Mafia who done it! The Play

Madcrawdad said:
He did help vote off Hooked...

Even putting aside their last minute voting heroics, I'm liking LChap and Ogre for scum. Also given the fact that Beth was on (and I saw you there Beth -- and then I saw you disappear, so don't deny) when she said she wouldn't be I'm liking her more again.

Ice, given the fact that Ogre was in front of your lynch on Day 1 and never waivered I'm thinking that Ogre and you are very likely on different teams. The fact that Ogre goes rb, but then votes Beth when we vote LChap...I'm liking LChap for the Colonel.
Click to expand...

Well one of the mafia voted for HN, that much is obvious. If its Beth then why didn't she switch last minute to me? I think the mafia player is trying to hide among us. We can lynch LC then Ogre and if neither is the Col then we'll have a 1-1 situation anyway.
 
IceH2O said:
Well one of the mafia voted for HN, that much is obvious. If its Beth then why didn't she switch last minute to me? I think the mafia player is trying to hide among us. We can lynch LC then Ogre and if neither is the Col then we'll have a 1-1 situation anyway.
Click to expand...

There was a mafia player on HN, and it was Beth. As Beth has a tendancy to make herself look scummy, I'm pretty sure that she's been instructed to hide out. Her whole timeline lie (regarding her Emo vote & not catching her botched vote even though it was mentioned 3 times) coupled with the fact that she was on at nightfall when she said she wouldn't be pretty much confirms it for me.

I think that Ogre and LChap may be trying a distancing plan from the Don here. I know I said I liked LChap for Don, but the more I think about it, it doesn't make sense for the Don to make that late move onto you (without enough votes for the win).

Ogre and LChap are both dead in the water, and I think they're now distancing themselves from Beth by voting her. IMO Beth could be the likely Colonel, as she's the one who stayed behind...

Either way, I would consider leaving Ogre til last, as he's likely just a mafia goon...Voting Beth or LChap would likely secure the win for the town as opposed to leaving us tied at the end and just waiting on a coin flip. Either way, I'd be willing to vote them in a different order (ie, not leaving Ogre til last) if that would make townies more secure in my status (mafia v innocent). I just think that Beth before Ogre gives us a better shot at a win vs. a 50-50 shot at the end.

I'm pretty sure were looking at RB/Ice/Mad vs. Beth/LChap/Ogre
 
I was not on last night, I didn't sign out, but I was not on after my post of not being here for nightfall

I was watching the Longest Yard with my family.
 
bethkira2000 said:
I was not on last night, I didn't sign out, but I was not on after my post of not being here for nightfall

I was watching the Longest Yard with my family.
Click to expand...

Funny, I saw your name there around nightfall, and then it disappeared a few minutes later. Care to explain, or do you just want to say that I'm lying?

Beth, I don't know if you ever addressed the Emo thing. Remember you said his comment about not saving anyone didn't sit right and caused you to vote for him? Then we clarified that you had to mean that his comment was the reason you never took your vote off, as his comment didn't come until well after you voted... You claim to have seen Emo's comment before nightfall, but you missed several mentions of your botched vote. How might that have happened?
 
Because I used thread search on Emo, I really didn't notice anything else. I just thought that Emo even though innocent, really wan't being helpful and I thought it would be a good idea to remove him, and leave those of us who wanted to play here.

And I was on last night I think around sevenish, and then like no more than 5 minutes later I shut off my computer. I never log/sign out of AC. But I wasn't on after I posted.
 
bethkira2000 said:
Because I used thread search on Emo, I really didn't notice anything else. I just thought that Emo even though innocent, really wan't being helpful and I thought it would be a good idea to remove him, and leave those of us who wanted to play here.

So you came back on before night (but after you voted for Emo) and chose not to read the thread? You just decided to do a thread search on Emo instead?

And I was on last night I think around sevenish, and then like no more than 5 minutes later I shut off my computer. I never log/sign out of AC. But I wasn't on after I posted.
Click to expand...

Night fell around 7 here (central), and you said that you were signing off around 6 central. Your name was on and off around 7 central, which would have been during your movie....
 
bethkira2000 said:
Because I used thread search on Emo, I really didn't notice anything else. I just thought that Emo even though innocent, really wan't being helpful and I thought it would be a good idea to remove him, and leave those of us who wanted to play here.

So you came back on before night (but after you voted for Emo) and chose not to read the thread? You just decided to do a thread search on Emo instead?


And I was on last night I think around sevenish, and then like no more than 5 minutes later I shut off my computer. I never log/sign out of AC. But I wasn't on after I posted.

Night fell around 7 here (central), and you said that you were signing off around 6 central. Your name was on and off around 7 central, which would have been during your movie....
Click to expand...

Sorry forgot to change the color of my response in the quote box (see previous post). Here's how the post should have looked....
 
nightfall, in 7 and one half hours.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom