Mafia #23 Revenge

[LesbianChap]

More thoughts on the clue.

What if he is naming both teams?

Grins- Grins

Ogre- sighs

cool-kewl

emo-kewl (bc they think they are)

LC- clarification (backwards cL)

Clown - clarification

though I thought of a reason for cL that fits with the being the junior cL.

He was trying to clarify why he wouldn't have hit IBL and why he couldn't be mafia.

Since clown seems to be actually helping the town I would be inclined to not include him and think the rest of the list actually looks pretty good. According to my thoughts and those of others.

That would be 6 total, and since RB did say anything is possible if its not in the rules its possible Z and/or KOTD came in as mafia and chose a 3rd player for their team (Blue?) to make it 9 mafia vs 9 innocents which would be a 50/50 game.

All speculation as even as I type it I'm thinking its a reach. But I would have felt wrong not putting it out there. I'd rather be wrong about an idea then to keep it to myself and be right.

Well there are technically "two" CLs..Clown and Cory...Maybe he was refering to Cory instead? At least you're not looking at JM anymore. I'm starting to think more and more that she's innocent. You still got at least one player on there that's wrong.

Anyways, I'm going to retract my vote for Emo in the hopes that he UDs. After that, I'm going to vote to lynch Blue. Why? Day 1 she was too quiet, even for her, then the clue RB left in the night posts, and now she's gotten too defensive over simple questions. She seems like a good suspect, and if we get a 2-way spread I'd like to see her in it.

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

i don't think we are thinking of the same game then. it definitely was not around halloween

i was mafia in the game i'm thinking of, after RB's clues we were all out in the open and the innocents lynched us all, which caused us to be a bit mad.

just an add on

this is the only game i can remember where anyone was mad about RB clues, i don't recall ever playing with cool.

 

[clown-lover]

Well here are my daily morning thoughts...

Beth – Has gone almost completely silent? Was the first days worth of posting just to get her out of the limelight and make her look innocent? I don’t think I’ve heard anything from her since before day 1 nightfall. – severely questioning

BKW -While I know he is not a large quantity poster I get more concerned every day where I don't see a little bush kicking out of a player. I see him following other players trains of thought but not a lot of analysis out of him.. A little last night about RB's comments but nothing player wise. Also think he would make a great conversion because of his seeming to be able to fly under radar. Again I haven’t heard from him in a long while.. Whats up here? – severely questioning

BlueIz – new melodrama queen. Here, what can I say I simply asked to see her have some more input into the game and I get blasted from here to high heaven that she posts “thoughts” when she has them. As of this update there are well over a thousand posts and I have yet to see more than one thought. – leaning mafia

Cool – I’m still not sure where to put this player. He really hasn’t been helping out the town and what messages he has posted in the thread haven’t done anything for me personally. – leaning mafia

DD - back to unsure.. She has posts that seem to be helping the town, has also used the RL issues card which I'm not denying it happened but I have seen her post from home in the game more frequently.. She has brought up some good points however. No change in my thoughts here. I’m still undecided.

Emo - am wondering where this player is as well.. Last game was posting and now you can't even get him to post in fun. Is he even playing this game? Has a whopping 2 posts in this game and jumps in right before night and places a post. There really isn't anything for me to pick apart in his posting, however behavior from players with this style in the past have pretty much IME been Mafia - leaning stronger mafia simply due to lack of posting

Grins – What can I say..you’ve seem to come out and help the town a little but I am wondering if it is to little to late here. I really am doing a LadyG on this one with you thinking that you could be innocent, but then I go no mafia, then back again.. – leaning mafia

Hooked - I have posted above in a different message thoughts on HN but while he does have RL issues and I do empathize with that is happening at this juncture of his life, I am missing his analsysis. And fair is fair he did kick my bush asking me questions yesterday but in all honesty it is not normal HN play.- questioning and undecided

ICE - I am going back and forth on ICE. There were some questionable interactions and protections going on but at one moment I'm thinking he's helpful and the next I question. I really can't lean him as innocent but he has had some helpful posts... So back to neutral

ILB - Innocent

Joander - Innocent

Judge – Where had the judge been? Yesterday (game day 1) she was all over the place making posts, playing the fool and her answer was so she didn’t get picked. We then see a message that this was her “plan” to not get picked and that she is so happy that she is an innocent this round. Well if she is an innocent where are the helpful innocent posts? I mean she did have time to make all of those worthless posts, why not helpful ones today. She has moved up on my list greatly to the point because of her play that I can say – mafia

KOTD – Undecided..

LadyG – LadyG has come out of the box today and made several significant posts that have really helped me out. As of this point I’m leaning her innocent

LesbianChap – have seen some play from him but again nothing that leads me to believe he is a townie or innocent for that matter. I am torn with him.. But at this point I see no reason to call him innocent so – leaning mafia

Mad - Again hard.. hard to read. Not a lot of posting.. However what posting he has had to this point has seemed helpful. However I’ve also seen this when he was evil. He is so very hard for me to read. – very undecided

Malbri - Innocent

Ogre – undecided, still haven’t see a ton of posting and really don’t have a read on him

Zman – I’m having to lean him more towards the innocent side as of this point but with how good of a player I think he is (if my memory serves me right) he is one to watch - undecided

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

Well here are my daily morning thoughts...

Beth – Has gone almost completely silent? Was the first days worth of posting just to get her out of the limelight and make her look innocent? I don’t think I’ve heard anything from her since before day 1 nightfall. – severely questioning

BKW -While I know he is not a large quantity poster I get more concerned every day where I don't see a little bush kicking out of a player. I see him following other players trains of thought but not a lot of analysis out of him.. A little last night about RB's comments but nothing player wise. Also think he would make a great conversion because of his seeming to be able to fly under radar. Again I haven’t heard from him in a long while.. Whats up here? – severely questioning

BlueIz – new melodrama queen. Here, what can I say I simply asked to see her have some more input into the game and I get blasted from here to high heaven that she posts “thoughts” when she has them. As of this update there are well over a thousand posts and I have yet to see more than one thought. – leaning mafia

Cool – I’m still not sure where to put this player. He really hasn’t been helping out the town and what messages he has posted in the thread haven’t done anything for me personally. – leaning mafia

DD - back to unsure.. She has posts that seem to be helping the town, has also used the RL issues card which I'm not denying it happened but I have seen her post from home in the game more frequently.. She has brought up some good points however. No change in my thoughts here. I’m still undecided.

Emo - am wondering where this player is as well.. Last game was posting and now you can't even get him to post in fun. Is he even playing this game? Has a whopping 2 posts in this game and jumps in right before night and places a post. There really isn't anything for me to pick apart in his posting, however behavior from players with this style in the past have pretty much IME been Mafia - leaning stronger mafia simply due to lack of posting

Grins – What can I say..you’ve seem to come out and help the town a little but I am wondering if it is to little to late here. I really am doing a LadyG on this one with you thinking that you could be innocent, but then I go no mafia, then back again.. – leaning mafia

Hooked - I have posted above in a different message thoughts on HN but while he does have RL issues and I do empathize with that is happening at this juncture of his life, I am missing his analsysis. And fair is fair he did kick my bush asking me questions yesterday but in all honesty it is not normal HN play.- questioning and undecided

ICE - I am going back and forth on ICE. There were some questionable interactions and protections going on but at one moment I'm thinking he's helpful and the next I question. I really can't lean him as innocent but he has had some helpful posts... So back to neutral

ILB - Innocent

Joander - Innocent

Judge – Where had the judge been? Yesterday (game day 1) she was all over the place making posts, playing the fool and her answer was so she didn’t get picked. We then see a message that this was her “plan” to not get picked and that she is so happy that she is an innocent this round. Well if she is an innocent where are the helpful innocent posts? I mean she did have time to make all of those worthless posts, why not helpful ones today. She has moved up on my list greatly to the point because of her play that I can say – mafia

KOTD – Undecided..

LadyG – LadyG has come out of the box today and made several significant posts that have really helped me out. As of this point I’m leaning her innocent

LesbianChap – have seen some play from him but again nothing that leads me to believe he is a townie or innocent for that matter. I am torn with him.. But at this point I see no reason to call him innocent so – leaning mafia

Mad - Again hard.. hard to read. Not a lot of posting.. However what posting he has had to this point has seemed helpful. However I’ve also seen this when he was evil. He is so very hard for me to read. – very undecided

Malbri - Innocent

Ogre – undecided, still haven’t see a ton of posting and really don’t have a read on him

Zman – I’m having to lean him more towards the innocent side as of this point but with how good of a player I think he is (if my memory serves me right) he is one to watch - undecided

i'd like to know why you have me as undecided and z as leaning innocent..just an explanation..i could see if you had us both as undecided, which you did mention at the end of z's paragraph, but still..i need an explanation..why does z seem more innocent at this point?

a new team member, perhaps?

 

[clown-lover]

Well as of this point I put my vote on emo in hopes that it would pull him out and get him active into this game. But I guess he really doesn't care to play and will probably UD tonight. So I retract my vote from Emo

With that said I am torn as to who to vote for.. I agree with HN and ICE and I would like to see a three horse race and see where votes go late in the game.. With votes already on Grins and LC putting one on Blue. With me thinking that Emo is going to UD I just see him as a wasted vote right now so I'm going with my second choice of yesterday in hopes that others see that she still isn't a townie (and am wondering why she has dropped off of so many radars - thinking we are relying on RB to much here) and vote to lynch JudgeMax (see my rational in my last list posting)

 

[clown-lover]

i'd like to know why you have me as undecided and z as leaning innocent..just an explanation..i could see if you had us both as undecided, which you did mention at the end of z's paragraph, but still..i need an explanation..why does z seem more innocent at this point?

a new team member, perhaps?

Because I have seen more effort on the towns behalf than from you.. You just seem.. quiet at points. Almost to quiet and so I'm not willing to call you an innocent yet. But your not high on my list either. If I had to rank my top four right now it would be

Blue
JM
Grins
LChap

 

[clown-lover]

Well there are technically "two" CLs..Clown and Cory...Maybe he was refering to Cory instead? At least you're not looking at JM anymore. I'm starting to think more and more that she's innocent. You still got at least one player on there that's wrong.

How and why.. Thats a bold statement to put out there without any supporting material. Yesterday she was all over the place (game day 1) in the last 24 hours of RL play she's had a post here and a post there. Some with me but I really haven't seen any more townie play out of her than I have you.. So is this one of your team mates that your trying to get off the radar LC?

Anyways, I'm going to retract my vote for Emo in the hopes that he UDs. After that, I'm going to vote to lynch Blue. Why? Day 1 she was too quiet, even for her, then the clue RB left in the night posts, and now she's gotten too defensive over simple questions. She seems like a good suspect, and if we get a 2-way spread I'd like to see her in it.

I don't have a problem with the above vote, but I agree more with HN (I think it was his post) where a three horse race would be a good idea and see where the votes go later in the day.

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

Because I have seen more effort on the towns behalf than from you.. You just seem.. quiet at points. Almost to quiet and so I'm not willing to call you an innocent yet. But your not high on my list either. If I had to rank my top four right now it would be

Blue
JM
Grins
LChap

i don't agree with that, but ok.

also, you can ask just about anyone here if i am usually among the top posters, they will all say no. even i cannot believe how many posts i have this game.

 

[clown-lover]

i don't agree with that, but ok.

also, you can ask just about anyone here if i am usually among the top posters, they will all say no. even i cannot believe how many posts i have this game.

Well in all honesty King I do have you both as Undecided. You guys are those vets that I will always have a hard time reading I think.. You guys have matured your play to the point where I'm wondering where the challenge is for you anymore honestly.

And yes you do have quite a few posts. But most of those posts came from Game Day 1, not game day 2

 

[clown-lover]

And actually to add to the above message, I'm finding it quite humorous that LadyG is in the middle of the pack vs being "The" front runner for postings as she normally is in these games. Seesm like she has met her match in you and Judge... However realistically if you take away all of JM's garbage posts she'd be in the bottom third.