My top suspect at this point is Beth. As Mad pointed out, she has her timeline all messed up. Oh what a tangled web we weave.
I vote to lynch Beth
I vote to lynch Beth
Mafia who done it! The Play
- Thread starter judgemax
- Start date
I still believe there were atleast 2 mafia on emo. A few scenerios.
1) Ice is mafia and he jumped on Emo cause of "tht post". With help from his crew they take out an innocent and save himself, all the while they have a good excuse why they voted for emo.
2 ice is innocent, and the mafia helped ice lynch emo with an excuse of "that post" to later back em up to why they voted emo. They'll then turn around to try and used the info against ice.
IMO either one is possible. The big unknow being, is ice innocent or guilty? Either LC or HN, or both, IMO is maifa.
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
I'll be honest and say, I didn't read Emo's posts the same way you did. I read them (it seemed) like what he meant to say. That he didn't know who the boss was because he didn't have one.
And no, it's not skimming, it much more interpretation than anything else. I've noticed this about some players, they take one little thing and nit pick it to death. That isn't a bad thing, because they can tease the clues out of someone, but in some cases, an innocent phrase (meant in humor or whatever) can cause the demise of the player saying it. We've all had it happen to us.
I personally thought that you (Ice) were jumping all over one little comment and hoping enough people listened to you to save your life.
Maybe my first thought was right and you are the don. Emo wasn't a sacrifical mafia, but an innocent who just happened to say the wrong thing, the wrong way.
I can see the lure for Beth as a potential mafia here. It's a good analysis by Mad. However, I'm not real fond of charlie's sudden appearance and almost instant train jumping. We have a very different charlie here.
rb is also playing differently than normal. Very quiet with a single short after post.
Who else seems suspicious to me? That's a good question and I'm glad you asked. Ice is by no means off my watch list. (see above)
On the other hand, I'm wondering if the Don is one of the REAL quiet players. Surely Ice or rb or someone like that wouldn't let a team mate UD. I know it does happen, but anything would have been better than a UD. Maybe the reason Andi went out is because they haven't been communicating very much.
This train of thought would lead me to suspect the don as being charlie, beth, or bkw.
I'm still worried about Rb & Charlie being so quiet. I think the Colonel is laying low and probably letting his or her team mates do the work. I'd also include bkw in that group. I don't think they're all mafia, but I'm guessing one of them is in charge of the scum.
Cory- I think you're probably innocent, but sheesh dude. Why couldn't you let the shading thing go?
Mad- I've been back and forth on all game. I think he caught Beth though and so he definitely looks more innocent to me now.
I vote to lynch Beth pending input from the lurkers.
Cory- I think you're probably innocent, but sheesh dude. Why couldn't you let the shading thing go?
Mad- I've been back and forth on all game. I think he caught Beth though and so he definitely looks more innocent to me now.
I vote to lynch Beth pending input from the lurkers.
Ok...I vote to lynch beth
Reasons: Skipping around my question. That whole incident when she listed mad as leaning innocent, but put him as a suspect. Also, she was the one who saved Ice.
My vote is subject to change...and this is NOT a train vote. I'm interested to see how many people stack up on beth...or if people start trying hard to create another target.
Matt
Reasons: Skipping around my question. That whole incident when she listed mad as leaning innocent, but put him as a suspect. Also, she was the one who saved Ice.
My vote is subject to change...and this is NOT a train vote. I'm interested to see how many people stack up on beth...or if people start trying hard to create another target.
Matt
I want to know why in better depth why you think so and so is leaning mafia or innocent. Just throwing out a list with one line comments isn't really helping as all you do is reiterate what has been said. Something has to be standing out to you about players you think are mafia.
I would have jumped it as quick if I didn't have a single vote on me.I took it as him saying his boss never contacted him. I could have cared less if I was lynched. It would have shown that you guys were just trying to get rid of a good player. In death we find truth.
I fully expect to see you vote me again since you feel so strongly about my mafiaism. Or are you to worried to be found out?
I can buy the excuse that Emo was trying to say what Ogre/Bkw says they thought Emo meant. As stated earlier in the post I though he meant that he was never contacted. Yes JMs PM to Emo would have told him who was on his team but Emo could have not understood that 1 person was the Don and the rest just mafia.There by not knowing who was his boss.
Thats the way I took it at least.
RB and Charlies quietness bothers me also. Especially Charlies vote and run posts.
When I saw his vote on Beth my 1st instinct was that Beth is innocent but with people looking at her maybe a vote would help start a train.
My 2nd thought was that Charlie is being looked at also so if he voted Beth then others might shy away from voting her.
I'm not sure yet, I want to see more of the days events, but I might switch to Beth as this could be a shot at protecting the Don.
Check the vote count, she wasnt the one to save ice.........
This post is after Ice and CL vote andi just 2 mins apart. HN isnt openly defending Andi, but to me he seems to try and make ice and CL look guilty.
If night was in the next couple of minutes i would vote to lynch HN
I vote to lynch HN
Cory why would you think Beth was the one to save me? Her vote for Emo was actually the 2nd vote. If anyone saved me it was HN but in reality all he did was tie it up for a 50/50 shot. I was saved by a flip of the coin.
I could somewhat see that. HN knew we were both innocent so why not tie it up and let the coin flip determine which goes home.
BUT.. If HN was mafia then why not just let the bigger threat go home and then lynch Emo the next night. Doesn't make sense to me. I think my vote stays pending on what Beth reveals tomorrow.
