thank you for responding
i don't kno what to think,
both blue and DD have lady in a corner
but i don't kno who is good or bad.
Mafia #14 -- The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
thank you for responding
i don't kno what to think,
both blue and DD have lady in a corner
but i don't kno who is good or bad.
remember that there is a possibility that they are all bad...not a very good one because I doubt that if blueiz and dd were on the same team they would both be going after the same person. And neither of them would be going after Lg if they were on the same team as her...so I guess I could rule that out. My guess is that two of them are mafia and like you I have no idea which one is at this point. If I had to pick it would be Lg and Blueiz. But I am still watching DD, of course.
Quote:
Originally Posted by IceH2O View Post
Dead??? It was 5-4 at that time.
You were #7 (of 9) on Charlie...
Actually I was 7 of 10 before JL jumped off. At the time I voted Charlie the score was vote was 6-4 with a handful of players still left to vote. Far from dead I'd say. I voted Charlie because he looked and acted mafia.
Can I ask why you threw away a vote onto Sway? I mean if she was such a suspect why didn't you push for her and get some votes floating that way if you knew Charlie was innocent?
I didn't know that Charlie was innocent....just didn't think that he was as lynchworthy as others did. A couple of people mentioned Charlie early on, and half the town was jumping all over him.
Of course they were, he was posting crazy then threatened a UD. Looked like a halfbaked mafia plan.
I learned my lesson a few games back when Cory Lover said 'Innocent again.' I fought like crazy to get the town not lynch him on Day 1, (based on that single post), as it was a pretty rash move to do so, and on Day 2 he ended up as mafia....oops, I won't do that again.
So you didn't want to protect Charlie because you thought he might be mafia? So why the hell are you so surprised that others voted for him?
Heres my post showing the vote break down.
Maybe it should be asked of Jpap or DD, who came off DP to Charlie, and we already assume DJ is mafia. I agree... I was just starting with you.
The votes that are made late and put on a player not in danger always gets my attention
Of course it gets your attention... Funny that you didn't mention it until I asked you a question, though.
Sorry was I supposed to post it right after the lynching? As I thought about it after signing off I was looking at notes and noticed the jumpers and wasted votes. Are you just upset that you can't sit back and watch and instead have someone looking at you?
Mad onto Sway
Blue onto LG
This was my post that mad responded to in blue. My responses to his responses are in red.
Yeah because thats my MO. I always sit back and let others do all the work. I almost choked on my dinner reading this post. Come on Mad, you can do better then this can't you?
Quote:Blue Post 754
I see that not much more new info has popped out there while I was away. Lady G is highest on my suspected mafia list at this point. She is a bit wishy washy and seems to not be able to firmly say anything, always leaving a hole open to chnage her views. She posts a lot with no real information, almost seems nervous with a forced sense of caring about the town.
I believe LG is mafia also. LG is just on a different team then you though Blue.This last quote bothers me. If JM was your highest suspect and nothing new has popped up why then has LG become your top suspect? Did you feel as though you had put enough distance between you and JM?
This time my drink almost choked me.
Can't speak for the others but my response is in red under your question. I can say I'm not seeing it with DD though I always have trouble reading her. I already said I think Blue is mafia.
I'll get my list and reasons posted here in a minute.
Originally Posted by IceH2O View Post
Dead??? It was 5-4 at that time.
You were #7 (of 9) on Charlie...
Actually I was 7 of 10 before JL jumped off. At the time I voted Charlie the score was vote was 6-4 with a handful of players still left to vote. Far from dead I'd say. I voted Charlie because he looked and acted mafia.
Can I ask why you threw away a vote onto Sway? I mean if she was such a suspect why didn't you push for her and get some votes floating that way if you knew Charlie was innocent?
I didn't know that Charlie was innocent....just didn't think that he was as lynchworthy as others did. A couple of people mentioned Charlie early on, and half the town was jumping all over him.
Of course they were, he was posting crazy then threatened a UD. Looked like a halfbaked mafia plan.
I learned my lesson a few games back when Cory Lover said 'Innocent again.' I fought like crazy to get the town not lynch him on Day 1, (based on that single post), as it was a pretty rash move to do so, and on Day 2 he ended up as mafia....oops, I won't do that again.
So you didn't want to protect Charlie because you thought he might be mafia? So why the hell are you so surprised that others voted for him?
Heres my post showing the vote break down.
Maybe it should be asked of Jpap or DD, who came off DP to Charlie, and we already assume DJ is mafia. I agree... I was just starting with you.
The votes that are made late and put on a player not in danger always gets my attention
Of course it gets your attention... Funny that you didn't mention it until I asked you a question, though.
Sorry was I supposed to post it right after the lynching? As I thought about it after signing off I was looking at notes and noticed the jumpers and wasted votes. Are you just upset that you can't sit back and watch and instead have someone looking at you?
Mad onto Sway
Blue onto LG
This was my post that mad responded to in blue. My responses to his responses are in red.
Yeah because thats my MO. I always sit back and let others do all the work. I almost choked on my dinner reading this post. Come on Mad, you can do better then this can't you?
Quote:Blue Post 754
I see that not much more new info has popped out there while I was away. Lady G is highest on my suspected mafia list at this point. She is a bit wishy washy and seems to not be able to firmly say anything, always leaving a hole open to chnage her views. She posts a lot with no real information, almost seems nervous with a forced sense of caring about the town.
I believe LG is mafia also. LG is just on a different team then you though Blue.This last quote bothers me. If JM was your highest suspect and nothing new has popped up why then has LG become your top suspect? Did you feel as though you had put enough distance between you and JM?
This time my drink almost choked me.
Can't speak for the others but my response is in red under your question. I can say I'm not seeing it with DD though I always have trouble reading her. I already said I think Blue is mafia.
I'll get my list and reasons posted here in a minute.
Have went back through reviewing the posts made after nightfall last night. Have found one that seems a bit off..maybe Ice can explain.
Ice, In this post of you madcrwdad s question, this statement here stands out
Is there any reason you say we?
Ice, In this post of you madcrwdad s question, this statement here stands out
Is there any reason you say we?
eh ...Dwarf Puffers is forsaking both the evil ways of his people and their town. I am leaning toward his errors.
here what i have:
dj might be mafia or his post could be a slip, but even so i've never heard of anyone hoping for a good 'hit'
lady could be mafia, blue could be mafia or DD could be mafia. if both blue and DD were then DD and blue are trying to get lg...
OR all three could be innocent and just at each other throuts for a "suspicious vibe" there getting from each other.
soo while this lovly circus ride is going round and round, we still have all of the mafia players prolly laughing at there good fortune at not being found.
soo more thoughts anyone?
dj might be mafia or his post could be a slip, but even so i've never heard of anyone hoping for a good 'hit'
lady could be mafia, blue could be mafia or DD could be mafia. if both blue and DD were then DD and blue are trying to get lg...
OR all three could be innocent and just at each other throuts for a "suspicious vibe" there getting from each other.
soo while this lovly circus ride is going round and round, we still have all of the mafia players prolly laughing at there good fortune at not being found.
soo more thoughts anyone?
Since we cant edit, would also like to say i gave the reason why I voted for LG in the same post that I voted for her to be lynched in originally.
My list broken into teams are for no other reason then what I feel are attacks versus distancing.
Team A
JM- Started out defensive and her automatic vote on Blue seemed out of the norm. Even JM isn't usually one to vote a newb the 1st day.
Blue- Her fight with JM and then voting LG is what made me think this was a distancing tactic
Sway- Her vote for DP wasn't much but it stayed there. It was put there to draw DP out. I didn't see anything from DP after that to warrant keeping it there. But the kicker was
Mad- his vote placed on Sway. At a time when it was mostly between Charlie or DJ. If he was worried that Charlie was innocent why not build a case against Sway and get us to switch or why not vote DJ?
Team B
LG- threw suspicion on Charlie, which is finer I thought so also but her statement that it was odd how he was acting but then posting he is acting as usual caught my eye. Its like she wanted us to vote for him but then tried to cover her *** by saying it looked normal. Why then the suspicion?
DC- Felt as though he had to translate LGs post. A few other things have popped out, the posts have been covered. His early vote onto DJ was a big factor, as pointed out he didn't even question it just threw it out.His translation of LGs post, but he doesn't argue it as if he agrees but then he votes Charlie.
Jpap- The posts with JM and JL bother me. If you look at the posts he starts off with I agree but the rest of the post contridicts him agreeing with what he agreed with.
DJ- I think last nights posts speak for themselves.
Team A
JM- Started out defensive and her automatic vote on Blue seemed out of the norm. Even JM isn't usually one to vote a newb the 1st day.
Blue- Her fight with JM and then voting LG is what made me think this was a distancing tactic
Sway- Her vote for DP wasn't much but it stayed there. It was put there to draw DP out. I didn't see anything from DP after that to warrant keeping it there. But the kicker was
Mad- his vote placed on Sway. At a time when it was mostly between Charlie or DJ. If he was worried that Charlie was innocent why not build a case against Sway and get us to switch or why not vote DJ?
Team B
LG- threw suspicion on Charlie, which is finer I thought so also but her statement that it was odd how he was acting but then posting he is acting as usual caught my eye. Its like she wanted us to vote for him but then tried to cover her *** by saying it looked normal. Why then the suspicion?
DC- Felt as though he had to translate LGs post. A few other things have popped out, the posts have been covered. His early vote onto DJ was a big factor, as pointed out he didn't even question it just threw it out.His translation of LGs post, but he doesn't argue it as if he agrees but then he votes Charlie.
Jpap- The posts with JM and JL bother me. If you look at the posts he starts off with I agree but the rest of the post contridicts him agreeing with what he agreed with.
DJ- I think last nights posts speak for themselves.
