Mafia #18 The Santa Game

[Sploke]

I am also a little alarmed with the large post of quotes from andi.

Alarmed? I thought it was really helpful, to isolate the back-and-forth between those two. I know it saved me a lot of trouble anyway.

 

[Sploke]

and another thing everyone is so quick to jump on atnixon being evil, but what if he was evil would he act that way? what if he really is playing it that he is innocent but he is keeping the focus off someone else. Or it could be that he is really evil and he is protecting someone.

My concern about niko is that he was never really answering questions, just giving these little contradictory, cryptic hints. Not being straightforward, or looking like you're purposefully trying to be coy or cryptic, does no one any favors.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Alright this goea out to Plantling post #296 will somone please tell me how and where I am following I have explained my thought and reasons. I was a misunderstanding on my part. But I have also stated that after reading all the posts thus far who some of my top suspects were. I am not a follower I just happen to think out loud.

Beth, here's the post where you voted for me. The whole thing basically says, 'I agree with Coler, therefore, I second his vote.' That's following.

I think Coler might have a point Madcrawdad, you said that hunting down Blitzen is scummier than trying to hunt down the evil elves, but you have never mentioned hunting them down yourself. Only critizing those who wanted to go after Blitzen, I think I might second Coler, only becuase that seems to weird. If I am on later also I will review. But I think I will say I vote to lynch Madcrawdad.

 

[Coler]

Ice explaining Mad and HN doesn't necessarily make them a team. I would think they would try and be less obvious. I have them leaning innocent, though.

Bethkira is following, could be authentic newb confusion and could be evil trying to blend in.

Jmax was suspicious to me, too. Since her role had to be replaced, I'm thinking she was an evil and now someone who was innocent prior is now evil. Tells would be someone suddenly going quiet or changing their views on pple they suspected before.

I agree with all of that...there might be some question of whether Judge if evil leaving the game means a goodguy was made evil...could have just given the power/role to another on same team.

I have a sorta sneaky suspicion she was in fact Blitzen myself but this is speculation...but did have her leaning evil prior to her having to unfortunately retire.

 

[Coler]

Beth, here's the post where you voted for me. The whole thing basically says, 'I agree with Coler, therefore, I second his vote.' That's following.

yep...thanks for pulling them out, that's indicative of what I was talking about

 

[Coler]

JL - I'm surprised to be your top suspect to be honest but so be it.

I am not surprised at the lack of any team effort to vote me out - the bad guys are going to kill me tonight and they know it.

CL and I are most certainly not on the same/any team. If we are on the same side it will be because CL is good, as am I...I am thinking deeply about the vote, remembering Ogre from zombie mafia and a prior game where CL got kicked early but I'm keeping it where it is for now.

 

[Coler]

the way I see it with CL, one way or another he came out with a panic defence and then voted for himself...I have to say, on day 1, you will rarely get such clear signs of scumminess.

 

[bethkira2000]

I did it once but I was not following he happen to make a good point that was all I jumped into to quickly, being a newb cut me some slack. It is not like I keep doing it. so may the two of you are followers hmmm.

 

[clown-lover]

the way I see it with CL, one way or another he came out with a panic defence and then voted for himself...I have to say, on day 1, you will rarely get such clear signs of scumminess.

If people wish to vote me out they can.. I will not harbor them any ill will Coler.. But like I said when I die and am shown innocent I hope the votes immediately stop on your doorstep and people see past this facade that you have surrounded yourself.

JL - I'm surprised to be your top suspect to be honest but so be it.

I am not surprised at the lack of any team effort to vote me out - the bad guys are going to kill me tonight and they know it.

CL and I are most certainly not on the same/any team. If we are on the same side it will be because CL is good, as am I...I am thinking deeply about the vote, remembering Ogre from zombie mafia and a prior game where CL got kicked early but I'm keeping it where it is for now.

Why would they hit one of their own Coler? Your either in league with them or their boss..

 

[gupman]

from what I see is you seem pretty combative, Coler... not sure why

Short to the point A little evasive If you ask me..Not sure why? saw a little bit of the other game and you posted more then this?