MAFIA 22: Who is who?

[Grins]

Hey lookie, its the Ghost of Mafia Past come to look on. <waves to the freshly lynched Ct>

 

[Lady G]

Well, lets see first...I didn't make a BIG deal, I made a vote with my reason...plain and simple, I believe that is the way you are suppose to do it right??? IMO, it was the thing that stood out the most to me, and after her response to me, yep I feel pretty good about it.
Second...nope, it didn't say the start time/day. Point is PMs don't go out until the game is ready to start, doesn't need to say it. For you to point back to this is a little off to me. Why you would want to bring something back up that made you look guilty in the first place is beyond me.

Sorry LG but you do seem to be making a big deal out of it. That looks really off to me and I've already explained why I brought up what I did...i went back and reviewed ALL the posts since my head had been so fuzzy the first day+ of the game. I have no worries about brining anything I've done back up as there isn't anything I need to hide. Is there something you're trying to hide?

LG: Made an awfully big deal out of DD's asking Niko to remove a post when DD was up front and asked for it in the thread and even corrected Niko when he removed the wrong content. Why did you go after her so hard LG? And I didn't see an answer from you regarding this.
I like your point here about an experienced player knowing that HN could be valuable and was worth not hitting the first night until more information was gathered. It makes sense that a newer player that didn't know HN so well would have taken him out. However in the same vein of how this game twists one thinking it also makes sense for a vetern player to bring that possibility up to to cast suspicion elsewhere. It doesn't make you guilty, and I don't feel I am able to read you well. Shoot, I was convinced you were mafia in the pirate game and was obviously wrong about that. Even the mafia thought you were mafia then.

Umm, Grins I did answer that, and you responded...see posts above.

 

[IceH2O]

RB 1 LC(446)

DD 1 Ogre(539)

Ogre 1 Bkw(547)


game off/

RB give me the slot after Zmans game. I'm working on a Mafia: Survivor type set up.

I'm thinking that we do another 50/50 split. We have lynches but no hits, at nightfall a randomizer picks a players number and they go home that night.

game on

 

[Dangerdoll]

Nice post there DD!! You do know that CT is gone though right, and he wasn't the boss??

Aside from me (of coarse), I think you have a good list going there. What do you think about Clown at this point??

yep, knew he was gone, just did a quickie post with the names there, didn't eliminate anyone... notice Hooked is still on the list too

 

[Grins]

Umm, Grins I did answer that, and you responded...see posts above.

I know LG, as I said at the top of the post, only the comments in red were new. I like to build off the previous day's analysis to help me keep track of thoughts on players.

For anyone else reading it, although I still have the new suspicions I listed in red, LG is correct, she did answer the comments from the day before.

 

[Grins]

RB 1 LC(446)

DD 1 Ogre(539)

Ogre 1 Bkw(547)


game off/

RB give me the slot after Zmans game. I'm working on a Mafia: Survivor type set up.

I'm thinking that we do another 50/50 split. We have lynches but no hits, at nightfall a randomizer picks a players number and they go home that night.

game on

I might make a Mafia Mod Game. Only past Game Mods can play..and the public votes for which Bala to evict from the island.

 

[Grins]

yep, knew he was gone, just did a quickie post with the names there, didn't eliminate anyone... notice Hooked is still on the list too

It is kinda funny that you listed him as likely to be intimidated by HN to support a theory of which one might have hit him though.

 

[Lady G]

I know LG, as I said at the top of the post, only the comments in red were new. I like to build off the previous day's analysis to help me keep track of thoughts on players.

For anyone else reading it, although I still have the new suspicions I listed in red, LG is correct, she did answer the comments from the day before.

Ok, I see what you mean...sorry.

yep, knew he was gone, just did a quickie post with the names there, didn't eliminate anyone... notice Hooked is still on the list too

Yes, I seen HNs name there, but you said you highlighted in red the names of the newbs that might want him gone, and you had CT's name in red...kinda confused me there....hence the reason I asked.

 

[Lady G]

Well, guys/gals...I have to go make supper and a few things...will be back on later tonight.

Before I go, I am leaving a few thoughts of who my suspects at this point are.

DD-well, she just doesn't seem my innocent friend. Could just be off...but many small things are adding up.

Clown-I know how you like to try and fool me (and others), I think you feel you have me figured out and are trying this new way of communicating to me..to try and make me feel more "comfortable" with you.

Lchap-Have to be honest, aside from the fact I could see Ice putting him as a PR, especially in this set up, and he would be a good candidate for the hit on Hooked...not much more than that stands out to me from his posts. He is good though, started out on a team with Hooked and learned very well so he IS there on my list, but I am going back and forth with him.

Emo-Got very quiet, none of his post say much of anything and most barely make any sense, I could see him as Mafia...not sure on the "boss" though

RB-Could be one vet that would of taken out HN, after I get back on I will try to find the post as to why. It was a post with him and DD in it from Hooked.

Beth-As I stated earlier, I am not sure on her...one minute I am thinking Mafia, the next innocent

Grins-Seems to be trying to be helpful...but is she too helpful??

Jpap-He seems to of gotten very quiet also, not sure on him either.

Bkw-Very hard to read...always is no real feel one way or another on him.

Ogre-Another that seems helpful, voted me for "no reason" though other then that nothing really to go with him either

MG-Well, I think he is MG...post little thoughts here and there nothing that really has any substance to them though.

CL-Not sure on him either

Jmax-well, she is evil rather she is innocent or not:silly:

 

[bkw1982]

But bk HN was mafia too, and HN really didn't do anything to help either side. So why take him out on day one no less.

JMax answered this perfectly in post 550

Aren't there only 2 players that would eliminate? Emo and Ct, one of which we already know was mafia for sure? I haven't played with Ogre before, not you either in fact, what is it that you know about Ogre that might convince those of us that don't have a refrence from a past game with him?

I dont understand your question lol

I have to disagree with you here Bkw, yes Ogre may be mafia...but I'm not so sure the boss is a vet, the hit on HN really makes me feel it is not. Yes, IF HN had actually done something to look completely innocent maybe...but I think he may of ruffled a newbs feathers, one that thought he may be innocent and the hit him, I just really do not see a vet taking him out on day one, not knowing...I know if I were the Boss or Mayor I would want him around long enough to figure out what I thought he was for sure cause I would want him on my team. He is one I would investigate before hitting.

I think a newb would use the logic of hittin HN only if he looked innocent, but a vet who sees HN as a threat cause of past games would hit HN just to get him out the way. Jmax explains it well in post 550

Bkw: Again, never played with BKW before and not sure to make of their few posts.
Nothing meant personally here Bkw but your way of playing is the one I have the most difficulty with. If we all made as little posts as you did the entire game would be less than 50 posts long. Help me out here, how should someone that hasn't played with you before read you?

Lol go read past games is all i can say, thts your handicapp to over come


My possible boss list(based on hit of HN)

Ogre
LG
DD

These are the folks i think woulda hit HN to get him out the way