Mafia #14 -- The Play

[IceH2O]

Pulling your vote insinuates it I believe.

From reading you past posts it seems you think its a mafia ploy between 2 players against the town. If you believe this then why remove your vote from DD as she has to be mafia.

Your squabbling with LG I can understand if you believe them to be playing the town but from responses I'm sure its not as you think.[/quote]


Can you clarify what you mean there?

All day you've been at LG. Your posts have been stating that you think they might both be mafia. This would explain the attacks by you on her.

From reading her responses I'm sure she is the Detective and you are wrong.

 

[Blueiz]

All day you've been at LG. Your posts have been stating that you think they might both be mafia. This would explain the attacks by you on her.

From reading her responses I'm sure she is the Detective and you are wrong.

You have a way of posting your interpretation of things as factual.

I hope that my mind is made up as to what to think before nightfall.

 

[Lady G]

I vote to lynch DD. For the record, I disagreed with LadyG's plan, but it's done and I believe her, especially after DDs lame attempts.

I think DD did more to help LadyG thatn LadyG could have.

Ice, I would encourage you not to place JMax and DP on the back burner.

DD has been very helpful in convincing me that you are the detective and that she mafia.

You asked twice and I have been out since 2:00P CST. You could at least way until I make a post that doesn't answer your question before you go jumping on me for not answering your question.

Ok, Ogre I am sorry if I didn't give you enough time to respond. Really I was talking about earlier in the game when you stated this (remember when, DD, blue and then Cl joined in to jump all over me), you said how she has been so helpful this game...I asked how, you never responded.
Now that she has been brought out as the Don, you again state she has been more helpful so again I asked...still waiting for you to show me where btw.
But thank you for responding at least.

You have a way of posting your interpretation of things as factual.

I hope that my mind is made up as to what to think before nightfall.

For one, I think it is pretty much fact what he has said.
Second, I don't think it really matters if you make your mind up or not, DD has been brought out and will be lynched tomorrow...the only question is are you going to help take out a mafia or vote a townie?

 

[Lady G]

That quote in my post was NOT made by Ice, it was Blue responding to Ice...I don't know why it showed as Ice?????

 

[Lady G]

All day you've been at LG. Your posts have been stating that you think they might both be mafia. This would explain the attacks by you on her.

From reading her responses I'm sure she is the Detective and you are wrong.

You have a way of posting your interpretation of things as factual.

I hope that my mind is made up as to what to think before nightfall.

This was what I was posting about. Still have know idea why it came up that way.

 

[Lady G]

Ok, this is odd....the post with Ice say's Blue and the post with blue say's Ice. Can Mods do things to switch names around in a quote???

 

[Lady G]

Point me to where I have said that DD is innocent.

Could it be a plan to draw out the mafia?

So correct me if I'm wrong...but unless you are trying to say Mafia is trying to draw out mafia, you are insinuating she is innocent? Plus you withdrew your vote on her.

 

[Madcrawdad]

That quote in my post was NOT made by Ice, it was Blue responding to Ice...I don't know why it showed as Ice?????

In looking at Blue's and Ice's recent posts, it looks like something is wrong with the quote function. If you notice their posts all start with the quote tag from the other showing.

 

[clown-lover]

Wow exciting day.. Got home earlier than expected (9:30) and have been able to go through todays posts.. Took some time to do some investigating and quell whatever questions lingered in my mind.

Yes, I have questions, but I kind of want to see how it plays out. In your first posts today, though, you came out quite strongly trying to discredit LG. First you voted to lynch, then in a post that quickly followed you said that a person would have to be stupid to come out as detective....not exactly questioning. It looks like your mind was made up at that point to immediately discredit her.

I noticed that you said that 'your brain hurts' quite a bit lately....that is kind of the same as saying 'I'm so confused,' isn't it?

Not to discredit her at all.. But in trying to wrap my head around some very hastily made comments and things started going very quickly at that point.. To me I had to question the motives of someone making this claim 30 minutes before nightfall. Almost like she was wanting to create chaos within the game. Wouldn't that be a mafia move? Thats what got me really but after a lot of thought today while pulling cable in that *&*#( building I have had time to think things over.. While the timing was very poor IMO I am believing that LadyG is the DET. (See below where she even states that it was bad timing)..

You know when all that was really directed at me last night yeah my head was hurting.. I WAS CERTAIN I had a mafia with LadyG.. So yeah my head hurt.

Honestly Swayde I was "hit" night one last game, lynched night one the game before that....I freaked ok, I wanted to come out all day but like I said wanted to talk to the Doc first when I got my PM back from her/him, I had just got home and I wanted to get the name out their...I know it was bad timing, I'm sorry about that, but you KNOW how badly I freak out sometimes when I'm innocent and ppl are all over me
After DD is lynched you will see. Hopefully the one investigated tonight will come back mafia

Read my responses to her. Having walked a mile in her shoes before, I am willing to believe her for now, or at least give her the benefit of doubt. She will have all heck to pay if she's wrong about DD, but that's quite a specific claim she's made I dont think it would be a good strategy for the mafia to try to come out at this point and there's no way a mafia team would know for sure who the don is of the other team. I can't imagine why a mafia team would give up their own don either.

I can't either unless they are having an internal dispute and the rest of the team are thinking they can do better without the DON.. But to me that would be stupid because your going to loose your investigations if I understand the rules correctly.

that's fine, Swayde..... you'll see... I must say though, G is quite clever and I never expected her to out me like that. G.... for what it's worth, if you don't come back to the room, I am sorry.... I never meant to offend you so badly.

DD you just outed yourself. This post in itself has convinced me that you are what Lady G says you are.. For that I vote to lynch DD

Effort :thumbsdown:
I agree that CLs posts are somewhat strange. Looks like he took a page from Colers playbook. ( Anyone hear anything about him?)

Actually I take that as a compliment since I respect Colors Game play more than anyone else that plays this game.

Long detailed posts that look good. But in trying to save a lost cause he seems to have outed himself. Same with Ogre IMO.

Not trying to save a lost cause. I had questions and need to straighten everything out logically in my own head before I make a decision. Like I have said in previous games I am a Libra. We are notorious for weighing everything before making a decision. As of last night I was convinced that LadyG was mafia and had weighed it all out.. She made her post and when she came out she even stated "Is that proof enough for you CL" or something to that effect. As I stated above to Mad I thought she was purposely trying to create chaos in the game and it would have been a great misdirection move. If DD hadn't handled the situation the way she did my guess is that there would be a lot more chaos happening in this game thread right now.

So we have

DD
Ogre
Blue
Jensons
Clown

Leaning mafia is

JM
DC
Sway
Mad

Everyone else is till a 5 except LG who is now a 10 along with me.

Ice think about me what you will.. It doesn't even bother me that I'm on your list or anyone else's for that matter. We wouldn't be playing this game right if we weren't on someones list.....

Would it be proclaiming my innocents to loud if i state I AM NOT MAFIA?

Actually this screams to me that you are mafia.. That and your post asking who the DOC was.. I think your next to go under everyones scrutiny..

ok, so not much has materialized, besides DD's silly accusations, ( not saying they couldn't be mafia) , but they just seem desperate,

on the other hand, could this be "distancing", since she is doing it so sarcastically, maybe they are rolling the dice, thinking we will all exclude ICE, and Ogre off the lists for awhile?..would be a smart tactic?....hmmmm.,....I still think RB picked those roles, and that would be one hell of a team.

I don't think distancing anyone off you list for a while is a good idea. In fact I think this latest round of game issues has allowed certain players to hide and others to put themselves into the lime light. I wish I was the DET so I could be certain about things.. At this point I only have a whole list of uncertainties. The only thing I can be certain of is that DD has outed herself in my eyes.

for JL, and clown.
I asked how anyone could not believe that The doctor had protected Lady G when RB pretty much said the same exact thing as LG did.

Yes I am quick to side with LG, after RB said that, I thought about it after, and even posted so, but I am now comfortable, seeing How DD turns out, before I doubt her, You have all done this in prior games, I am doing it now, If LG is wrong, you better believe that I will vote her, come first light.

Again things moved very quickly last night and I had other IRL things to worry about. I still do.. Tomorrow is going to be a full day of studying and this will be my "I need a distraction" excuse.
As of this point I am certain that LadyG is the detective. But then I was certain that DJ and LadyG was mafia last night.. :/

 

[clown-lover]

Ok, Ogre I am sorry if I didn't give you enough time to respond. Really I was talking about earlier in the game when you stated this (remember when, DD, blue and then Cl joined in to jump all over me), you said how she has been so helpful this game...I asked how, you never responded.

I would like to clarify this.. They had left you alone for quite a while which honestly is why I picked it up.. I thought they were letting you off easy.. If you had answered those questions I would have gone on.. But that in combination with what I felt was some strange play from the previous days had you pegged as mafia.. But then I was wrong about Charlie and Dj.. I know I was wrong about you as well now.