THE PLAY: Mafia #16 'Till death do we part...

[Blueiz]

No assumptions, just logic. Why do you think she would replace Sploke with a mafia member?

sigh, looks like i will go down too.

All i can say is i truly thought DD was mafia. I pushed the hardest for her because i honestly thought that she was mafia, as did LG and HN and Jpap and others too im sure.... if you are going to lynch me you're going to lynch me theres nothing i can do, but do the town a favor and lets not start off 0-2 with the lynches.

My next candidate for a lynch would be liz or kulhi. Kuhli doesnt seem to be following the game well at all, nor does liz really. There both a shot in the dark, but neither of them seem to be doing us much good either.

I vote to lynch Kuhli

also, DC has been way to quiet, as has atnixon... i would personally say that 1 of them is mafia.

You are gong to lynch kuhli for the reason bolded above? I find that extremely anti town. Can you back up your vote with evidence?

 

[Lady G]

im missing how everyone can "see the case" for me.... WHAT FREAKING CASE... i was WRONG... i admit it so wasnt LG, so wasnt HN, so wasnt everyone else who voted for DD!

Because i pushed harder to get people to feel the same way as i felt i must be mafia?
You guys have seen me in games when im mafia... im not usually vocal... this has been by far my most vocal game yet... if i was mafia why would i have pushed so hard to get someone lynched? If i truly was mafia i wouldn't have cared who got lynched as long as it wasnt me! Do you guys not understand this?

I'm not really ready to say there is a case against you Jo, I said maybe but I haven't really looked back yet. Although I do have to agree with the fact you usually do not speak quite so loudly about things, that I remember. The last game we played and you were mafia you were one of the most quiet I do believe.

Really I would like to hear more from Kuhli right now, and not the "joking" Kuhli some actual thoughts would be nice.

 

[Blueiz]

Sorry, the quote by HN was not suppose to be in my last post.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I dont feel i have been that quiet since its my first game...Mearly pointed out my thoughts along the way..When your innocent, you dont have to start twisting peoples words or anything of the sort as you have nothing to hide or twist...It seems to me so far that some really do have a lot to say for themselves and appear to find it rather too easy to start throwing out retorts to peoples comments..why retort if your innocent? something to hide perhaps? hmmm...i would say so..

Not sure where my vote lies yet...HN and Ice are on my radar simply because of the war of words from day one..something is not right and i have yet to put my finger on it..

If everyone sat back and posted with any one style there would be very little information gained and the mafia could blend in and pick everyone off. I choose (and have everygame) to "go on the attack" a bit and I will place votes on people to see their reactions to them and the reactions of others. As obnoxious as it may be, I've found it to work pretty well and besides, obnoxious fits my personality. :lipssealedsmilie:

I think everyone should suspect everyone, especially early in the game so I am fine being on your radar screen.

 

[jpappy789]

sigh, looks like i will go down too.

All i can say is i truly thought DD was mafia. I pushed the hardest for her because i honestly thought that she was mafia, as did LG and HN and Jpap and others too im sure.... if you are going to lynch me you're going to lynch me theres nothing i can do, but do the town a favor and lets not start off 0-2 with the lynches.

My next candidate for a lynch would be liz or kulhi. Kuhli doesnt seem to be following the game well at all, nor does liz really. There both a shot in the dark, but neither of them seem to be doing us much good either.

I vote to lynch Kuhli

also, DC has been way to quiet, as has atnixon... i would personally say that 1 of them is mafia.

Jo...ummm...hmmm, not sure I agree with you. You name the 3 newbs as suspicious or not helping or a combonation. Somehow this does not seem fair as it WAS their first day and this is their first game. How much "good" do you expect them to be doing?

I would vote for you but I think most votes will fall on you anyways. I noticed you following quite a lot and many pointed it out but I was too concerned with DD and got carried away at the time to comment. I also believe that plant put some good evidence out there against you.

Hn and Ice are on my radar, but it would not be the first time that two innocents sparred like that so I am not 100% counting on one of them being mafia. Hard problem is deciding which one would most likely be scum if I end up needing to decide...

DC, rb, blue, and chas have all been sort of 'non-comittal' in a sense. Not sure that is right word to describe what I mean, but its hard to explain. Mostly they dont have a whole lot to say on certain things that others are really talking about. Maybe its just me, and it probably is. Not using this against any of them just an observation I have made. Of course amount of time to actually read through the thread and post is an issue for some, so thats why I am not really accusing them. Just my thoughts, now I am ramling...

My guess is brains2 is innocent. And I know we cannot count on that but it makes sense to me. Why replace an innocent with a mafia? Especially since they would most likely need to choose a partner and we would be screwed. An easy target for mafia but HOPEFULLY jm didn't make them the preach, then we'd be in a bigger hole...

 

[Blueiz]

I dont feel i have been that quiet since its my first game...Mearly pointed out my thoughts along the way..When your innocent, you dont have to start twisting peoples words or anything of the sort as you have nothing to hide or twist...It seems to me so far that some really do have a lot to say for themselves and appear to find it rather too easy to start throwing out retorts to peoples comments..why retort if your innocent? something to hide perhaps? hmmm...i would say so..

Not sure where my vote lies yet...HN and Ice are on my radar simply because of the war of words from day one..something is not right and i have yet to put my finger on it..

The goal is to put thoughts and suspicions out there. If someone is called out, they are going to defend themselves.. This is how we try to figure out who is who. We cant just sit back and look at each other to find this out..

 

[jpappy789]

Just to clarify...I would like to see more activity from the newbs of course, not giving them a free ride, but I don't agree with jo's suspicions of them after one day

 

[IceH2O]

Comments & questions in Blue.

It was a feeling and it was right on. DD does not screw up that easily. I don't expect any vet to screw up like that. Ogre didn't really screw up as much as he took a chance and it backfired.

I put you and Jo together because you were the 2 attacking me for defending what ended up being an innocent. Not my fault you couldn't see it.

Yes, but the Mod? C'mon. If that were true, we might as well suspect that there are roles that haven't been included in the rules or that all the mafia can talk. Judge flubbed up and admitted it, so I think she'd even it up. If Brains is mafia, then I'd think one of the mafia were turned innocent.

Guess HN skimmed past this post by LG( find below). Mafia tend to do that when they are focused on one person.

Another thought then I am off till morning. I think we should be wary about believing Brains2 to be innocent. Although it would only be fair to make the new player innocent, since a innocent was wrongly killed off, at the same time this would make for an easy target for a mafia "hit". I doubt she would make Brains2 the Preacher, at least I hope she wouldn't and would of chose a innocent already playing for that role, or maybe switched off a mafia and made them the preacher and then Brains2 could come back as a mafia? I think we should wait and see their postings and decide innocent or mafia the same way we do everyone else, I don't want to assume either way simply b/c if we do believe them innocent they are a sure hit for the mafia, but if we assume them mafia they are an easy target for the innocents either way it would be unfair for one side, I am more apt to believe they were random generated just like the rest of us and if came up innocent another innocent got the role as preacher but if came up mafia, then a original mafia would have to become innocent and the preacher.

HN if you're just going to keep bringing up yesterdays vote the entire game I'm done answering for it. Because I was able to see that DD was innocent is not a reason to suspect me as mafia this game.

The setup isn't the same. In past games it would be a great vote on me as then the mafia know the innocents. This game doesn't work that way.

The mafia are in the dark as much as the innocents are. We need to use that to our advantage. Not use it to turn other innocents into lynch victims.

 

[Reefscape]

JPappy....Why highlight my name in post 575 but not make a comment? is this a secret code to your spouse or something?

 

[IceH2O]

sigh, looks like i will go down too.

All i can say is i truly thought DD was mafia. I pushed the hardest for her because i honestly thought that she was mafia, as did LG and HN and Jpap and others too im sure.... if you are going to lynch me you're going to lynch me theres nothing i can do, but do the town a favor and lets not start off 0-2 with the lynches.

My next candidate for a lynch would be liz or kulhi. Kuhli doesnt seem to be following the game well at all, nor does liz really. There both a shot in the dark, but neither of them seem to be doing us much good either.

I vote to lynch Kuhli

also, DC has been way to quiet, as has atnixon... i would personally say that 1 of them is mafia.

im missing how everyone can "see the case" for me.... WHAT FREAKING CASE... i was WRONG... i admit it so wasnt LG, so wasnt HN, so wasnt everyone else who voted for DD!

Because i pushed harder to get people to feel the same way as i felt i must be mafia?
You guys have seen me in games when im mafia... im not usually vocal... this has been by far my most vocal game yet... if i was mafia why would i have pushed so hard to get someone lynched? If i truly was mafia i wouldn't have cared who got lynched as long as it wasnt me! Do you guys not understand this?

To funny. At this point I don't even need to try to continue a case against you as you're doing it for me.

You're voting for Kuhli based on a shot in the dark? Because they haven't been much help?

A lot of people have been not posting much or knocking down doors. Why not mention them, why pick on the newbs when the Vets in hiding are more suspect for not contributing?