Mafia #23 Revenge

[LesbianChap]

Well, unless things drastically change, here's what's going to happen tonight, with the team counts:

10 Innocent - 6 Mafia
1. I get lynched.
9 Innocent - 6 Mafia
2. Someone gets hit...most likely an innocent. (I'm thinking JM at this point)
8 Innocent - 6 Mafia
3. The previous Det. UDs.
7 Innocent - 6 Mafia

At least I won't be around to witness the final defeat

 

[LesbianChap]

LChap, if you already adressed my earlier question I apologize. I'm trying to do a couple of things at once and have been reading rather quickly. What's your current claim.....ARE you the detective, or WERE you the detective? I need to know, as it'll help me work through some things. Thanks.

I think my last post says it clearly enough.

 

[judgemax]

Jm, a post like this is why people have you leaning mafia. You ask someone else to come up with suspects for you instead of building a case and presenting it yourself. You say you want to be on the winning team even if you are dead, so build a case for Ice or Grins, or whomever and if and when you are lynched and show Innocent people will look back at those posts and suspects you named. But then you say you won't vote for LC as a precaution when half the town is now voting for LC. Well you can't ask others to build a case for someone to vote for and then not follow it. If LC is the Detective and Innocent it will be a great loss, but he isn't helping us, he is just confusing us. So, vote for who you think is the biggest Mafia suspect, don't wait on anyone else to tell you who you should vote for.

well, i am frustrated, and upset, i don't know what else to do, ..i tried pointing things out, WTF is the point?> when i did that, i got told, no one asked for my opinion, so dam, screw it, I Vote to lynch ICE

 

[Lady G]

So before I hit the rope tonight, I'm suspecting Blue, Ice, Grins...I think KOTD may have been turned last night. As for the rest, I'm not too sure...We'll never know if RB made a third Mafia team unless I survive, or we lynch Z as well.

Why do you have to survive for us to know this, why include Z?? Are you trying to say you and Z are part of a new mafia group...is that the supposed reason for you loosing your Detective role???:headshake2:

Here is my thought perhaps Jmax is being made to be a scapegoat. Just a thought remember, I know one person who has slipped by twice now, and thats Grins. SHe was looked at on day 1 and then the whole "Mal is the don" popped up and lots of people myself included let Grins slip by. NOw people were looking hard at Grins again and now LC has "outted himself and she slips by again. In all Honesty my top two picks are Grins and LC. Thoughts anyone?

Beth this is EXACTLY what I have been thinking this entire time I am trying to get through these posts. I was thinking how suspicions were growing on Grins, then the whole Mal thing started (granted she caused much of it), then the same today. The only other thing that keeps going through my mind is Jmax is right in the middle of it both times too, one of the two OR both have to be mafia IMO.

 

[LesbianChap]

Well since you're all going to take my words out of context and put meaning in them that isn't there, here's something more for you paranoid freaks:
I retract my vote for Blue and vote to lynch Grins

 

[bkw1982]

For some reason RB changed the roles around. I was the detective, now I'm not and only a mere innocent, and I can safely reveal what I knew.

Well, unless things drastically change, here's what's going to happen tonight, with the team counts:

10 Innocent - 6 Mafia
1. I get lynched.
9 Innocent - 6 Mafia
2. Someone gets hit...most likely an innocent. (I'm thinking JM at this point)
8 Innocent - 6 Mafia
3. The previous Det. UDs.
7 Innocent - 6 Mafia

At least I won't be around to witness the final defeat

Maybe you went over this before. But were you the first detective or the 2nd? in the last post you said "previous detective" and in the first post you make it seem you were the original detective.

if the "previous detective" UDs does that mean you're goin to UDs. Either you're confused or a bad liar

 

[Lady G]

Gotta agree with you Beth, my top three for a New Mafia team would be LChap, Grins, and cooldude (based on LG's analysis).

However, I would like to see for certain that cool was not in that game mentioned by LG, I think I was in it, and I don't think I have ever played with cool.

Z, I looked back and it was game 14...he WAS in it. I stated that in one of my posts to Mad. I just didn't remember him ever playing in a game with me before, and before I took it any farther with that thought I had to go back and look...it was a Old/New school mafia game.

 

[Madcrawdad]

I think my last post says it clearly enough.

Alright, based on that post, I'm assuming that you're claiming to be the former detective...

To the rest of the town questioning whether RB would or wouldn't have switched the role of detective, I can't say with certainty. But I think for the town, he might have.

Here's one of LChap's very early posts that had me a little concerned. It was his response to me and a couple other folks as to why he had been playing so oddly, apparently trying to get himself lynched.

To have fun.


Been there, tried that, nearly got lynched each time.

Seriously, I've made minor gameplay changes every game, not because my role has changed, but consciously to avoid having tells while adding to the game. It's either that or having no content to slip tells into...

I much prefer the first, but lessons must be taught. :devil: I know, I'm a *******, and I deserve scorn...but then again, I'm not much of a people person anymore.

If you'll notice the part that I bolded 'but lessons must be taught.' When I saw this, one of my first thoughts was, 'what if this guy's a PR and trying to get lynched just to prove a point.' It seems a little far-fetched, but I also play the game on another site and in my first game a townie played intentionally scummy 'to teach a lesson...'

So, if RB knew that LChap was detective and thought he might be intentionally trying to get himself lynched it wouldn't be that far out there IMO for him to consider moving the role. The only thing that I can't work out, though, is why he would have waited until after LChap had apparently begun to actually play the game to do so...

Not positive, but not out of the realm of possibility. A very unusual situation, as whether or not LChap is now innocent or mafia, his revelation serves no purpose other than to get himself killed?

 

[bkw1982]

Alright, based on that post, I'm assuming that you're claiming to be the former detective...

To the rest of the town questioning whether RB would or wouldn't have switched the role of detective, I can't say with certainty. But I think for the town, he might have.

Here's one of LChap's very early posts that had me a little concerned. It was his response to me and a couple other folks as to why he had been playing so oddly, apparently trying to get himself lynched.


If you'll notice the part that I bolded 'but lessons must be taught.' When I saw this, one of my first thoughts was, 'what if this guy's a PR and trying to get lynched just to prove a point.' It seems a little far-fetched, but I also play the game on another site and in my first game a townie played intentionally scummy 'to teach a lesson...'

So, if RB knew that LChap was detective and thought he might be intentionally trying to get himself lynched it wouldn't be that far out there IMO for him to consider moving the role. The only thing that I can't work out, though, is why he would have waited until after LChap had apparently begun to actually play the game to do so...

Not positive, but not out of the realm of possibility. A very unusual situation, as whether or not LChap is now innocent or mafia, his revelation serves no purpose other than to get himself killed?

Mad i would only buy that reasoning if LC wasnt so inconsistant about his story. Even if that was the case i dont think Rb would take the role away from him

 

[ZSandmann]

Z, I looked back and it was game 14...he WAS in it. I stated that in one of my posts to Mad. I just didn't remember him ever playing in a game with me before, and before I took it any farther with that thought I had to go back and look...it was a Old/New school mafia game.

Yup I saw your post and looked back, I too didn't remember him.