i just got 3 female/1 male guppies, but which tank do i add them to?

[AquariumNoob13]

one of the females is pregnant, and so might the other 2, but i do not know whether to add them to my mbuna tank (contains 2 socolofi, 3 yellow labs, 2 mollies, 1 JD) or do i add them to my oscar tank (1 small albino oscar)? i want them to have fry, but at the same time, i want them to survive also. so which tank will they have the most likely chance to survive in? (the mbuna tank has a rock cave, a copper domed castle, and lots of plants)

 

[Lupin]

Neither.:screwy: Besides, use logic. Both are not community fish.

 

[elementkid65]

:rofl: that was a great idea gettin those guppys

 

[AquariumNoob13]

hahaha. my friend had like 40 guppies in a 10 gallon so he told me to take some. =/

 

[tarheels910]

They will be eaten in both tanks.

 

[wataugachicken]

if you have any compassion for the guppies. . . . they will be eaten more quickly in the oscar tank. the africans would probably shred them rather than swallow them whole.

 

[lucky777ca]

If it is an option, I would suggest to put the guppies in another tank with lots of cover. In both of the tanks mentioned, they will not survive for long (the adults and the babies).

 

[tarheels910]

Lets see the options.

10 gallon with an Oscar.

29 gallon with Africans and a JD.

Stop taking in fish. You dont have any room for the fish you have, let alone more.

 

[AquariumNoob13]

come december 4th i will have room.

 

[tarheels910]

come december 4th i will have room.

Sorry to burst your bubble, but you will need a 75 for the oscar alone. The mollies and guppies will eventually get eaten unless they have their own tank.