THE PLAY: Mafia #16 'Till death do we part...

[Liz]

me:"Why are we all posting as townies out to get the mafia. Why don't we put a spin on things and post as the mafia out to terrorize the townies?"
hooked newbie: "This looks like an admission to me. The majority of us are townies. This is our town. That is why."

in retrospect, that statement I made seems like a silly reason to suspect someone? He was the first to really suspect me, based on that post alone.In his post he's also kind of pushing the point that he is a townie.

 

[Dangerdoll]

but he had them NUMBERED. I could see that he only had two if it was a list of suspects but DD...come on

pappy, I know they were numbered. My point is, because of the early post, being so early in the game, what is to stop people from putting 2 people out there?? One toward innocent, one toward guilty??

 

[Liz]

I also took it literally.

 

[Lady G]

DD, I'm sorry but I'm not buying it. You are always so careful it's just not you to make such a mistake. The way I see this, is you are mafia and trying to "look" helpful, since we have all mentioned in the last couple games how you sit back and come out only when called upon when you are mafia...I think maybe you decided to TRY and at least "look" to be helpful.

 

[jpappy789]

pappy, I know they were numbered. My point is, because of the early post, being so early in the game, what is to stop people from putting 2 people out there?? One toward innocent, one toward guilty??

DD, I vaguely remember you getting on my back for posting a list early that was a joke and now you are saying that it is acceptable? Am I understanding you correctly?

He chose rb and kuhli because kuhli made a comment about rb beating his movers. Go read the back and forth if you do not belive me (or you were skimming). Jo obviously was being sarcastic about kuhli having a "good find" and that making rb mafia.

 

[Dangerdoll]

if you all feel that way, then by all means, lynch me. I don't know if I would feel that same way. For the record, I was loaded with work this morning and trying to be helpful, trying to put things out for the town to discuss. There's nothing I think that should be swept under the carpet for a reason such as "so and so is new, pardon them"... All I can say and I know it's cliche but it will be a mistake. Mark my words.

 

[jpappy789]

I also took it literally.

I dont want to seem rude but I can sort of understand you taking it literally, but DD no. Its not like her.

I am sure that DD will come out and say "See look at her. I am not the only one."

The thing that gets me is that you still don't get the sarcasm after jo said it was sarcastic. You even posted after that thanking him for telling you that.

 

[Liz]

haha was that an insult to my intelligence?

if so that would be kind of silly.

 

[Dangerdoll]

DD, I vaguely remember you getting on my back for posting a list early that was a joke and now you are saying that it is acceptable? Am I understanding you correctly?

He chose rb and kuhli because kuhli made a comment about rb beating his movers. Go read the back and forth if you do not belive me (or you were skimming). Jo obviously was being sarcastic about kuhli having a "good find" and that making rb mafia.

where am I saying the list is acceptable?? I voted for you for the list, I also voted for Jo. Where did I say the list was acceptable. I voted for Jo simply for different reasons BECAUSE of the list. No twisting please, Pappy.

My initial feeling was that the post wasn't sarcastic which resulted in my vote.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

my take so far is that Liz is a confused newb, and those voting for her now are mafia scumbags desperate for a spot to park their votes.
Paul posted in the cichlid forum, but not here.....hmmmmm....i think i bagged me a scumbag already