Mafia #15....The Play....

[judgemax]

look, the whole point of this game, is to find the mafia, you all ask for people to talk and post, the whole game is based on theories, because mine isn't the same as yours, It must mean I am guilty, right, get over it, ..
coler:
I put it out, because that is what I was thinking, I thought last game that Lady G was the dr, I was right, won't you feel like an ***, if I am right here to.

Again, please let me state, my list, was because I wanted to see how right I was at the end of the game, thats it, i did the same thing last game, and was shockingly close, ...coler, you are quick to jump on anything that wiggles right now, any thing, to keep the spotlight off yourself?..Seriously, what do you want from me?...I am innocent, I am not defending, or looking for anyway to change votes off brains, ...If brains is mafia, let (them) hang, period.

 

[IceH2O]

I am not saying in any way, that i think brains is not mafia, if you had actually read all of my post, you would have read that. and, I think you all might think I am thinking NJ..I had that whimsical thought, ..I do know, that the brains player, is not a newbie, They are someone who has played, I could be wrong, I said before and will say it again, Its a theory, nothing more.

please4 again, do not take my saying that as me trying to convince you brains is innocent, i stated at the bottom of my post, that i still think that brains is guilty...jeez ..read before you post..


and for the record, i actually think its msjinzd, simply because i searched NJ, after I had made my original post, and she has not posted anything since july, unless rb emailed her, ITS NOT HER.(which I thought might have been possible due to the joking in the sign up thread)

however , MsJ was watching the sign up thread for quite awhile, and she always seems to be posting at the same time brains is, ..She also has a quick wit, and the post style seems to fit her, ..Like i said, its simply a theory, good lord, do you guys need an explication on the word theory?..

She has never played a single game but you don't think its a newbie.

Your theory has many holes in it.

 

[johnlarson66]

I am sure rbishop will tell us at the end of the game who brains2 was.

At this point it really does not matter. It is taking a lot away from the town.

Brians2 has had plenty of chances to defend themselves and all they have done is made it worse. They have been anti-town and most likely are mafia.

Also, this next night the mafia will hit someone. I think we will know much more day 3.

 

[Coler]

hmmm...we should get some lists up anyone who hasn't...there's a hit tonight...

of course...if they really are all over the place there's a chance they'll take out one of their own silent types

 

[judgemax]

and



how could this possibly be mee mee accidentally logged in as weezer ?

I am putting jm up on my list of suspects :

a) I don't like the 'its just a theory' line...that's the second time its come out from jm, the first with her 'think nothing of this but here's my list of mafia/innocents' and now this.
b) anyone sniffing around brains lynching and seeing if there is leeway for a different take on it has to be considered suspect at present, unless they are willing to put out a case for his innocent. JM is not doing this, relying instead on the 'its just a theory thing'

now I got all distracted from captain caveman...anyway...late here...off to bed.

–noun, plural -ries. 1.a coherent group of general propositions used as principles of explanation for a class of phenomena: Einstein's theory of relativity. 2.a proposed explanation whose status is still conjectural, in contrast to well-established propositions that are regarded as reporting matters of actual fact. 3.Mathematics. a body of principles, theorems, or the like, belonging to one subject: number theory. 4.the branch of a science or art that deals with its principles or methods, as distinguished from its practice: music theory. 5.a particular conception or view of something to be done or of the method of doing it; a system of rules or principles. 6.contemplation or speculation. 7.guess or conjecture.

the game is about theories...we read each other's posts...we evaluate their meaning, then their significance, in an effort to discover the source/motive.

exactly, so why the big deal when I put out a theory?...I may be wrong, but I am willing to admit that, ..I am not trying to discredit your theories, whats the big deal if I have one?...

 

[Coler]

coler:
I put it out, because that is what I was thinking, I thought last game that Lady G was the dr, I was right, won't you feel like an ***, if I am right here to.

no honestly I will not...could care less

...coler, you are quick to jump on anything that wiggles right now, any thing, to keep the spotlight off yourself?..Seriously, what do you want from me?...I am innocent, I am not defending, or looking for anyway to change votes off brains, ...If brains is mafia, let (them) hang, period.

no honestly I am not (quick to jump on anything that wiggles)...I just like kicking around a bit...I really do not feel as if I have the spotlight on myself...I think you are looking uncomfortable under it though and that really has got my spidey senses tingling

my comments in blue

 

[judgemax]

She has never played a single game but you don't think its a newbie.

Your theory has many holes in it.

ok, so it does, I thought it might have been NJ but when I started looking I noticed The msj thing, the whole point of a theory is to discuss it, so, I have stated that I could be wrong, again, not afraid to admit that, ..not at any point claiming its truth, or asking you to remove your vote, I was thinking and typing out loud, you all wanted me more vocal, I tried, and got basically told I was an idiot, for giving a thought, next time, I will ask permission first OK?..:wall:

 

[judgemax]

Coler I hope I do have you looking at me, I hope you all do, thats the point of the game, and no, I can tell you, I am hardly uncomfortable, just frustrated. :silly:

 

[Coler]

well...be more vocal...but what is the god honest point about being more vocal about this thing if that is your effort to allay suspicions about you being non-vocal. It's completely non-constructive - you even admit that yourself now that we're talking about it. It also does not appear to be logically sound.

 

[Coler]

so :

brains - my mafia vote

other candidates :

plantling (I know I know. I will try to put a more solid set of reasons together next game day...and will see what the response is)
JM - just of late
Lady G
JL

Don't knows (i.e. concern)

HN
KOTD (a lil less he has posted like this before when innocent in fact he is a more active player as a mafia from my recollection when playing as mafia with him at least)
Bkw - in a big way (the concern)
ZS - (ditto)
Charlie - quiet most recently and I have said before I don't have a read on him...I feel happier when he is at his loudest in many ways though.
Joander
Blueiz

Leaning innocent :

DD

Either 100% innocent or pulled off a major mafia sacrifice (unlikely)

Ice

genuinely don't know what to think

mee mee

to be looked at in the cold light of day

Capt. Caveman