Mafia #20 - Pirates of the Carribean the Play

[Madcrawdad]

Seems several of you are overly concerned about my vote on judge. Would you have preferred me to be on Beth?

You are right, several others had lower post counts than judge. I never said I was voting for the LOWEST poster. At the time of my vote on judge, she had posted absolutely nothing but fluff and she is a better player than that.

In fact, so many of you seemed to be concerned about it, it causes me to have deep concerns about you. Need to protect an associate...?

I vote to make Judgemax walk the plank....

RB, for me, it's not about who you voted for....the thing is though, you basically implied that it was a random vote (which some folks may do on Day 1). In the same post, though, you basically called LG a pirate. Wouldn't it have made more sense to vote LG instead of the random vote on JM?

 

[IceH2O]

Lady G...I never stated you only posted late at night, I said you were sneaking in and posting late at night....

Game 17....244 posts....184 of them in the 6 AM to 9 PM time frame, 60 of them in the 9 PM to 6 AM time frame

This Game...49 posts...24 of them in the 6 AM - 9 PM, 25 in the 9 PM - 6 AM....

Your current posting has shifted greatly to late at night, where you fail to face confrontation.....

I don't really see how when she posts matters. She might not get confrontation right away but its still going to come. If anything she is leaving herself open to a train of thought be run on her and not being able to stop it before its to late.

Skimming again Ice, or just trying to continue the choo-choo? If you don't agree with the poster, it is easy to say their info doesn't help. When you know your team mates it is easy to pick your alignment.

I am looking at JM, Jpap, JL66 and you mainly...though I seriously think Malbri is getting some very recent coaching....she couldn't make the posts she did today without a lot of advice. Everything up till now has just been the normal chat room comments from her and she has just repeated back what so many of you are jumping on.

Remember, you asked....be sure to turn it into a defensive post from me.

It is amazing you can conclude two posts from some one as helping when they have basically ignored the game. Ice, do you know of anyone who stated they were going to vote for the low posters because they deserved it, newbies or night.....I could link you to it, but just do a thread search for your name in the sign up thread. Guess, I'll add you to my target list of those to lynch, Ice.

Nope I knew why you went after JM. Just thought it a weak reason and even weaker when you consider its day 2, though I do agree with her being vote worthy. Just thought you'd have a better reason then her posting style, like her going after LC right away.

Jpap and JL? Any reasons besides low posting? JL actually had a lot of posts to start the game. Jpap still bears watching but a good start once he started posting.

As for Mal all she did was reiterate what others said. If she was coached it was by your team telling her to just follow innocents.

 

[Rbishop]

Hook...look at my post 795...I was responding to Ice...however if it also answers your questions...good deal...

 

[Rbishop]

So have you had RL issues today or have you been laying low?

Nope, I post a bit in the early AM before work and a bit after work...on weekends, I am a post *****....

 

[IceH2O]

Right, Ice. My vote placement on Beth looks scummy to you. Earlier in Day 1 with your 'thought train' post you were on those folks who were pointing a finger of suspicion at Beth, but not voting her (pretty much like you did). What happened to that theory?

My vote pulled Grins and LChap on? Pretty sure that they were on Beth all on their own. Beth basically sealed her own fate. If you were convinced she was innocent, why didn't you try harder to pull people off, instead of standing off all alone on Lupin, then moving to Jmax then rb?

[/QUOTE]

Not saying you pulled them on. Just saying the votes on her slowed to a stop and you threw another on to see if anyone would follow you. People trust you until you show not too. I'm not saying Beth didn't look pirate, she did until her posts that day. I saw that she was trying to help the town.

As for me not trying to get people off Beth. I only had a couple of hours. I posted that I thought Beth was innocent and I posted that I thought JM and Rb were pirates. I hoped that by sitting on JM that others would follow and force Rb off to save her but the evidence on Rb was better so I figured why try to prove a point when we could just lynch him instead.

this goes for who asked
what I want to know is why would an innocent ask on the board but if a pirate, captain, PR, they have the ability to ask in PM???


just what I said, Pappy. I was asked if I considered the Captain a power role by G, I gave her my answer.

An innocent would ask to get input from other innocents. A pirate would ask his team mates and PM the Mod.

RB, for me, it's not about who you voted for....the thing is though, you basically implied that it was a random vote (which some folks may do on Day 1). In the same post, though, you basically called LG a pirate. Wouldn't it have made more sense to vote LG instead of the random vote on JM?

I agree wholeheartedly with this. He has many more posts against LG but still votes JM.

 

[Rbishop]

And how was he skimming PirateBob? At the point he said that your only posts in the thread today were at 5:01AM and 7:01PM (true) and I have to agree with him that you didn't say anything helpful. If you want to contest that fine..show us what you said that was helpful.

Well grins, I guess I would call it skimming when in post 786 at 7:10 I vote to have judge walk the plank and Ice at 7:29 wants to know my thoughts on judge...

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Nope, I post a bit in the early AM before work and a bit after work...on weekends, I am a post *****....

Why answer this now and so "out of order" to the posts that are out there?

 

[Rbishop]

I added them so you and your pirate friends couldn't try to throw some silly meaningless claim in there again. Those times are direct links to your two posts and support 1) there are 2 posts made today and 2) nothing you said was helpful towards the town.

So instead of weakly trying to deflect the heat why don't you answer my questions. I'll post them so you don't miss them this time:

Dear PirateBob,
1. What is that you are accusing of JPap of skimming past?
2. What did you do to help us in those 2 posts today?

Love (you to be lynched), Townie Grins

Jpap blew past my post just before his....

I gave you some thoughts and answered a question.....

You don't need to shout grins.....I can ignore you at any volume....

 

[Rbishop]

RB, for me, it's not about who you voted for....the thing is though, you basically implied that it was a random vote (which some folks may do on Day 1). In the same post, though, you basically called LG a pirate. Wouldn't it have made more sense to vote LG instead of the random vote on JM?

No.

 

[Rbishop]

Why answer this now and so "out of order" to the posts that are out there?

I answer posts in the order it suits me, sorry if it isn't according to your liking....