Mafia #13 - The Witches of ACville- the play

Oh ****! We had a bad night.....I'm not sure about Bk for a witch just yet. Stupid moves do not always make a badguy. I also think if he had teammates they would have advised him on the basics of looking innocent. (Like rule number #1 - don't be named Coler.) What are people's thoughts on KOTD and Ogre?
 
I don't have time right now to pull the posts and comment so I'm going to list their numbers.

LGs lists and posts that were worth mentioning.

DC 128
List 132
List 197
List 210
List 221
List 279
KOTD 313
List 358

JM had many more posts to look into

DD 123 *
CS 125 *
Z 129
DC 131
Plant 137
List 147
plant 154
Z 155
Sway 159 *
List 192
plant 274
DC 242
DC 289 then look at post 147
Z 314

* are people not suspected of being witches ATM

Z would be an * but after he votes JM, further along in the day he says he doesn't really see anything but doesn't remove the vote.

A couple of posts that stood out were DC 305 and KOTD 313
 
I still think DD is innocent and I'm beginning to believe Sway more now by some of her recent posts. Ice is a hard read right now. He's being helpful but he thinks hard about the game so I'm not sure if he's really being helpful or trying to steer the ship over the waterfall. (Speaking of, a pirateship mutiny mafia game would be fun for future reference.) I'll be checking stuff out more.
 
DeputyChiefJR said:
Oh ****! We had a bad night.....I'm not sure about Bk for a witch just yet. Stupid moves do not always make a badguy. I also think if he had teammates they would have advised him on the basics of looking innocent. (Like rule number #1 - don't be named Coler.) What are people's thoughts on KOTD and Ogre?
Click to expand...

King I don't have any read on either way, he doesn't seem Witchy but I think we all agree he is one of the toughest to figure out.

Ogre I have leaning very slightly Witchy, but again I don't have a strong vibe there.
IceH2O said:
I don't have time right now to pull the posts and comment so I'm going to list their numbers.

LGs lists and posts that were worth mentioning.

DC 128
List 132
List 197
List 210
List 221
List 279
KOTD 313
List 358

JM had many more posts to look into

DD 123 *
CS 125 *
Z 129
DC 131
Plant 137
List 147
plant 154
Z 155
Sway 159 *
List 192
plant 274
DC 242
DC 289 then look at post 147
Z 314

* are people not suspected of being witches ATM

Z would be an * but after he votes JM, further along in the day he says he doesn't really see anything but doesn't remove the vote.

A couple of posts that stood out were DC 305 and KOTD 313
Click to expand...

That's fair Ice, I was the first vote on JM, other than her initial comment of holding info I didn't see anything else, but she also didn't post much after that. I think myself and anyone else that voted for her is and should be under scrutiny.
 
Lists are still pretty useless to me but as far as who I have leaning Witchy
(Not scaled)

BrkD - For his early comment about the "room" and his posts and vote change right before Night.
Ogre - Nothing solid only a very slight feeling. I have actually agreed with some things he has said though.
DC - Voted 4th on JM (Yes I was number 1 but it still applies), the "drunken" posting, again just a general vibe.
sploke: Followed Ice onto Plantling without much additional info, seems willing to go with the consensus, maybe to make as few waves as possible.

No particular order to these.
 
I think I figured out why the Herbalist didn't use there protection.

You are the town’s Herbalist. You have a weak potion and it has limited duration so it cannot be used on the same person more than once. At the onset of night, you may protect one person with it and it will save them from being affected by a spell cast by the witches. You may communicate with the Prophet.
Click to expand...

If they blindly used the potion on a PR on Night 1 then they couldn't protect that person again. The chances of the witches hitting a PR were slim, maybe they figured the risk was worth it?
 
Good thinking Z.

Not sure what to think right now but two people I really want to hear from are Brk for the last minute change out of no where and blue for the jm vote for pretty much no reason. Both newbs yes, but the sooner as we figure them out the better. They still have a chance of being a witch...

DD pointing out me "protecting" lg is troubling but I can't say anything else about her is too suspcious other than her arguments with jm but too bold for an evil to be creating commotion early day one.

I still have bad 'gut' feelings about DC and sploke. Same with KOTD.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom