THE PLAY: Mafia #16 'Till death do we part...

[Lady G]

Another thought then I am off till morning. I think we should be wary about believing Brains2 to be innocent. Although it would only be fair to make the new player innocent, since a innocent was wrongly killed off, at the same time this would make for an easy target for a mafia "hit". I doubt she would make Brains2 the Preacher, at least I hope she wouldn't and would of chose a innocent already playing for that role, or maybe switched off a mafia and made them the preacher and then Brains2 could come back as a mafia? I think we should wait and see their postings and decide innocent or mafia the same way we do everyone else, I don't want to assume either way simply b/c if we do believe them innocent they are a sure hit for the mafia, but if we assume them mafia they are an easy target for the innocents either way it would be unfair for one side, I am more apt to believe they were random generated just like the rest of us and if came up innocent another innocent got the role as preacher but if came up mafia, then a original mafia would have to become innocent and the preacher.

 

[brains2]

Looks around wondering why these people are so worried one way or another of my innocents. I haven't done any thing honest.

 

[Lady G]

Welcome to the game Brains2

 

[Reefscape]

Hey there brains2...Welcome...Lets hope you have help us even the score and take down some mafia scum as the attrition rate over night did not help us at all....

Hopefully today, there will be less bickering and more mafia hunting...all the bickering does is really make people look suspicious..

 

[IceH2O]

Oh, thats entertaining, it "clears" him because he picked up on something... like he ever was a real suspect to begin with?

Why do mafia always leave off the important words of a post?

Did you skim over the part that said SOMEWHAT clears him in my mind?

I pulled the post and bolded the sentence, you must have missed it while skimming.





Made this post while wife paused to put son back into bed


You're not exactly helping clear yourself in my mind HN.

I don't care. All you can do is hit me. A case on me has way too many holes and I am comfortable with being a townie.

Missing comments.

Trying to point fingers at me for defending an innocent person.

I'm not expecting anyone to assume I'm innocent just because I was able to see through the push for votes on DD. I admit she made some out of norm posts but thats why I figured her innocent. She doesn't screw up like that most of the time. As I said I'm thinking shes just had a bad game, a bit of burn out.

Oh my... now you know whether or not someone is innocent even if they make out of norm posts? How do you find mafia then? So far it doesn't seem like you've looked. You put your vote on someone who was not at risk, that you could make a VERY basic case against and have attacked anyone that tried to get a mafia on night one. I guess you expected to be chosen huh? Oh yeah, Charlie... way to follow with the "I'll ride that train". I invite anyone who thinks I am guilty to vote for me, make a case, campaign for me to be gone. I just don't buy it and since I think I'll be gone soon enough..

I Vote to lynch Iceh2o.


I'd reason that Brains 2 is innocent just because they lost an innocent to a misfire on the hit.



HN I'm going to bed so if I disappear thats why. I bolded it for you so you can't miss it. Maybe you should make an eye appointment and get some glasses.

HNs comments are in blue. It wouldn't carry over for me.

You did the same thing that Jo did. Took part of a sentence and tried to turn it as evidence on me. If you would have continued to read you'd see I came to the conclusion because its out of the norm for her. DD doesn't usually screw up in either role. For her to screw up this early had to be from burnout IMO.

Keep the heat on me HN. It just makes you look more mafia, especially when you lynch another innocent.

Are you just going to use the excuse that you're having a bad game like all the mafia do when they lynch numerous innocents?

None of my posts make me look mafia as you think. The only ones that do are the ones that you and Jo twisted or left important words out of when commenting about them.


I don't even understand the part about knowing I'd be chosen. I think if anything, putting the heat on myself would keep me from getting chosen.

I protected DD because I could tell she wasn't mafia plain and simple. I went after you guys because you were attacking an innocent person and pushing hard for it. Doesn't mean you are all mafia but 1 or 2 of that group I believe is and since Jo pushed the hardest for DD I voted him.

I'd be more then willing to switch to Jpap as he is a top suspect also and why my vote was on him. Especially after admitting he twisted DDs posts.But I didn't see a reason last night to switch to Jo as it would have netted the same result.

You can call it a safe vote if you want. But I didn't think either was mafia so why would I vote to lynch one.

Another thought then I am off till morning. I think we should be wary about believing Brains2 to be innocent. Although it would only be fair to make the new player innocent, since a innocent was wrongly killed off, at the same time this would make for an easy target for a mafia "hit". I doubt she would make Brains2 the Preacher, at least I hope she wouldn't and would of chose a innocent already playing for that role, or maybe switched off a mafia and made them the preacher and then Brains2 could come back as a mafia? I think we should wait and see their postings and decide innocent or mafia the same way we do everyone else, I don't want to assume either way simply b/c if we do believe them innocent they are a sure hit for the mafia, but if we assume them mafia they are an easy target for the innocents either way it would be unfair for one side, I am more apt to believe they were random generated just like the rest of us and if came up innocent another innocent got the role as preacher but if came up mafia, then a original mafia would have to become innocent and the preacher.

Ok thats possible as the mafia wouldn't have had a partner yet and not know other mafia players.


Since I had an extremely early day I'm going to take care of some things around the house or sneak out when my wife picks up the kids from school and go play some Madden. Either way I'll be back on later.

 

[Lady G]

Lady G doesn't know what to think, how could she believe the stories about her dear friend DD were true. DD was acting so strange it was hard not to believe them. First the wedding then the town and her own friend turned on her. What a sad place ACville has become, Lady G thinks about all the things that happen here and wonders why she stays, when she first moved to ACville Warewolves were taking over the town, then there were zombies, vampires and the endless runs with the mafia. What is it about this town that make ppl stay?

Then there was poor Reverend Sploke, how could that happen to our preacher..he gave such a good sermon on Sundays mornings, he will be sadly missed.

John Larson had a family, he finally got that drunken Jmax to quit passing out in his back yard..now what will his family do, she'll be back Lady G can just feel it, poor Mrs. Larson and their children will have to deal with that alone now, maybe Lady will offer to spray Jmax down with the hose for them if drunken Jmax does return.

Then the new guy in town, no one got to know him. Did he sense all the trouble this town can bring on a person? Did he see the way the town and friends turned on one of their own and decide he just couldn't handle it here, was he afraid he would never be able to leave this God forsaken town...like the rest of us.

Just as Lady G was passing Meems old shop she could see movement inside..she knew who it was, she wanted so badly to go inside and just kill them all!! Sher terror is what stopped her, she didn't know if she could handle actually seeing who's face was behind those walls. If she did she's afraid it would be the last face she ever saw, no it is best to take care of them as a town, if we could just figure out who they were and stop killing our innocents.

 

[plantling]

After rereading the events leading up to nightfall, I also come away with the feeling that Jo really pushed the hardest for DD to be lynched.

i agree with RB, liz is def. not off my suspect list yet either... i just think that DD is a better candidate at this point.

Jo agrees Liz is suspicious but thinks DD is a better candidate.

I agree that we should pay attention to that as well, but DD did the same thing on a worse scale... at least IMO.

But ok now im really done for the night.

Here Jo agrees Jp should be paid attention to but comments that what DD did was worse.

Lady G has a way of speaking my mind for me...the comma thing was not what all the to do was over....

Here Jo agrees w/a Lady G post about DD being suspicious and adds that Jp's "comma thing was not what the to was over."

hey guys, doesnt seem like much has happened in my absence...im happy with either a Liz or a DD vote to be honest, but leaning more towards DD at this point and i will keep my vote there for now...

Here Jo he'd be happy w/a Liz or DD vote but leaning more towards DD.

Ice, to be honest i have very little to say in response to your attack on me.. I think your over analyzing.


The rb (agreeing and disagreeing) argument.. i thought it was a nice find, but i didnt say it wasnt worth following up, just not at this point as it is to early.

I don't understand how i seem to be following.... seems to me that this whole entire DD thing was started by me, not followed by me.

You also say that now that i have DD on the ropes im switching to attacking Liz... well thats because they are my top 2 suspects tonight and im happy to see a lynch on either... if DD goes tonight then i will vote Liz tomorrow....

about defending jpap.... it seems to me that what he missed was a lot easier to miss than what DD missed... although i do still think that he should be watched.. i've said that since the beginning ice.


but i dont understand how im following? Because i said LG spoke my mind? Well she did... i was about to reply to the thread in almost those exact words....


as too the 48 hours thing.. i just dont like how it takes so long to have a day go by, i like it more when there are fewer people left and there are 24 hour days towards the end of the game

and finally too the newbs not talking thing... when newbies like Liz make a lot of posts like she has.. it just confuses the **** outa everyone and creates a big jumbled mess because they dont know if shes playing the "im confused" card, or if she really is confused.



Well... i guess i lied i did have a little bit to say in response..

Jo claims the whole entire DD thing was started by him and that he wasn't following. Although if I'm correct Jo's vote was actually the 4th on DD after CL, Jp, and LG. He also states he wants to vote DD off then, Liz. And he states again that the comma that Jp missed was a lot easier to miss than what DD missed.

of course you do, hes the only one left sticking up for you.

I find this post of Jo's to be a bit severe. Jo is commenting on DD's post where she agreed w/Ice.

next on my list was liz, she will likely get my next vote. I'm sorry for being wrong about DD, but i truly felt she was mafia. I would do it all over again if it came down to it, well given the information i had then.

My vote will probably fall on liz, however Ice... dont think your out of the woods just because DD was innocent.

Right after night Jo states he will likely vote Liz next and though he was wrong about DD he would do it all over again? What an apology.

Based on these posts, I vote to lynch Jo.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

upon review of last nights posts I feel Jo pushed the hardest to lynch DD.
I retract my vote for Jpap, and vote to lynch Joe

 

[Blueiz]

I agree fully with Charlie.

I vote to lynch Jo. (subj to change at any time)

 

[Lady G]

Guy's you know I fully intended on coming on today and going right after Ice, cause he defended DD soooooo much, and I don't remember ever seeing him defend someone quite like that before. I really figured he was mafia, thinking she was mafia and didn't want her lynched for this reason. That played a small role in my being so sure she was mafia, I figured there was more to it than Ice thinking she was innocent. At one point I did get scared and was going to pull my vote from her, thought maybe they were a "innocent" team the preacher/ counselor I had to go back and read the rules to see if they could communicate from the get go, but they couldn't so I knew that wasn't it.

Really I don't know what to think at this time, I don't know what I think of Ice's defense of DD, I'm not sure that really makes him mafia though.

As far as Jo, I can maybe see it. I have to reread the threads and see if I see anything, I do not have the time right now and was going to do it this morning when I had more time, but the site was down so I couldn't.