Mafia #20 - Pirates of the Carribean the Play

[Hooked Newbie]

Rb- Jpap has definitely not added much up to this point, but his points this evening seem to be pretty valid. Why so defensive? Do you in fact have any thoughts or are you content to just post in defense? Why are you solely concerned about post count? (You may need to add some more smily only posts to bump up your count). You also seem to go back and forth whenever convenient on whether or not RL issues are valid reasons for not posting. I for one would like to see your thoughts on people.

So have you had RL issues today or have you been laying low?

Skimming again Ice, or just trying to continue the choo-choo? If you don't agree with the poster, it is easy to say their info doesn't help. When you know your team mates it is easy to pick your alignment.

I am looking at JM, Jpap, JL66 and you mainly...though I seriously think Malbri is getting some very recent coaching....she couldn't make the posts she did today without a lot of advice. Everything up till now has just been the normal chat room comments from her and she has just repeated back what so many of you are jumping on.

Remember, you asked....be sure to turn it into a defensive post from me.

It is amazing you can conclude two posts from some one as helping when they have basically ignored the game. Ice, do you know of anyone who stated they were going to vote for the low posters because they deserved it, newbies or night.....I could link you to it, but just do a thread search for your name in the sign up thread. Guess, I'll add you to my target list of those to lynch, Ice.

Bob- you seem confused. I asked those questions. Why the need to focus on Ice and ignore my questions?

 

[Grins]

Grins....you of all people should know where the pirates have been all day...

You bet'cha..and I already have told you. You're all in pirate chat trying to save your pirate tush. I'd not be surprised to hear that little Mal is a pirate and you've told her to say what you've told her just so you can claim someone out there is coaching the girl.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I'm not concerned about post counts at all Hooked. I guess I could ignore the question, then when I didn't answer I could be laying low....

Seems we have several folks all up in arms (as pirates would be) over me. Good to hear, you have someone to go for without having to actually scheme and carry out a plot.

I'm "up in arms" too and I think you're a pirate. The folks you're attacking seem to have been the ones being most helpful to the town. I could still go either way with Jpap though. I simply wanted your input and you seemed to not want to provide any that wasn't of your own initiative.

 

[Grins]

I don't believe he qouted times, grins...I guess you are adding to his statements....

I added them so you and your pirate friends couldn't try to throw some silly meaningless claim in there again. Those times are direct links to your two posts and support 1) there are 2 posts made today and 2) nothing you said was helpful towards the town.

So instead of weakly trying to deflect the heat why don't you answer my questions. I'll post them so you don't miss them this time:

Dear PirateBob,
1. What is that you are accusing of JPap of skimming past?
2. What did you do to help us in those 2 posts today?

Love (you to be lynched), Townie Grins

 

[Grins]

Hi JL

 

[Madcrawdad]

HNs vote bothers me a lot but if I had to think him pirate I'd have to rethink some of my suspects. I also think or have leaning pirate Rb JM and Mad.

Day 1s are hard enough without having to explain why you jumped last hour from someone who comes up innocent to another player. No excuse would be good enough. With that in thought and some of HNs other posts I lean him innocent. No one he could have jumped to that were suspect to him would have made a difference unless others followed.

Rb - His want of a UD of a player. An innocent wouldn't call for it not knowing if it hurt his team or not but I could see a pirate doing it to lessen the number of lynches and hits needed to win. As pointed out earlier its reminiscent of a past game.


JM has done nothing for the town, she is attacking LC who appears to me as being helpful. She jumped on him from the start,as soon as she saw his pregame post. The rest of her posts have been nonsense posts.

Mad has me leaning him pirate because of his vote placement and his response to Grins about JM leaving him off the post of men on Beth.

Those are the top 3 I'm looking at right now.

Right, Ice. My vote placement on Beth looks scummy to you. Earlier in Day 1 with your 'thought train' post you were on those folks who were pointing a finger of suspicion at Beth, but not voting her (pretty much like you did). What happened to that theory?

My vote pulled Grins and LChap on? Pretty sure that they were on Beth all on their own. Beth basically sealed her own fate. If you were convinced she was innocent, why didn't you try harder to pull people off, instead of standing off all alone on Lupin, then moving to Jmax then rb?

[/QUOTE]

 

[johnlarson66]

I am still in meetings. We were talking about going to a 'Canes game, but we are still going over things.

I have read the thread. I think there is a clue about who was protected in Clowns narration.

I am bummed out about Lupin UD'ing. How come it always seem like innocents UD?

I still think mee-mee needs some votes on her. I think she is a pirate and will crack once she gets a few votes on her. The first reason I voted for her is that she was defending jpap for his lack of posting. Then she gave me a OMGUS vote. Also, I expected more posting from her at this point in the game.

I vote to have mee-mee walk the plank.

I hope to have some more time to post. The house I am sleeping at does not have internet.

 

[johnlarson66]

Hi JL

Hey Grins.

 

[judgemax]

OK, well, i have been super busy, and only have tonight to catch up, I am not sure I will have much time tom, either, so I will be giving my opinions on the current players, and then I will be making a vote. I want to re-read a few things, before I do...

 

[Dangerdoll]

Wow DD I'm still going to go back and read your posts but this has me leaning you more pirate.

Why wouldn't an innocent want better explanation of the role? I thought LCs question was very valid. Its nice to know if the Captains hands when switched have to stay with the new captain.

I would think if a Pirate Captain it would be safer to ask Clown via email or PM and not out in the open on a thread.

this goes for who asked
what I want to know is why would an innocent ask on the board but if a pirate, captain, PR, they have the ability to ask in PM???

DD what are you getting at here?

just what I said, Pappy. I was asked if I considered the Captain a power role by G, I gave her my answer.