Mafia #13 - The Witches of ACville- the play

[Dangerdoll]

of course you do, you still have yet to be specific as to why you suspect me. I am trying to weed you witches out, judge and it seems I've already hit a nerve, huh.... of course you want me out.... now lets hear it for your reason.

 

[Dangerdoll]

Ogre and Z more or less for how they are on Brk.

9 times out of 10 we lynch a newb and they are innocent. They make themselves look guilty because they are inexperienced posters. If they are in fact witches they will continue to mess up and we can get them later. Less chance of them leading the town against us.

Ice as far as B is concerned, I still think that the fact he voted for charlie in one post and rushed back to state reasons is indicative of people behind the scenes (witch group) telling him to go back and give reasons before he is suspected. You don't think this is so? Your post makes me think you are trying to blow the heat off of him..... am I sensing correctly?

 

[plantling]

You are the Warlock. While you belive in your craft, you are not part of the coven and you are doing your best to learn how to cast spells. You just have problems with getting things right, sometimes. You have three spells at your disposal. You must use them on Nights 2, 3 and 4.

At the beginning of day 2, 3 and 4, you will PM me on who one of the spells will be used on. You even get to pick the spell. Spell #1 - doubles the vote of one person that night. Spell #2 - Converts a witch to a townie or a townie to witch, after the affects of that night. Spell #3 - forces a player to not vote at all and not have any consequences happen.


I was looking at the Warlocks role. I 1st assumed since they were warlock they were evil. But look at the bolded spell. This could be used against the witches.

Spell 2 states it could switch witch to townie. If the Warlock was evil why switch witch to townie? It couldn't be accidental since they would know who was innocent and/or witch.


Spell 1 and 3 could be used to either teams advantage.

I think that the Warlock is much like the labworker. They are a townie but get to choose the vial they wants to use as well as on whom. I think vials 1 and 3 are less dangerous than vial 2 which should only be used on a known evil.

 

[plantling]

How about this for an early list. No particular order since I think they are all in the Coven of Witches.

Plant
DD
Z
LG
Ogre

For some reason I just can't shake this feeling.

A feeling eh? After I got your answer about why you voted for Lady G when you had said otherwise I had you leaning innocent as well as those on your list, but does this "feeling" have anything to do w/something you've been brewing?

 

[judgemax]

of course you do, you still have yet to be specific as to why you suspect me. I am trying to weed you witches out, judge and it seems I've already hit a nerve, huh.... of course you want me out.... now lets hear it for your reason.

you, my dear, must not read, i gave my reasons in my prior posts, when I listed who I thought was a witch, I am also saying now, I think you are, because you are being very aggressive, and touchy, because I mentioned your name. You are holding last game against me, and are acting very guilty, ..its simple IMHO, if you can push me out the door right away, ..thats one innocent down, and you can use the excuse that I acted guilty, ..because I made an excuse, however, a lot of you inquired as to why I had not responded immediately to your posts, ..which is why I gave the excuse.

 

[Dangerdoll]

oooooh judge, you are doing terrible. The thing I am looking for is specific reasons. Not just the blanket post of "the more I read your posts". What in particular is giving you false senses. Maybe you should stop posting now though... seems you're not doing yourself any good.

As far as holding you to last game, nope, I just simple stated what happened last game. Your reactions today and of recent in this thread are what's drwing me to be more sure that you are hording black cats.

 

[IceH2O]

Ice as far as B is concerned, I still think that the fact he voted for charlie in one post and rushed back to state reasons is indicative of people behind the scenes (witch group) telling him to go back and give reasons before he is suspected. You don't think this is so? Your post makes me think you are trying to blow the heat off of him..... am I sensing correctly?

Not trying to blow heat off of him. B could very well be witch and I could be wrong about Z and Ogre.

It could also be newbie jitters on Bs part and Ogre and Z find him easy pickings.

A feeling eh? After I got your answer about why you voted for Lady G when you had said otherwise I had you leaning innocent as well as those on your list, but does this "feeling" have anything to do w/something you've been brewing?

Nope just a gut, thought I'd throw a list out to get reactions.

 

[judgemax]

oooooh judge, you are doing terrible. The thing I am looking for is specific reasons. Not just the blanket post of "the more I read your posts". What in particular is giving you false senses. Maybe you should stop posting now though... seems you're not doing yourself any good.

As far as holding you to last game, nope, I just simple stated what happened last game. Your reactions today and of recent in this thread are what's drwing me to be more sure that you are hording black cats.

LOL, ok, well, we will see, when you are a witch.

 

[OgreMkV]

I just want it noted that if I do change my vote, because it is early, it willl probably be onto BrkD. The more I think about him coming back with 2 reasons for voting Charlie so quickly, the more I think he is witchy.

Agree. Hey Ice, you forgot to include DD on the anti-newbie thing.

Ogre and Z more or less for how they are on Brk.

Find another good target... that's more than a feeling.

9 times out of 10 we lynch a newb and they are innocent. They make themselves look guilty because they are inexperienced posters. If they are in fact witches they will continue to mess up and we can get them later. Less chance of them leading the town against us.

This is very suspicious. It's almost exactly like a 'don't kill the known bad guy', instead, ignore tham and try to find more bad guys.... which is a terrible strategy.

This post strikes me as very anti-town.

Not trying to blow heat off of him. B could very well be witch and I could be wrong about Z and Ogre.

You are, but look what happened last game.

It could also be newbie jitters on Bs part and Ogre and Z find him easy pickings.

Nope just a gut, thought I'd throw a list out to get reactions.

Here's a reaction... notice how Ice's list includes the better players. This would be a great list for a witch to throw out, it includes myself, DD, Z... some of the better investigators.

Besides, I've only made like four posts. How can you get a feeling on me?

I was about to change to Br... but now, I'm thinking Ice might get my vote. He appears to be very anti-town.

 

[Sploke]

9 times out of 10 we lynch a newb and they are innocent. They make themselves look guilty because they are inexperienced posters.

I agree with this idea, B is coming across as a newer player, but not necessarily guilty to me yet. I remember when I was new and made a few jokes about something and suddenly I was like number one suspect, so it takes some experience to figure out what you can and can't say without triggering everyone's very sensitive triggers, especially on day one when we have no information.

you are being very aggressive, and touchy, because I mentioned your name. You are holding last game against me, and are acting very guilty

( this was from JM directed at DD) While I hate to agree with JM at this point, DD is coming across with a much bolder playing style than I have seen from her in the past. Before, she was always a suspect for low posting and kiind of hanging back and only coming forward when called out...her style has gotten a bit more overt than that now, which makes me suspicious.

Also, JM seems like she's kind of blowing everyone off regardless of what they say about her, and as usual the shopping list of why she may or may not be active at any given moment. Seems like someone trying way too hard to seem like they're not trying to seem innocent.

CS, to me, is playing his usual role...think Van Helsing on speed. Nothing he's done so far re. voting for about everyone in the game, really raises any flags for me. He's always kind of off the wall and twitchy.

Thats it for now, so my top suspicions right now are placed on JM and DD.