Mafia #14 -- The Play

This quote is the way it is because you continue to post your comments inside someone elses post. (I really wish you wouldn't do that.. Take the time to peal apart the post and quote it individually.. It makes it easier to answer)

Madcrawdad said:
clown-lover - another post soon after the day had started. He had challanged Lady G on being the Detective, but now in the new day, he wants to believe her. Instead it is a mafia play and votes to lynch her. I just do not like the "I want to believe you", she has been his number one suspect.
I've been keeping my eye on CL since the beginning of Day 2. In addition to my post last night where I pointed out that his reaction to LG coming out was 'odd,' there were a couple of other things that I've noticed.

Early on Day 2 he kind of laid the blame for his Chas vote at HN and Chas' feet... also, when looking helpful and pointing out who HN named as suspects, he conveniently didn't mention that HN named Clown Lover (along with myself) as suspects... Odd, isn't it?
Click to expand...
While she was the concentration of my efforts she is by no means my only suspect. If you look at the list I posted a while back I still strongly believe that JM and Blue are mafia.

I believe I have taken my fair share of the blame for Charlie's downfall.. And while I didn't not mention myself as his suspect was because that we had a conversation about his suspicions at that point and I believe I fell off his list to be honest.
 
Madcrawdad said:
JL, since you were asking for feedback to some of your posts, here goes:

What about your thoughts on Jpap, who looks to be siding with DD in the quote that you posted?
Click to expand...

Jpappy - I think is innocent. I have seen nothing that would make me think anything else. Maybe that should be a reason for concern. It isn't, I would be really really suprised if jpappy was mafia.

I know you did not ask, but here some other thoughts -

Swayde - I think is innocent. Posts seem informative and helpful. Has made good observations.

Madcrawdad - I think is innocent. Has been following the thread closely and asking good questions. Good at pointing out logic and finding detials.

IceH2O - Still not real sure, sometimes I think is innocent and then does something that makes me concerned. At one point thought the He and Ogre might have power roles. There is a connection between these two that I can't quite put my finger on.

I think that is about it, I need to really make a scaled list. I think I have mentioned everyone today, one way or another.
 
Ok, so my drunken post is going to be neither entertainig or enlightening. Instead I'm going to say, jesus my head hurts and I wish I could be hanging with the girl right now. These cat fights are mildly amusing but are getting me nowhere more than when I get in a fight with a woman. I'm freaking confused and have no idea where to place my vote. I'd like to think that G is detective but i know I've wanted to play that card before. I'm so burnt out on work and such right now that I can't think straight but I thought I'd check in. I've also been trying to take btter care of myself lately due to a certain influence. I went drinking tonight to blow off some steam but will make a semi-rational choice in the morning before I go to the lady's place. I know I've been bad this game even by my standards but stuff came up all at once and things are suddenly making a difference in life. It's weird, if anyone wants to talk or say hi feel free...God, I feel like a total dork but whatever, I'm in a good place right now...Night everyone...
 
Madcrawdad said:
In looking at Blue's and Ice's recent posts, it looks like something is wrong with the quote function. If you notice their posts all start with the quote tag from the other showing.
Click to expand...
Yes, I did notice that when I went back to try and "fix" my post. It was strange that it happened in those posts only though..that is why I asked if a Mod could make this happen. Blue seems to like to make post look like they say things they don't and if I hadn't noticed that ppl would of though Ice actually said what she did. Now I hate to think of a Mod using their "special" abilities to change things on a game...but you never know. Rb has been known to call out a person that is invisible and viewing the thread a time or two when he has played.

johnlarson66 said:
Jpappy - I think is innocent. I have seen nothing that would make me think anything else. Maybe that should be a reason for concern. It isn't, I would be really really suprised if jpappy was mafia.
I agree w/ you there, he has really done nothing to make me think anything one way or another about him.

I know you did not ask, but here some other thoughts -

Swayde - I think is innocent. Posts seem informative and helpful. Has made good observations.
I'm kinda on the fence with Swayde, I had her leaning more mafia...but her latest posting has made me slide her down a bit.

Madcrawdad - I think is innocent. Has been following the thread closely and asking good questions. Good at pointing out logic and finding detials.
Mad is another that I have gone back and forth with also...really I haven't gotten any huge bells ringing on him and his post do seem to be more helpful then not...so he is more toward the innocent for me.

IceH2O - Still not real sure, sometimes I think is innocent and then does something that makes me concerned. At one point thought the He and Ogre might have power roles. There is a connection between these two that I can't quite put my finger on.
I have to agree with this one too, honestly at first yes..I thought him to be mafia, but I have to say I have him leaning more innocent also.

I think that is about it, I need to really make a scaled list. I think I have mentioned everyone today, one way or another.
Click to expand...
I just wanted to make mention on my thoughts of the ones you have listed. Really in my eyes there are only a few that I am leaning mostly innocent...but many leaning mostly mafia.
I am going to make a scaled list also, I think this would be good to do so we can see who has who leaning what. The focus has mainly been DD, CL and Blue lately (due to latest developments and postings) so relooking at everyone is a good idea, IMO.
 
OK, here're some thoughts to mull over:

What if: DD is the det, and LadyG is the doc, and this is a ploy to draw out mafia?

What if: they are both on the same mafia team, and one really is a scarificial lamb? This could work if the teams are uneven.

What if: we are truly on a road to nowhere. People don't believe that rb cast the roles randomly. Could he have tweaked the game in a way that there is really no way for a team to win?

What if: the Doc is mafia, too?

What if: last night's save was made by the Thief, not the Doc?

Just some thoughts I had while sitting with my friend in the chemo room today. I will address accusations against me soon.

~brandy
 
This would have to be my scaled list at this time.

DD-10 (Don)

Blue-9

CL-8

Jensons-8

Ogre-7

DC-7

Jmax-7

DP-7

Mad-6

Swayde-5

JL-5

Cooldude-5

Ice-4

JP-4

LG-1
 
Jensons said:
OK, here're some thoughts to mull over:

What if: DD is the det, and LadyG is the doc, and this is a ploy to draw out mafia?
Then we would be taking out the Det and the Doc...If DD came back the Detective, the town would lynch me no way around that...they should. So that would just be silly to say the least.

What if: they are both on the same mafia team, and one really is a scarificial lamb? This could work if the teams are uneven.
I don't think we would vote off the Don, IF we were going to "sacrifice" a fellow team mate.

What if: we are truly on a road to nowhere. People don't believe that rb cast the roles randomly. Could he have tweaked the game in a way that there is really no way for a team to win?
I doubt that, IMO...it simply has to do with the fact the "mafia" keep coming back to the town...so it never ends.

What if: the Doc is mafia, too?
:huh:

What if: last night's save was made by the Thief, not the Doc?
Then RB would of made mention of a Thief...not the Doctor in his post about it.

Just some thoughts I had while sitting with my friend in the chemo room today. I will address accusations against me soon.

~brandy
Click to expand...
Wow and ppl always say I'm the one with the crazy thoughts:cool:
Again, I understand questioning me..especially by those who thought I was mafia and vise/versa. But these theories are really just :screwy: and I mean that in the nicest way.
 
AHHHHH, I can't edit...but my writting came out purple in that, sorry I forgot to change it!
 
:topic:
Swayde I just wanted to tell you, I've gone back and played luminary a few times and although it's a bit tooo cartoony it is addictive!;)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom