Mafia #14 -- The Play

Madcrawdad said:
Now folks were saying that his plan was anti-town, and in a big-picture sense, it was, because we could have lost 3 townies in one night. But it wasn't malicious anti-town. Had Chas been mafia and agreed to kill himself to avoid a lynch, he would have HAD TO FOLLOW THROUGH, otherwise he would have been lynched the very next day....NO QUESTION ABOUT IT. This might make sense for the mafia to do if they only needed one more day for a win, but it was Day 1. This made no sense as a mafia plan. Chas didn't seem any more guilty to me than anyone else.
Click to expand...

Mad as I stated earlier I was glad for the great detail in your post. I wanted to say something about this section though.

My thinking at the time was that it was a ploy to save Charlie. Djs posts that is.
We lynch DJ and Charlie gets forgotten the next day in the mix. Its happened before when we've had mafia in sight. All Charlie would have had to do would be hide among the others and stay out of the spotlight.

Thats was just my opinion at the time and why my vote stayed as it did.
 
Lady G said:
I just wanted to mention, I did not see any case that Ogre tried to get the detective to come out either...yes you said "please tell me he's not the detective" but I and I'm sure others took that more of a "joke" post.
DD, again trying to make something out of nothing.
Click to expand...
wrong, G.... I am picking up things which I believe need to be looked at further. Nice play of words yourself though. Feel free to show me where else you believe I "twisted" anything.

Swayde said:
Hey, I thought this was a family site! :laugh:
Click to expand...
ROFLMAO now stop that, LMAO!!

IceH2O said:
DD please show me where he is pushing for the Detective. I swear I don't see even a smidgen of him trying to pull out the Detective.
Click to expand...
sure, Ice... this one down below.

OgreMkV said:
I wasn't alluding you to be the detective... you said (I quote)

[/color][/i]

In response to me asking if DJMajor was the detective. You ASSURED me that he is not. I repeat, there are only two ways you can ASSURE me, that he is not the detective. The first is if you are the detective and the second is that you and him are on the same mafia team.



Don't Dons show as innocent to the detective? Wouldn't a Don WANT the detective to investigate them?

The majority opinion is that DJMajor is mafia. If that is true (and we lynch him to find out) then my next vote is for you J.
Click to expand...
the bolded area ia where I took it from. Now, the sentence after that goes on about the Don, which I think might take away from the sentence I am having trouble with. I don't know.... maybe it's nothing but I thought it was worth noting is all.
 
johnlarson66 said:
judgemax,

There is a chance that DJmajor is the Detective, the only person(s) that would KNOW that he wasn't would be the Detective, the Doctor, and if they were mafia the same teamates.

You made the statement, now if I push it, then I am forcing you out. You made the statement, do you really want to stand by your statement and say that you are positive that DJmajor could not be the Detective or could you just have a feeling that DJmajor is not the Detectice, but he could be.

By the way, DJmajor has not claimed to be the Detective, but Ogre made a comment, I took it as a joke, but your statement has me concerned.

DJmajor did ask for a day to prove himself.
Click to expand...

Here is my response to judgemax.

Also the whole thing about "pulling out the Detective", well I have done it many times. If someone hints that they are the Detective, then they should be called on it. From the statement judgemax made, it can only be assumed she is the Detective, Doctor or mafia.

For the record, I did not really see her take it back. Her reason that DJ could not be the Detective is because DJ voted for her.
 
I guess I didn't take note of your calling on it, John. I don't agree on that... I don't think if anyone is the detective or doctor, they should be called on it at all... I mean, maybe later in the game or if we had the upper hand, but it's only been one night and we are down two townies. That would be giving the detective to the mafia, no?
 
Dangerdoll said:
I guess I didn't take note of your calling on it, John. I don't agree on that... I don't think if anyone is the detective or doctor, they should be called on it at all... I mean, maybe later in the game or if we had the upper hand, but it's only been one night and we are down two townies. That would be giving the detective to the mafia, no?
Click to expand...


I agree with you there. It puts more stress on the detective too, which is a stressful role to play already without people trying to call you out. And it could very well benefit the mafia if they didn't happen to catch on to the clues.
 
Dangerdoll said:
wrong, G.... I am picking up things which I believe need to be looked at further. Nice play of words yourself though. Feel free to show me where else you believe I "twisted" anything.


ROFLMAO now stop that, LMAO!!


sure, Ice... this one down below.


the bolded area ia where I took it from. Now, the sentence after that goes on about the Don, which I think might take away from the sentence I am having trouble with. I don't know.... maybe it's nothing but I thought it was worth noting is all.
Click to expand...
I personally took it that he was calling her out as Mafia.
 
Update....

to lynch....

djmajor....11 votes

lady....3 votes

blueiz....2 votes

all have voted....

less than 3 hrs to nightfall....


PMs or e-mails, as required....thanks...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom