Mafia who done it! The Play

[IceH2O]

Whatever guys. All you are doing is trying to confuse the town but switching to players they had listed to vote for. Hoping to get them caught on multiple suspects so you can all converge on 1 innocent.

Innocents stay put and we'll win,don't fall for their late game tactics.

 

[IceH2O]

Relax, Ice I was just kidding you. But if you want to look at the timeline.

Here you appear to be willing to bury the hatchet for the time being. Fine





Then a little while later we have this one where it looks like you're floating my name as scum again. So much for waiting until the end, huh?

Just covering the bases Mad. Since I still have doubts I need to put them out there.

 

[OgreMkV]

More and more sounding like mafia ice. You and rb in cahoots?

 

[IceH2O]

Hooked dropped you, I'm trying to keep it even.

Hooked dropped me after you voted me, did you post to quickly?

 

[Madcrawdad]

Whatever guys. All you are doing is trying to confuse the town but switching to players they had listed to vote for. Hoping to get them caught on multiple suspects so you can all converge on 1 innocent.

Innocents stay put and we'll win,don't fall for their late game tactics.

Agreed. We live or die as a town... this late confusion makes me feel pretty good that Hooked is our boy...

 

[LesbianChap]

Mad's and Ice's comments make me think that Ice may be the Col...if it's a 50/50 toss, I'd rather it be for the Col. Ogre's already moved, now just for the other two innocents.

I retract my vote for HN and vote to lynch Ice

 

[Madcrawdad]

there they go....

 

[Hooked Newbie]

fair enough

I see a trend here... try to follow along.

you probably will be beth...one to lynch and one to hit...

Rb accuses Beth of being scum...

THis is the vote count as of #518
RB-Ice(450),Ogre(451),Ice retract(482),Ice(485)
LC-Mad(498)
Mad-Lc(486)
HN-Bk(461)
Ice-RB(503)
no votes from HN, or myself

Now Beth points out that I haven't voted yet.

Well, it looks like my vote on LChap is going nowhere...

I retract my vote on LChap, and vote to lynch IceH2O

The town needs to come together. Apathy is going to kill us... All 4 townies need to be on the same mafia member to have a chance. Anything less will allow the mafia to move late for the win...

It looks like nightfall will be tonight, so we really need to start talking this through. Sitting out there on what you might consider a good vote will doom the town, even if you're right.

Mad switches to LC.

RB (2) -Ice(450) Ogre(451) Ice(485)
LC (0) -Mad(498)
Mad (1) - LC(486)
HN (2) -Bkw(461) Beth(520)
Ice (3) -RB(503) HN (522) Mad(523)

This should be the latest vote count. Please speak up if you notice something incorrect...

I would like to hear from BKW regarding his current thoughts on HN/Ice, as I would consider moving from Ice to HN.

I think before we go with the nightfall tonight, though, we need acknowledgement from all players that they realize that night will actually fall tonight.

Mad is worried that his teammates won't be on?

I'm fine with 24 hours.

I'm not real sure about moving to Ice. If things stay as they are, then I guess I would have to switch, but rb is mafia in my book and hooked may be.

I revoke my vote for rb at this time.

I've got some rereading to do.

Ogre flips.

I've never said I would stay on RB. I've said RB or LC then HN and then Mad or whoever was left would be the order I'd want to do lynches.

Mad that was a great case against me. Since I've been totally played then yes thats what has me setup to look mafia.

I want to get who we think is the Col. If you think its LC I'll join you there. I don't know if HN is Col but if the numbers need to be there to just out mafia I'll vote there. I don't want my vote to be sitting where its no good. We need to choose 2 players, the innocents need to be on the same player.

If others will agree to vote LC I think he is the better bet to be Col.


Or its RB and all this is to protect him from being the lynch and just taking out other mafia to prolong the game. But since Bkw thinks RB is innocent and I don't think he will move I retract my vote on RB and vote to lynch HN

Thinking out loud here. Bear with me.

RB (2) -Ice(450) Ogre(451) Ice(485)
LC (0) -Mad(498)
Mad (1) - LC(486)
HN (2) -Bkw(461) Beth(520)
Ice (3) -RB(503) HN (522) Mad(523)

OK, if Ice is innocent, then there are two innocents on rb (assuming I'm there to). With that in mind, then where are the other two innocents? And more importantly, where are the four mafia?

If Ice is innocent, then more than likely there are at least two mafia on him... if not three. That means rb, mad, and hooked are mafia... or at least two are.

Now, I really think that the mafia have split up so that if the innocents are split, then they can control the voting. We'll see a sudden surge of vote changes near the end. Whoever does that, then we can nail them... if the innocents can all get together at the end of the day.

So, say two mafia on Ice and that leaves two mafia out of either bkw, LC, and beth. I was pretty concerned about beth, but then, she says that she'll switch to rb. If that's the case, then I'm not worried. If all the innocents go to rb, then we'll have at worst a tie going into nightfall.

bkw seems more of a hit & run voter, so I'm not so sure if his vote is mafia or innocent. At this point it seems pretty useless, so hopefully it will change. Same for LC (except the hit & run part).

OK, so I move back on rb and beth moves to rb. That makes it 3-3 rb and ice with the ENTIRE CONTROL of the night falling to LC and bkw... I'm not sure I'm comfortable with that.

It's kind of funny. At this point, it all comes down to whether you believe Ice is innocent or not. I know mad thinks Ice is guilty as heck. I'm thinking that rb's vote is almost an OMGUS vote. His single defense was the line, 'if you vote for me we lose.' Which has pretty been used by every mafia in every game ever.

I vote to lynch rb again.

RB, it's possible that the mafia will vote each other and then hop off last-minute. If you're innocent, your singleton vote on Ice virtually guarantees a town loss (regardless of HN's status)... If you're mafia, it looks like you could be protecting HN.

Tell you what, I'll not let you blame me for a singleton vote.


I retract my vote on Ice. I vote to lynch hooked.

Let me know when the next sign up thread is posted.

Wow, looks like everyone bailed on Ice.

I revoke my vote for hooked and vote to lynch Ice.

So Ogre are you the missing mafia piece? If you're innocent you just gave them the vote they needed for the late switch back to me and to have the numbers to win the game outright.

Whatever guys. All you are doing is trying to confuse the town but switching to players they had listed to vote for. Hoping to get them caught on multiple suspects so you can all converge on 1 innocent.

Innocents stay put and we'll win,don't fall for their late game tactics.

I retract my vote to lynch Rbishop and I vote to lynch Ice.

 

[bkw1982]

Far as i see.

Hn 5 votes-Bkw(461) Beth(520)Ice(527)mad(549)rb(579)

Mad 1 LC(486)

RB 1 HN (585)

Ice 1 ogre (583)

 

[OgreMkV]

You're behind bkw LC and HN are now on Ice.