Mafia #23 Revenge
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
You were the detective???? Wow...sorry!! If it matters I did lower you some after your last couple posts, and was going to bring that up on next day...but well guess we wont get a next day LOL!
So Ogre is LYING:mad2:
New Mafia Don...Grins
1st Day, wanted ice or hook, got Ice
2nd Day, wanted clown or mad, got Clown
Old Mafia Don...DD
1st Day, wanted ice or hook, got Hooked
2nd Day, wanted zsand or clown, got zsand
Joander-Doctor
Blueiz-Detective
New Mafia wanted ILB hit and ogre invest nite 1, they got the hit
New Mafia wanted KOTD hit and hook invest nite 2, they got the hit
(note, there was disagreement that the hit had been changed to Lady, but I didn't get the e-mail, sorry. I can't control those things.)
Old Mafia wanted ice for hit/invest nite 1.
Old Mafia wanted lady for hit/invest nite 2.
The Detective investigated judge nite one.
As for the UD/ role assignment, there wasn't any rules broken. You may disagree, but then so be it. Sometimes a call has to be made and it is ridiculous to think I would put it up for a vote.
The UD of the Doc falls into a different catagory for me. They UD'd because of their lack of participation/vote. The Town got a bum deal from it and I didn't reassign the role. About a third of you PM'd or posted in the thread thinking I should have "secretly" reassigned the role.
As for the Detective, I will state what happened, since several of you have made up your minds and my explanation will not change anything. I am sure each Game Mod would of handled things differently if in a similar situation.
I check the thread/site every weekday morning before going to work. The Detective wanted to leave the game for reasons not necessary to go into. I told them I would UD them at nightfall. I ran a random number generator on the remaining innocents...and Lchap was selected. I sent him a quick PM and left for work.
I got home a bit late, had an e-mail from the original player that they wanted to stay in the game and I said yes. Sent Lchap a PM to let him know what was going on and I was working on a solution.
I started a quick review of the almost 300 daytime posts. Lchap was obviously well on his way to hanging himself with your votes. You treated him like anybody else who comes out as a power role for the innocents.
I sent Lchap a PM letting him know I would take him out of the game as an Innocent. I rolled the night. That's it.
Roles do occassionally get reassigned in these games. It is a fact. You can't figure in all possible combintions of events and not all of them require any announcements.
Sorry that some of you feel you got "screwed", though I am positive some townies would have the same feeling if I UD'd the Detective without a replacement as the Doc had gone night one.
I still work at my old fart age. Maybe if it had been the weekend I could have handled it differently, but there wasn't anyway for me to stay home on a week day and to have done things differently and it was too close to nightfall to to review and work in another scenario.
Thanks.
1st Day, wanted ice or hook, got Ice
2nd Day, wanted clown or mad, got Clown
Old Mafia Don...DD
1st Day, wanted ice or hook, got Hooked
2nd Day, wanted zsand or clown, got zsand
Joander-Doctor
Blueiz-Detective
New Mafia wanted ILB hit and ogre invest nite 1, they got the hit
New Mafia wanted KOTD hit and hook invest nite 2, they got the hit
(note, there was disagreement that the hit had been changed to Lady, but I didn't get the e-mail, sorry. I can't control those things.)
Old Mafia wanted ice for hit/invest nite 1.
Old Mafia wanted lady for hit/invest nite 2.
The Detective investigated judge nite one.
As for the UD/ role assignment, there wasn't any rules broken. You may disagree, but then so be it. Sometimes a call has to be made and it is ridiculous to think I would put it up for a vote.
The UD of the Doc falls into a different catagory for me. They UD'd because of their lack of participation/vote. The Town got a bum deal from it and I didn't reassign the role. About a third of you PM'd or posted in the thread thinking I should have "secretly" reassigned the role.
As for the Detective, I will state what happened, since several of you have made up your minds and my explanation will not change anything. I am sure each Game Mod would of handled things differently if in a similar situation.
I check the thread/site every weekday morning before going to work. The Detective wanted to leave the game for reasons not necessary to go into. I told them I would UD them at nightfall. I ran a random number generator on the remaining innocents...and Lchap was selected. I sent him a quick PM and left for work.
I got home a bit late, had an e-mail from the original player that they wanted to stay in the game and I said yes. Sent Lchap a PM to let him know what was going on and I was working on a solution.
I started a quick review of the almost 300 daytime posts. Lchap was obviously well on his way to hanging himself with your votes. You treated him like anybody else who comes out as a power role for the innocents.
I sent Lchap a PM letting him know I would take him out of the game as an Innocent. I rolled the night. That's it.
Roles do occassionally get reassigned in these games. It is a fact. You can't figure in all possible combintions of events and not all of them require any announcements.
Sorry that some of you feel you got "screwed", though I am positive some townies would have the same feeling if I UD'd the Detective without a replacement as the Doc had gone night one.
I still work at my old fart age. Maybe if it had been the weekend I could have handled it differently, but there wasn't anyway for me to stay home on a week day and to have done things differently and it was too close to nightfall to to review and work in another scenario.
Thanks.
I don't get why the UD was going to wait till night fall. If the role was reassigned then the UD should have been announced at that time.
Since the UD wasn't though I think once the role was removed and reassigned it shouldn't have gone back even though the person decided to return to the game.
Just MO as a Mod.
I don't hate RB and I'm sure in time I'll probably return to play but I think just need to sit out a while.
It was a great game while it lasted.
Since the UD wasn't though I think once the role was removed and reassigned it shouldn't have gone back even though the person decided to return to the game.
Just MO as a Mod.
I don't hate RB and I'm sure in time I'll probably return to play but I think just need to sit out a while.
It was a great game while it lasted.
all I can say is WTF.........how.....,why......,what.......I am so lost and sad by all that has happened, And Clown please don't leave these games your half the reason I play, all the vets are you guys rock and I love to play these games.
I'm sure he will return to the games and just needs a break, many of the Vets...like Ice, HN, Clown take breaks now and again, I'm sure this is just one of the times he needs to sit out for a few.
I for one would be very sad if him or Ice didn't come back to the game, they are great to play with (you to Grins
).Unfortunately temperatures rise, at some points feelings/pride are hurt and some just need to step back, recoup, and come back full force.
I also am not upset at RB, I can understand the feelings of the players that quit, if they had investigated and thought they had the Detective...but I also understand why RB did what he did, as I said I think he did what he felt best at the time...this is why I would not be able to Mod a game, not sure how I would handle these situations (that and I'm just nuts:lipssealedsmilie
. I respect all the Mods decisions, I may not always agree...but everyone handles things differently and if it wasn't for them, we wouldn't be playing...so my kudos to ALL those who have and will Mod!
I could take youLOL..what a crazy freakin game..
i'll be ready with my ropes and duct tape mal
Bob sincerely, no grudges. While I don't agree with the game modding this game I think your heart was in the right place.
