Mafia #23 Revenge

[clown-lover]

I wish I could see what you guys are saying but I don't. Even with Mads quotes,which were the 1st ones anyone actually pulled for evidence and not just a post of feelings she is evil, I thought her responses were good answers.

Actually I'm finding your play as much off as Grins personally. What I have seen is you step in several times trying to deflect off of Grins and force people into your way of thinking. Just like last night when we were having that other discussion and you were trying to make me look dirty just because I didn't put into my post anything about JoAnder but had raised you up my scale a notch (which as of this point is actually more than one).

So you're saying that you don't think Mal and JM are screaming mafia to you at this point? Are you trying to protect the other team here? I think we have a team and Mal is the Don. As I said earlier JM wouldn't choose Mal but I could see Mal choosing JM.

What in that post is so hard for you to understand? What I see you doing is trying to force players into your line of thinking. While you have made an attempt to make yourself look like a concerned townie as of this point I'm ranking you scummy and realistically give your reasoning the same attention I would a grain of salt. When you aren't mafia you tend to concentrate on more than one or two players and I have yet to see that in you other than on this post where you are trying to tie myself to mad. This post you are quoting along with the next post talk about how I found all of this banter last night was probably a simple deflection move to keep us from sniffing out a power mafia player. And honestly your a better player than that to simply fall for the overly obvious. While I personally don't have an objection to voting for either Mal or JM as of this point, because while JM put in her "I'm Innocent" post that is EXACTLY what I expected her to do. Do I believe Mal's play is different absolutely, do I find her to be possible Mafia, absolutely but day one isn't up yet and I'm still allowed to sniff out mafia now arn't I.

Yo say you'd vote for 4 people earlier then you post 5 players here. 2 of them I agree with 2 I don't yet and the 3rd is a newb.

Yes because like I said I'm not possitive.. I don't think even that whole list is mafia but they are people that I am questioning and looking at as possible mafia.

I'm leaning but not heavily at this time(about an 7-7.5 on a scale of 1-10) that Mad and Clown could be the other team. Mad usually goes after more then 1 person but I think with all the questioning of Grins he has a target he thinks he can easily get voted out. Clown tends to get defensive and harsh with his words when mafia.He is following suit with Mad on Grins.But also throwing accusations at other players. The fact that Mal and JM don't stand out over everyone else to them makes me lean them more mafia then innocent. I think they are trying to deflect votes from their sister team.

Actually that was the game with old/new mafia that you are thinking about and I got very aggressive towards one player.. LadyG. And I get harsh with my words when I'm an innocent or a townie. Especially when things have been explained to players and they don't catch the hint.

So with this your saying that you feel Grins is 100% innocent then right? I mean with this post and the couple of others that you have made trying to deflect people from looking at her to me that means you have some piece of inside information correct? But since RB hasn't rolled night yet that could only mean that you have mafia information as of this point doesn't it.

Oh and BTW it would help if you could read the rules as well. Your vote count is wrong.

See my comments in red

 

[judgemax]

okay I just read through all the posts from last night and...my head hurts.

First what is Mal trying to do? I am so lost as to what she was thinking or what she was saying for that matter.

Jmax- I really don't know what to say to you.......I had hoped by now you would have let it go, and understood that I got your point. i have, so wheres the problem?..

Grins-Thanks for being fair, I read the first part and was going post something, glad I waited.

I have no idea where to post my vote there are so many to choose from, I am speechless after all I read.

 

[Blueiz]

Through fishing through all these posts, the one that stands out to me the most is JM. The continuous use of LOL, ROFL, is something that JM does when shes nervous, or trying to play the "good guy". It has been noted in at least one other game, and it seems to be her way of deflecting seriousness from her posts and responses to others.

Grins, it seems the only reason you would deny the post edit is because you were scared it would draw attention to you. It did not go unnoticed by me that you only quoted part of what I said in my earlier post concerning it, but did not reference my saying "I know what I saw". Were you hoping that it would just drop? There have been several that have edited there posts immediately after posting them, myself included in previous games. I have never denied it when it was caught by someone, that would make me look as tho I had something to hide. What are you hiding?

Im torn between voting for grins for denying the post edit and JM for reason listed above, those are my two top suspects atm. However, Im going to place my vote on grins atm because the more I ponder over it, the more it confuses me why she would deny what she did, and why would she call me a liar if she was truly trying to help the town.

I vote to lynch Grins, subject to change as always.

 

[judgemax]

Clown, i obviously posted the I'm Innocent post, just because you said something about it. right after it, it says so, ..

 

[clown-lover]

I have

LC 2 LC(4)LG(205)Grins(309)
HN 1 JM(7 )Grins(30) ILB(52)
JM 3 ILB(14)HN(27) Cory(486)ILB(560)Ice(582)
ILB 1 Mal(23)Bkw(433)KOTD(475)

Grins 3 Bkw(69)Ogre(107)Clown(450)Mad(682)
Clown 1 Cool(114)
Mal 2 Ice(424)Ice(632)KOTD(638)
KOTD 1 Mal(498)


ILB moved from HN to JM in post 560 and Mad onto Grins but after your post.

God I'm helping a potential mafia person here.. ICE your wrong. ILB didn't move their vote because they NEVER RETRACTED the last vote. And this coming from the person who wouldn't take a retracted vote if we didn't put "I retract".. Sliding up the list more ICE..

 

[judgemax]

Through fishing through all these posts, the one that stands out to me the most is JM. The continuous use of LOL, ROFL, is something that JM does when shes nervous, or trying to play the "good guy". It has been noted in at least one other game, and it seems to be her way of deflecting seriousness from her posts and responses to others.Please check this fact, ..I was innocent the game they claimed that, I do use those alot, however, In IM'S PM'S and any chat or conversation, i type them alot. thats me, guilty Innocent, whatever. i started that, after MAFIA 4 , that way people understand, that i am not taking this game serious, ..its a game!

Grins, it seems the only reason you would deny the post edit is because you were scared it would draw attention to you. It did not go unnoticed by me that you only quoted part of what I said in my earlier post concerning it, but did not reference my saying "I know what I saw". Were you hoping that it would just drop? There have been several that have edited there posts immediately after posting them, myself included in previous games. I have never denied it when it was caught by someone, that would make me look as tho I had something to hide. What are you hiding?

Im torn between voting for grins for denying the post edit and JM for reason listed above, those are my two top suspects atm. However, Im going to place my vote on grins atm because the more I ponder over it, the more it confuses me why she would deny what she did, and why would she call me a liar if she was truly trying to help the town.

I vote to lynch Grins, subject to change as always.

comments in red

 

[clown-lover]

Clown, i obviously posted the I'm Innocent post, just because you said something about it. right after it, it says so, ..

I realize you did.. And that post didn't help you in my eyes any JM. In fact your looking more mafia just because you did it because I had said you had done all but that..

 

[judgemax]

I realize you did.. And that post didn't help you in my eyes any JM. In fact your looking more mafia just because you did it because I had said you had done all but that..

well, I couldn't help it, lol, You basically challenged me. How could I resist?..

 

[bethkira2000]

lady-nothing says mafia, so leaning innocent atm

ogre-I feel so bad that your one post has gotten out of control. I think right now you are leaning innocent

hook-you are one of a couple who I have such a hard time reading. I really don't know which way to put you yet.

ice-you are another one I can't read, I think maybe more innocent feeling this time around, but I don't know.

blue-leaning innocent at the moment, has done nothing to say mafia.

clown-I can't read you either,I have no idea which way with you either.

DD-Leaning innocent at the moment

emo-I have to ask where are you? Out of all the posts last night you had none, and out of all the posts in the game you have had one. I find this unsetteling, compared to last game.

cory-you are leaning mafia atm, you jumped hard onto the ogre post, but really didn't see that it could be a mistake.

lchp-I wish you were back to your more agressive style, you helped more then, it just feels like you gave up. I have to say your leaning more Mafia a this point.

ILB-I think I need to watch your style more, your a newb to me, so I can't say either way with you right now.

beth-I know myself

bkw-leaning slightly innocent

joan-Your style is new to me too, I can't fairly judge either way yet

cool-you are the last new style to me so I can't really say, but I feel you need watching

grns-something does seem off with you this time, however I don't think its because your Mafia.....I have you leaning more innocent right now, though subject to change.

mad-You are the last one that I have a hard time reading.

jdge- I want to give you the benefit of the doubt, but the more I think of your posts and the way you reacted it bothers me. It really makes me want to think your Mafia with the way you don't let it go. I do not think you and Mal are on the same side, with all the craziness I read last night, that would set that team up for instant disaster. I will watch you for the day and wait to make my mind.

mal-Wow, if your not Mafia then wth, how do you really think those posts are helpful?I have never been more confused in my life, I really think you let the game get to you, been there done that. But some of the things you said have me really thinking you are Mafia.

zsand-no posts so nothing to go on

My feelings are subject to change, they are not in any particular order. The best canidates for me are Mal,LC,Emo, just cause he has not posted at all and was in chat all night.

 

[bethkira2000]

King- innocent till proven otherwise, for now.
Sorry I forgot you off my nice list.