Ok so your saying I'm off base with my assumption then.. Thats what I was wanting to know.. Thanks.
Mafia #14 -- The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Ok so your saying I'm off base with my assumption then.. Thats what I was wanting to know.. Thanks.
either way, that doesn't explain why the accident would play Day 1 badly (and I'm not saying that Charlie did). When in doubt, play it straight townie for a day....you can't go wrong, right?
Well I'm off to bed.. I get to splice fiber in the cold tomorrow.. Yeah.. (can you tell I'm so excited. I'll try to catch up again after work.
Only if we're drawing random numbers to determine who to lynch....at least 8 folks wouldn't be drawing random numbers, though.
Ice, you keep saying that Lady G is a good candidate for mafia. You even voted for her on Day 1 at some point. So why'd you unvote her and jump on Charlie after he was pretty much dead and buried?
FireDancer7905
I'm in love!
My current thoughts, in no particular order:
1. s*%! we lost 2 innocents, and the mafia ratio was pretty high to begin with.
2. How do you prove innocence, without screaming it and being called mafiascum?
3. The current players:
Swayde- makes me nervous. lots of posts, little to judge by
ogre- nothing suspicious yet
Dangerdoll- very conversational and soothing posts, lots of "honeys" and "girls", a ploy to make us comfortable? or just DD enjoying life?
lady g- i still don't like her style or tone- no more evidence than that
jpappy- appears helpful, who knows?
madcrawdad- pushing people for more info, could be baiting
clown lover- no bad vibes yet
cooldude- playing like a noob, suspiciously so, maybe using his stauts as such to play us as per boss' ruling. i don't trust him
johnlarson66- early vote, quiet for a vet. not sure.
jensons- innocent
blueiz- I don't trust her. After LadyG jumped on me, she posted something that seemed to back her up. The vote she then cast for LadyG made me thinkthat it may have been a ruse to keep us off her trail. And, if she is mafia, and suspects that LadyG is on the other team, it would be a good vote.
deputychief- no read
judgemax- leaning innocent
ice- bad vibe, no good reasons
hooked newbie- innocent and gone: no votes placed
dwarf puffers- leaning innocent, but could very well be using past history to play as a sleeper mafia
djmajor- leaning mafia
charlie stubbs- innocent and gone: HN(191) Ogre(382) DP(403) CL(414) DC(417) JPap(462) Ice(464) DD(471) DJ(476)
4. I know that there's not much to go on here, but this is what I can do before bed. At least it's not about Heroes.
5. My top 3: LadyG, Blueiz, cooldude
G'nite all!
~brandy
OMG!!! I went to work thinking I would come back to at least ONE mafia gone...wow we lost two townies in a 2 mafia game, that is just crazy!!!:thud:
See this is EXACTLY why I said I was worried about EVERYONE jumping on one person!! What can we learn from this, not much! Yes, I agree what Charlie said was very anti-town..but I HATE the excuse of "he did it to himself" NO you all that voted him did it to him. I learned along time ago, when I believe it was King did something similar... it doesn't always mean they are evil...sometimes ppl just are at a lose as to what to do, when they know they are innocent and can't truly "prove" it. I know I've been there.
I think we should look more into the "early" voters of Charlie. Who besides HN pushed for him early on?
I'm not sure I think he was the "accident" Rb usually tells a role when a person dies.
As for the "hit" on HN...I would assume they felt he was a good player and wanted him out, or they thought him to be a power role.
See this is EXACTLY why I said I was worried about EVERYONE jumping on one person!! What can we learn from this, not much! Yes, I agree what Charlie said was very anti-town..but I HATE the excuse of "he did it to himself" NO you all that voted him did it to him. I learned along time ago, when I believe it was King did something similar... it doesn't always mean they are evil...sometimes ppl just are at a lose as to what to do, when they know they are innocent and can't truly "prove" it. I know I've been there.
I think we should look more into the "early" voters of Charlie. Who besides HN pushed for him early on?
I'm not sure I think he was the "accident" Rb usually tells a role when a person dies.
As for the "hit" on HN...I would assume they felt he was a good player and wanted him out, or they thought him to be a power role.
Ok, guys/gals...I couldn't sleep I had to come back and apologize for my last post. I'm sorry I got so upset. You know I had a really bad night at work, came home and found we lost 2 innocents. Then I read ppl saying "he brought it on himself".
When I read this it reminded me of when I was lynched for "freaking out" kinda in the same way (never said I'd take a UD) but still I freaked a little b/c I felt like I was being set up...I have a feeling Charlie may of felt the same way and that emotion came out in me. PPl said the same thing "she brought it on herself" and guess what those ppl were on the bad side.
So now I am going to look into who was on him early, and who said "he brought it on himself". I think this may be where the truth will lie.
This is going to sound hypocritical, but I also believe there are some who voted another way (yes, I know I did) but I believe there are some who voted another way b/c they KNEW he was innocent. No I did not KNOW he was innocent and really had my doubts about him..and it took everything I had NOT to switch to him, I am also going to look at those who were "on" me for saying I thought he seemed Mafia but not voting him, I have a feeling some of these KNEW he was not Mafia.
I will back on tomorrow and look through everything from the very first post's on, and post what I find.
Well, I just mainly wanted to come on and say sorry for that last "vent" post!! Really that is all it was a vent, I'm sure more will be read into it, but that is simply all it was.
When I read this it reminded me of when I was lynched for "freaking out" kinda in the same way (never said I'd take a UD) but still I freaked a little b/c I felt like I was being set up...I have a feeling Charlie may of felt the same way and that emotion came out in me. PPl said the same thing "she brought it on herself" and guess what those ppl were on the bad side.
So now I am going to look into who was on him early, and who said "he brought it on himself". I think this may be where the truth will lie.
This is going to sound hypocritical, but I also believe there are some who voted another way (yes, I know I did) but I believe there are some who voted another way b/c they KNEW he was innocent. No I did not KNOW he was innocent and really had my doubts about him..and it took everything I had NOT to switch to him, I am also going to look at those who were "on" me for saying I thought he seemed Mafia but not voting him, I have a feeling some of these KNEW he was not Mafia.
I will back on tomorrow and look through everything from the very first post's on, and post what I find.
Well, I just mainly wanted to come on and say sorry for that last "vent" post!! Really that is all it was a vent, I'm sure more will be read into it, but that is simply all it was.
Dead??? It was 5-4 at that time.
Can I ask why you threw away a vote onto Sway? I mean if she was such a suspect why didn't you push for her and get some votes floating that way if you knew Charlie was innocent?
Heres my post showing the vote break down.
Maybe it should be asked of Jpap or DD, who came off DP to Charlie, and we already assume DJ is mafia.
The votes that are made late and put on a player not in danger always gets my attention
Mad onto Sway
Blue onto LG
I find it odd that you say this about me
yet LadyG is one of your top 3 suspects as well. Can you tell me why I am suspicious for voting to lynch Lady G, but you think she is suspicious as well?
I think for now our focus needs to remain off of djmajor. Keep in mind his antics, but lets don't zone in on him.
