Mafia #18 The Santa Game

[Grins]

Ok, I'm caught up. At this point I'm not exactly sure who is out to cause the town harm but even a newbie can figure out what looks suspicious. To me Clown-lover seems to be intentionally provoking responses from Coler especially. On top of that I don't like the voting for himself to be lynched. Seemed like a ploy to use reverse pysch and then when called on it his explanations seemed really suspect. Plus...well that avatar is just downright creepy. :lipssealedsmilie:

I vote to lynch Clown-lover.

 

[Reefscape]

wow Niko.... need a shovel?

Nope

 

[Coler]

I think I have made my opinions on you clear coler...its not like I am pushing for votes on you.

no you havn't...you just stuck a vote on the minute I voted for CL

I know you are not pushing for votes on me...there's no point, is there.

I said it before and I repeat it now...if CL is innocent please, CL, come out and put some stuff up here that rings true.

 

[Coler]

I retract my vote on coler and vote to lynch andi

I am sure coler will mention my vote change off of him but anyways andis response do not make any sense at all...some of cls recent posts, including the self vote, arent sitting well with me either though I do not see it as a complete sign of scumminess. If I remember correctly KOTD did this a few times when innocent but as mentioned mafia have done it as well so imo CL needs further watching. Still suspicious of coler because for some reason he felt that he didnt need to mention his explanatiom for voting cl at the time...because he thought it was obvious??? KOTD and kuhli are way too quiet. Kuhli was very active last game (when he was alive) so I thought I would at least see more posts from him...is somone trying to hush him up? Niko still suspicious but nothing recent has really come from him that would further my suspicions. Also beths self vote has me confused...this town is going crazy

SO my top suspects:

andi
coler
Kuhli
niko

just check the list folks...does anyone seriously at this point in a pretty active day one have kuhli in their list of say 'three or four people I might vote for'

 

[jpappy789]

no i don't think anything of your vote change off me...your only reason for voting for me was because I voted CL...and no one else has come on board...does andi has votes on i.e. is a possible lynch ahead of CL ?

so..your still suspicious of me...but andi's post made less sense than my 'unexplained' vote for CL ? Then you pick out a low poster, and try and piggyback on other peoples suspicion of niko ??

this is really triggering my spidey senses jpapp...I think you're just naming people who you reckon others might just fix on...its been clear that you couldn't get anything going on me...so you're changing horses mid race...very dodgy.

no coler, I voted for you because you didnt explain yourself when you voted and you know that a "random" vote is suspicious, it didnt matter who you voted for. but then you got a reaction from cl, one that may be useful in the future if something else suspicious comes from him. and you were acting oddly last night so I figured you were just going crazy at the time...

and you cant disagree that andi has made absolutely NO sense from basically the beginning but then lg showed up and started posting about beth and that really got me worried so I switched again.

I dont know why it matters that I "picked on" a low posted. I explained my suspicions based on kuhlis activity last game and I am still confused as to why he is so quiet.

And I mentioned way earlier that niko was suspicious and I didnt see anything from him to prove otherwise at this time so yeah he is still on my list/

 

[Lady G]

Well, I just wanted to post and apologize to everyone. I should not of blew up at you all for my RL issues, I am sorry.
Go ahead and vote me, I'm sure it will happen anyway.

But I'm not going to vote someone I know is NOT evil, I may of seemed that way and yeah, I'd jump me too for what I did but I retract my vote on LG and vote to lynch Andi

Read what you want to into it.

 

[jpappy789]

just check the list folks...does anyone seriously at this point in a pretty active day one have kuhli in their list of say 'three or four people I might vote for'

ok coler...how is this suspisious? is there a reason for him not to be on my list at that point? had he shown up, and even if he does now, I think he still has some explaining to do. Just because he isnt here doesnt mean he is innocent. I think it is obvious as well that at 3rd on my list of four I wouldnt consider voting for him today.

 

[jpappy789]

Well, I just wanted to post and apologize to everyone. I should not of blew up at you all for my RL issues, I am sorry.
Go ahead and vote me, I'm sure it will happen anyway.

But I'm not going to vote someone I know is NOT evil, I may of seemed that way and yeah, I'd jump me too for what I did but I retract my vote on LG and vote to lynch Andi

Read what you want to into it.

hmmmm...lg could have just as easily voted for cl and made it closer but she chose andi...although possibly because she was thinking about changing to her earlier...is this really innocent play or is it just supposed to appear that way?

 

[Coler]

no coler, I voted for you because you didnt explain yourself when you voted and you know that a "random" vote is suspicious, it didnt matter who you voted for.

it wasn't random - of course it looked that way but I notice you arn't bothering to defend CL

but then you got a reaction from cl, one that may be useful in the future if something else suspicious comes from him. and you were acting oddly last night so I figured you were just going crazy at the time...

anything else suspicious - what like voting for himself ? I was acting oddly...I laugh out loud; so many people post this nonsense 'coler doesn't seem himsel' 'coler seems less relaxed'...'coler is acting oddly'...what does this mean exactly ? use less adjectives and more analysis please.

and you cant disagree that andi has made absolutely NO sense from basically the beginning but then lg showed up and started posting about beth and that really got me worried so I switched again.

whatever...andi may well be evil...bizarre choice for your top nomination though.

I dont know why it matters that I "picked on" a low posted. I explained my suspicions based on kuhlis activity last game and I am still confused as to why he is so quiet.

what is confusing you ? the guy is not playing the game end of story in my opinion...you're just trying to pull out possible mob candidates and hoping somone salutes.

And I mentioned way earlier that niko was suspicious and I didnt see anything from him to prove otherwise at this time so yeah he is still on my list/

ok...so andi is top choice for some vague LG related reason, kuhli is on the list for not posting and niko was always suspicious and you have no reason to change that opinion...and you started this vote on me for voting CL and I still haven't given you my reasons...confused ? I think I now agree that you are.

 

[Coler]

hmmmm...lg could have just as easily voted for cl and made it closer but she chose andi...although possibly because she was thinking about changing to her earlier...is this really innocent play or is it just supposed to appear that way?

you must be happy enough..she's voting with you right ?