Mafia #15....The Play....

[OgreMkV]

Not to "defend" Ice at all, he very well may be scummy, but I'm afraid the attitude that we can lose ANY townie and it's "no huge loss" is the scummiest thing posted so far.

Care to explain your reasoning behind apparently knowing Z is innocent and that we can lose Ice because he isn't "hot as a townie"?

Go ahead and mark your spreadsheet for me.

I vote to lynch Ogre. Early vote that may change pending response for the reasoning.

You are right, any townie is a big loss. But the game cannot be won for four days no matter what happens.

I never said that Z was innocent... be careful putting words in other peoples mouths (that's a mafia thing).

I said that I believe that I can tell when he is playing innocent and playing mafia. My statement about Ice was made at the time when there were already two votes for Ice.

As soon as I made that post, charlie left Ice and went to CCM.

hmmm nevermind i'm caught up... wasnt all that much reading really....

ogre.... they could have simply just given out the password... right?

I too dont really like the idea of playing with someone i dont know. Seems fishy, and until i get further info....

I vote to lynch brains2.

I guess...

Nice point there, King.... Ogre's explanation detailing of what the mafia/unknowns should be looking for is very telling.... what a way to give a clue out Ogre!

Look, the mafia types at this point aren't stupid. They know this. I'm just putting them on notice that it won't work.

At this point we have 8 voters and 7 votees... the town has got to get together. Sure tonight is partially random, but it's a 50/50 shot.

I won't vote now, mainly because we haven't even heard from everyone.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

You are right, any townie is a big loss. But the game cannot be won for four days no matter what happens. Agreed, but why risk putting us at a disadvantage?

I never said that Z was innocent... be careful putting words in other peoples mouths (that's a mafia thing). So is pointing out things you deem "mafia things".

I said that I believe that I can tell when he is playing innocent and playing mafia. After less than 50 posts and he hadn't posted more than maybe once? Wow you are good!

My statement about Ice was made at the time when there were already two votes for Ice. So, why make the comment though? Maybe I'm missing something... he had 2 votes so you were encouraging those voting for him by basically saying (paraphrasing here) that even if he was innocent, no big loss?

See above.

 

[Weezer]

Good game but I'm not in this one.

 

[IceH2O]

HEh I knew Brains 2 was Weezer lmao. You may as well use the Weezer account since Brains 2 won't fool anyone paying attention.

Ogre my friend you do seem like you jumped to early. I think with the numbers you got to cocky. I might not be a big loss to the town IYO but there are so many more players this game you could say that about just from being newer players. Why single me out?

I had 2 votes on me at the time yes, but one claimed random and the other was charlie who will end up voting for every single person before nightfall on Sunday night. I don't really see where you have/had a case to even suggest a vote.

I on the other hand do have posts to look at and statements I deem not town friendly.

So for now I vote to Lynch Ogre

 

[IceH2O]

I'd like to pint out Weezer edited his post. He is in fact in the game. He had, and I wish I quoted him, quotes pulled on Brains 2 voters and pointed out he thinks they are a team but not sure which team they might be on.

Nice try Weezer, don't worry JM did the same thing as Brains 1 in the Zombie game. I caught hers also.

 

[Dangerdoll]

ummmmm why is that votable, Judge.... just curious

 

[Dangerdoll]

I'd like to pint out Weezer edited his post. He is in fact in the game. He had, and I wish I quoted him, quotes pulled on Brains 2 voters and pointed out he thinks they are a team but not sure which team they might be on.

Nice try Weezer, don't worry JM did the same thing as Brains 1 in the Zombie game. I caught hers also.

nice catch, Ice.....

I vote to lynch Brains2 (subject of course, to change)

 

[Dangerdoll]

Look, the mafia types at this point aren't stupid. They know this. I'm just putting them on notice that it won't work.

At this point we have 8 voters and 7 votees... the town has got to get together. Sure tonight is partially random, but it's a 50/50 shot.

I won't vote now, mainly because we haven't even heard from everyone.

who said the mafia this game were stupid? Who even said they were Mondo-smart? How do you know either way, Ogre that they wouldn't be making such posts. You indicated little clues, if anything, that was a little one that I saw and that Ice picked up on. To even try to make it seem like a stupid clue is enough for me to make you suspicious.

 

[IceH2O]

I'm in no way saying Brains 2 is mafia. Its just something that caight my eye.

In fact I'm more inclined to believe those voting for Brains 2 are mafia.

Voting for someone you don't know is not a town move IMO. Wouldn't you want to keep them around for a few days and see if they slip or are helpful?

 

[Weezer]

I'd like to pint out Weezer edited his post. He is in fact in the game. He had, and I wish I quoted him, quotes pulled on Brains 2 voters and pointed out he thinks they are a team but not sure which team they might be on.

Nice try Weezer, don't worry JM did the same thing as Brains 1 in the Zombie game. I caught hers also.

What , :huh: The post was not edited, nice trick.:nono: