MAFIA 22: Who is who?

OK, here is the post I was talking about from HN, that made me think Possibly RB or DD could be the one who hit him, and why.

Hooked Newbie said:
All those posts and not much substance. The Emo thing is interesting, but since no one knows who is who, I doubt it's staged in the least. Also, DD & Rb- isn't deleting posts basically editting AND using Mod powers? I believe Ice probably tweaked the roles too. LChap- good post but then again I remember how much you've been working for "future games" in the 2 you've played so anything I see from you wil be with a grain of salt.



Comments in blue.
Click to expand...

I had voiced my opinion on the posts being deleted by a Mod instead of letting Ice deal with it, how he saw fit. Not really sure why he added RBs name...I don't recall him saying anything about it..but the fact he added that in this post, would POSSIBLY give them (either) a reason to feel HN was innocent and want him gone.

I have to say I have thought alot about Lchap and him being the boss, yes...I at first thought maybe and it did make since, but the more I think about it he did play on a communicating team with HN, he knows what a good player he is and I believe he has caught on enough to know he would be a good one on the team with you, and I do believe he would of most likely investigated HN before hitting him. I THINK.

Still think it makes more since for the Mafia Boss to be an newb, then a Vet...but someone and I don't remember who mentioned how it could of been a tactic, this really could be true...they may of thought HN was innocent and wanted to throw everyone off by hitting him....imagine their surprise when they saw he was the hitman though....OH MAN!!!
 
Is Jpap still playing???
 
I hope all is ok with him!!!
 
I don't think he said anything, but there was another game where he had something come up and he ended up UDing...so he may just be busy w/ something...or he may be mafia scum hiding out:grinyes:
 
read through all the threads here are my thoughts, in no particular order and if I have forgotten anyone I will add them:
LC-you are leaning more mafia now, somethings you say don't seem right for an innocent.

Jmax-leaning Mafia atm,

Cory- nothing says mafia, leaning innocent for now

BK-leaning Mafia there are some posts that have my interest.

DD-leaning innocent at the moment

Ogre-so hard to read, could be innocent

Beth- I know what I am

Grins-had you leaning Mafia, but now I think more innocent

Lady G-you still seem Mafia to me, but this may change

Rb-still nothing screams mafia or innocent, you are another hard one to read

Emo-your still Mafia, even more now that you have gone quiet.

Jpap-you have been gone so I have you leaning innocent, hope you come back soon

Clown-your quiet, but you were last game too, nothing screams Mafia, you do have some helpful thoughts,

MG- I wish I knew for sure where you really are, nothing really helpful so not sure on innocent, but nothing says Mafia.
 
judgemax said:
Right now, I am torn between a vote for grins, and a vote for beth, grins as stated prior, and beth, because shes so darn agreeable, ..and every other person on her list was , ..not sure, don't know, ..could be, maybe not, ..I used that same strategy when i was guilty...didn't want to upset anyone...
Click to expand...

Okay Jmax, I have people listed this way, simply because I didn' think it fair to call someone on or the other if I truely had no idea. and because it was only day 2, however things have begun to fall one way or the other. I also don't have the gift of reading people well, so I have to get evidence first.BUt thanks for making me think differently of you.
 
#563 I was not intimidated by HN, I think he was and will always be an awesome player, so your theory of me as a newb being intimidated is wrong. Maybe one of the others.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom