Mafia #14 -- The Play

[djmajor]

Whoa, weird turn of events, but it makes sense with his posts. It's too bad we lost HN, because he's always really good at harassing mafia and I was looking forward to get good lynch picks from him. So the whole DJ thing...Is he really playing so badly as to give himself away? For now it seems like a pretty safe bet.

I vote to lynch DJ.

It's kinda hard to judge by voting record who is what right now, since Chas was acting so funny that it made it easy for the mafia to jump on him.

:rofl:making a innocent mistake, beleive me glub glud remember fish tank cow?

 

[IceH2O]

Have went back through reviewing the posts made after nightfall last night. Have found one that seems a bit off..maybe Ice can explain.




Ice, In this post of you madcrwdad s question, this statement here stands out

Is there any reason you say we?

Yes the reason being I'm part of the town. The statement of we had 8 chances out of 18 is easy enough to figure out I would think but since you're mafia you wouldn't see it that way would you. In your mind you have 10 townies to hit and 4 other mafia players so your odds are 14 out of 18 right?

Not much more info had came out, but it was enough for me to cast my vote onto LG.

Im not quiet sure what you mean by putting distance beween myself and JM, can you explain?

You and JM are team mates. She votes you and then you and her have a staged fight. Now why would anyone think you 2 would attack one another if teammates. Since you've gotten people talking about it you have them thinking either both innocent or 1 is mafia but no way both are. Thats distancing.

Since the deed had been completed and however many posts you stated, 276 I think, it was time to go after someone you assume to be innocent.

 

[Blueiz]

:rofl:making a innocent mistake, beleive me glub glud remember fish tank cow?

Then I will change by vote list too.

Clue

#560 with jpappy789 has the head protecting his companiions

Is that a cow on the pappy's pole Why is he leaving? Sounds like he was here trying to get somebody to change the vote for the sake of his group. What is the count?

With djmajor mentioning a cow again, it sparked a thought, this is the second time a cow has been mentinoed in this thread, by him. Have noted these two things from DJ posts. As well as it seems hims and jpappy are posting a lot towards each other, with jpappy responding to DJ. Anyone have any thoughts? Im not sure what to make of it....

 

[OgreMkV]

What I find a little funny here is you say your list is based on who is correct on mafia, you have Ice as a 6....he voted Charlie (innocent), You have CL 5, again voted Charlie (innocent), Jpap voted Charlie he is a 5. Then your next highest numbers 4-DD, DC both voted Charlie also.
So Orge to me it looks as though you are a little bit backwards here on who is right about mafia??
No..I don't think all these to be mafia...I would say

One thing that struck me as odd was what ogre is basing his list on. I do not think that anyone should be thought of as innocent or even leaning innocent just because they found a mafia member. Mafia from team A is also gunning for team B as well as innocents because only one side can win technically, if I understand the rules correctly. When I was CIA in the Bloody coup I went after DC until he was lynched, he was FBI. Also, the mafia are trying to gain the towns trust and that is done by finding mafia from the other team. And I do not know what you are using for your first numbers because as lg pointed out we havent found anyone yet. Based on on how you are structuring your list, shouldnt everyone be a 5 right now? I am just confused...

The list... sigh. Why does this happen everytime I try to make a dang list. Look, no one is a ten or a one. A one would be someone who was a known mafia just trying to confuse and/or cast doubts. A ten would be a known innocent trying to help the town.

This list is about POSTS, not innocence or guilt. It's about who I think is helping the town.

Jpappy, I see where you're coming from and I agree with it. I keep forgetting there are two mafia teams... however, in a round about way, a mafia who leads us to kill another mafia... well, we still lynched a mafia. I'll take it as long as we can figure out that we were led.

i guess you're saying that even though someone helped out the town, we can't automatically assume they are innocent... and I agree with that.

My list broken into teams are for no other reason then what I feel are attacks versus distancing.

Team A

JM- Started out defensive and her automatic vote on Blue seemed out of the norm. Even JM isn't usually one to vote a newb the 1st day.

Blue- Her fight with JM and then voting LG is what made me think this was a distancing tactic

Sway- Her vote for DP wasn't much but it stayed there. It was put there to draw DP out. I didn't see anything from DP after that to warrant keeping it there. But the kicker was

Mad- his vote placed on Sway. At a time when it was mostly between Charlie or DJ. If he was worried that Charlie was innocent why not build a case against Sway and get us to switch or why not vote DJ?

Team B

LG- threw suspicion on Charlie, which is finer I thought so also but her statement that it was odd how he was acting but then posting he is acting as usual caught my eye. Its like she wanted us to vote for him but then tried to cover her *** by saying it looked normal. Why then the suspicion?

DC- Felt as though he had to translate LGs post. A few other things have popped out, the posts have been covered. His early vote onto DJ was a big factor, as pointed out he didn't even question it just threw it out.His translation of LGs post, but he doesn't argue it as if he agrees but then he votes Charlie.

Jpap- The posts with JM and JL bother me. If you look at the posts he starts off with I agree but the rest of the post contridicts him agreeing with what he agreed with.

DJ- I think last nights posts speak for themselves.

Just something to think about... most of these events have been painfully obvious... don't you think that the mafia might try to be more subtle?

 

[Blueiz]

Quote:
Originally Posted by Blueiz
Have went back through reviewing the posts made after nightfall last night. Have found one that seems a bit off..maybe Ice can explain.




Ice, In this post of you madcrwdad s question, this statement here stands out

Is there any reason you say we?

Yes the reason being I'm part of the town. The statement of we had 8 chances out of 18 is easy enough to figure out I would think but since you're mafia you wouldn't see it that way would you. In your mind you have 10 townies to hit and 4 other mafia players so your odds are 14 out of 18 right?

ok, I was refferring mostly to your saying

Umm we have 8 chances out of 18 people to get a hit c

I should have asked why you said we and hit in the same sentence, sorry for not clarifying my question more. Correct me if I am wrong, us townies lynch ppl and the mafia hit ppl, right?

 

[djmajor]

its the hour...when things change.

 

[IceH2O]

Just something to think about... most of these events have been painfully obvious... don't you think that the mafia might try to be more subtle?

Its only obvious if its pointed out. Most of this stuff would easily be lost among the posts. You can try to be as subtle as you want. Trying being the main word. When you try you can also fail. I think they thought all of this was pretty innocent banter. Also the distancing tactics have to be out in the open or they wouldn't work now would they?

 

[Swayde]

its the hour...when things change.

What is that supposed to mean?

 

[djmajor]

I vote to lynch JudgeMAx

 

[Blueiz]

You and JM are team mates. She votes you and then you and her have a staged fight. Now why would anyone think you 2 would attack one another if teammates. Since you've gotten people talking about it you have them thinking either both innocent or 1 is mafia but no way both are. Thats distancing.

With "distancing" being clarified for me, Id like to make sure that it is known I still think JM is mafia. If she is innocent, then she will have to prove it to me, as everyone else beucase everyone is suspect and no one can be trusted. As already said, she dropped lower on my list. I feel that LadyG is more of a threat to the town becuase of her covert ways of manipulating ppls thoughts, the confusion techniques she uses, the way she twists words and throws out her own interpretation of them as gold. This is pretty much the same things that I have already said previously...just worded them differntly so hopefully it is better understood.