I hadn't been. Then the whole bringing up the "mis spelling" posting between Sploke and I, if she had read what lead up to that she should of known what was going on...nothing really to note, just a little 1st day fun. Lastly she makes a list of who she feels is suspisious, but vote for someone else?? Ice has posted alot so far and I really see the "getting answers" vote as more for low posters JMO.

And for now I am going to vote to burn Plant at the stake.

 

[Lady G]

I am trying to figure out what this post meant...epsecially the lat part in red

bluerat is now on my list because I can't figure out what this post means and why the heck it was posted

My list...I will probably be grilled for including both newbs but I don't really care because its all I got...and no particular order...

bluerat- reason above
brk- a newb but vote for Chas out of left field is quite troubling
DC- I usually have to jump on him at some point so why not now didn't really like his first post directed towards lady g because all he had to do was read...then he realized his mistake and agreed with everyone about jm's posting trying to appear friendly
DD- posting differently than other games and isn't even being questioned by a lot of people yet, but nothing else is different so if anything dd just needs further watching imo
lady g- see below...

I know this sounds really paranoid but for some reason the whole warlock thing bothers me in this post...the warlock is on the towns side lady g...not part of the coven...did you not read the rules or was this a tiny slip?

Ok, Charlie the whole warlock thing was simply that a male witch is usually called a warlock, I wasn't meaning it and didn't think of others as thinking I meant he was the warlock. Sorry about that guy's I can see why it would bother you though Charlie.

 

[Lady G]

Ok, Charlie the whole warlock thing was simply that a male witch is usually called a warlock, I wasn't meaning it and didn't think of others as thinking I meant he was the warlock. Sorry about that guy's I can see why it would bother you though Charlie.

Edit: Man I hate you can't edit...that should be Jpap!

 

[ZSandmann]

Hehehehe Lady just can't get Charlie off her mind. I think you have competition DD.