Mafia #20 - Pirates of the Carribean the Play

IceH2O said:
Or the guard could just hit JM so even if the Cooke protected Rb we'd still get a dead pirate.

If we went to tie and last second switch then they might out think us and protect JM instead. If we just tie and the random goes to the protected one we get nothing. I'd rather see one dead and since the Cooke can't protect a Guards hit that person will die. If we stay the course and Rb is protected by the Cooke it just reassures his pirateness. Maybe JM is Cooke and the hit kills her and leaves Rb unprotected.
Click to expand...

You, know Ice that sounds like a good idea there. I was thinking about the guard once I read your post and went back to look at his/her role a little better, I found something interesting, something I didn't notice before.

Guard – You are the guard and have a one time shot to execute anyone within the game of your choosing. You will email me your request on whatever night you choose. Your execution cannot be protected by anyone. You NOT communicate with the governor, magistrate or watchmen outside of the thread. Depending on the number of people who sign up there may be two of these roles.

Could we possibly have 2 guards???
 
Lady G said:
You, know Ice that sounds like a good idea there. I was thinking about the guard once I read your post and went back to look at his/her role a little better, I found something interesting, something I didn't notice before.

Guard – You are the guard and have a one time shot to execute anyone within the game of your choosing. You will email me your request on whatever night you choose. Your execution cannot be protected by anyone. You NOT communicate with the governor, magistrate or watchmen outside of the thread. Depending on the number of people who sign up there may be two of these roles.

Could we possibly have 2 guards???
Click to expand...


Wonder what happens if they both aim at one player, do both shots count?

Theres no way to know if they will both shoot. Theres also no way to tell one to shoot and not the other because how will one know if the other one does.
Unless they are Guard 1 and Guard 2 in the PMs to them.
If thats the case then Guard 1 should take the shot and Guard 2 should hold steady or fire on another suspect like DD if they think she is pirate. Be great to get 3 pirates tonight.
 
In the sign up thread it says Clown wanted a minimum of 16 but preferred 20 with all the power roles.

I'm going to assume there is only one Guard since we only had 17 players to begin.
 
IceH2O said:
Or the guard could just hit JM so even if the Cooke protected Rb we'd still get a dead pirate.

If we went to tie and last second switch then they might out think us and protect JM instead. If we just tie and the random goes to the protected one we get nothing. I'd rather see one dead and since the Cooke can't protect a Guards hit that person will die. If we stay the course and Rb is protected by the Cooke it just reassures his pirateness. Maybe JM is Cooke and the hit kills her and leaves Rb unprotected.
Click to expand...

IceH2O said:
Wonder what happens if they both aim at one player, do both shots count?

Theres no way to know if they will both shoot. Theres also no way to tell one to shoot and not the other because how will one know if the other one does.
Unless they are Guard 1 and Guard 2 in the PMs to them.
If thats the case then Guard 1 should take the shot and Guard 2 should hold steady or fire on another suspect like DD if they think she is pirate. Be great to get 3 pirates tonight.
Click to expand...
Also, they may not even know themselves..hopefully we have 2 and hopefully they know about each other. If they do not know about each other, I hope they both do not take the shot and it counts for them both, I'm sure they wouldn't know who the other is but the Guard 1 & 2 thing would be helpful.

It would be GREAT to get 3, even 2 with our Planking and the guard hit, having a 3rd OMG, WONDERFUL!!!

:cry:I wanna call in!!!!!!!!!!!
 
That top quote wasn't suppose to be there:)
 
jpappy789 said:
DOes it matter if I quoted times rb? You had only two posts yesterday when I posted, both had no imput what so ever, and they are posted below:



Mal is following, I would agree, but you jump to the conclusion that she is being coached...how many times, honestly, has anyone been coached into making a case, other than mee-mee's screw up (but they were desperate at the time).



Here is your first post of the game. No relevance other than you responding to LG and keeping your thoughts on her, which apparently now arent much other than you have her leaning more evil...



No I didnt. I saw it. I asked if you have anything else to say not concerning LG who you were gunning after earlier. I guess I didnt see your response to mal as a definite post indicating her as a suspect of yours...and since then you have not commented on her as a suspect of yours so I am trying to figure out whther or not you really suspect mal or if that was just supossed to be some type of distraction, claiming that mal is being coached into voting for you when you were on the chopping block making you seem innocent...



Once again, your post on mal had no imput at all other than insinuating that she is being coahched.

Rb, so far I have seen you name Jm, LG, and supposedly mal as suspects. You dropped your case on LG, and havent mentioned Mal since. The Ice asks you for your thoughts on blue, Lchap and DD. You come up with the most neutral answers I have ever seen from you that I can remember. "Blue-needs to post more. LChap- leaning pirate, too good for a newb. DD- dont trust her but slightly leaning innocent"...So basically all you have right now is JM???

BELOW IS A STRING OF QUOTES

Here is mine from last night that got rb going...


Rb responds with this


Grins quotes the ABOVE post about me and posts this


Rb quotes Grins post above and then somehow Ice is added in to the mix!?!?!?


I vote to make RB walk the plank...
Click to expand...

I guess we should feel privileiged...he crawls out of the forward bilge tank and allows us to savor his indepth and "continuous help for the Townies".

Should we be saving our gold to pay your price? Pretty soon you will have participated as much as some of the dead people....
 
IceH2O said:
In the sign up thread it says Clown wanted a minimum of 16 but preferred 20 with all the power roles.

I'm going to assume there is only one Guard since we only had 17 players to begin.
Click to expand...

Yeah, thats probably true, if we had 20 or closer to 20, I bet we would of got two, but with only one more then his minimum, I bet we just got one. Well whichever we have...I hope they make the right decision.
 
rbishop said:
I guess we should feel privileiged...he crawls out of the forward bilge tank and allows us to savor his indepth and "continuous help for the Townies".

Should we be saving our gold to pay your price? Pretty soon you will have participated as much as some of the dead people....
Click to expand...
:lipssealedsmilie:
 
Lady G said:
Beth-HN, DD, Mal, Mad, Grins, LC
LC-Beth, JM, Blue
MM-JL, JP
Jmax-RB
RB-LG, Ice
JL-MM
Jpap-Lupin
We now know, MG, Beth, and Lupin were all innocents. Yes I added MG although he wasn't here to vote.

Just referencing who voted what night one. Our two known innocents that voted...Lupin/Jpap and Beth/LC.
Click to expand...

I am sure you or one of your shipmates will twist this....but I think you should have made it three known innocents....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom