Mafia #27: Survivor ACville Island

johnlarson66 said:
Why would I lie?

If mafia, why would I choose such a move? What is there to be torn about. If I am lying, then I am dead the next day.

I think we can be sure that Fungi is a member of the Emerald Alliance.

What we can't be sure of is what I am:

Am I a member of the Emerald Alliance and have chosen to gain the trust of the town by killing one of my two teamates? Which makes me a big target for the Lazuli Alliance to hit me or to cast doubt on me.

Am I am member of the Lazuli Alliance and have taken a 50/50 chance to name Emerald Alliance member?

Am I an innocent that has used his investigation and has made that information public?

If Fungi comes up innocent, then by all means banish me. Let me be the one that the mafia teams goes after. Which at this point, I do not think they will. My investigation is spent.

I see no reason to wait.
Click to expand...
I am really thinking you knew he was going to be on the Emerald team b/c he was a team mate of yours.....
IceH2O said:
What I'd be worried about is that you did indeed name a team mate or you named a player from the other team.

If you named a team mate you buy some safety for yourself.

You might have opened yourself up to the other team but they need to get rid of you anyway to win.Since anyone NOT on their team is the enemy you were a target to begin with.But if the innocents believe you it will be hard to lynch you so the other team needs to use a coconut hit,which is only a 50/50 shot.

If you named a player from the other team its the same scenario. Innocents less willingly to lynch you,or need to use an investigation on you, and they still need to do a coconut hit.

You have essentially forced a hit on yourself to which you have a 50/50 shot of surviving.

Since the chance of you just naming a player and hoping they are on the other team is to risky I think you named a team mate or are honestly an innocent.

Now the question becomes do one of the 3 innocents waste an investigation to find out if you are telling the truth.Well other 2 since if you are one then ones been used already.
Click to expand...
I think Ice was on to something here, I really do.

You know I am done multi-quoting, with Ice being the one to get hit, your comment on how you "think" it is the Emeralds that hit him along with everything I just read and how you kept saying what a great plan/idea it would be for someone to of done this...I am thinking that is exactly what you did, I am going to use my ONE vote switch and I retract my banish on RB and vote to banish John from the Island

Now which way will RB go for the tie breaker???
 
I vote to banish Lady G from the island....
 
About 9.5 hours until night...

3 Lg: HN, rb, jl

2 jl: GC, Lg

GC: jl

rb: Lg

John, I'm assuming you are voting for Lg, but you never retracted your vote against GC.
 
Cory Lover said:
About 9.5 hours until night...

3 Lg: HN, rb, jl

2 jl: GC, Lg

GC: jl

rb: Lg

John, I'm assuming you are voting for Lg, but you never retracted your vote against GC.
Click to expand...

I retract my vote for the mafia scum known as Gracecat (GC for short) and vote to banish Lady G from the island.

I am also hoping that there might be a slim chance that it is not a 3 - 3 - 3 player split.

This voting makes no sense, unless Lady G is in fact innocent, her failure to vote for GC and her distrust of me being innocent will most likely be the cause of the innocents losing. She brought the votes on herself.

The only thing that even comes close to making sense is if there are 2 more innocents. I felt the GC plan was very reasonable and in no way see her as a possible innocent, her claim to have investigated me is, well is plain old silly.

I am innocent, I can only hope to not get hit in the head with a coconut. It will suprise me if there is not a late minute vote change from HN or rb to me. Which will be insane, because HN has investigated LG and rb has been voting for her all along.

The way it sits, makes no sense if it is a 3 - 3 - 3 split.

If I have gotten played by HN and rb I 100% blame Lady G.
 
I haven't played much today guys. I apologize.

Ya know John, may be. It may be possible you're telling the truth. And I'm being irrational by digging in my heels from the get go. I don't know. LG has a strong case in front of her. I think you're just as positive I'm not innocent as I am of your position.

It can only get crazier.
 
My list right now (just in case)... LG & GC. I was sure of JL's innocence until the recent posting and paranoia so I'm not sure of the 3rd. Gotta be him OR Rb though.
 
johnlarson66 said:
I retract my vote for the mafia scum known as Gracecat (GC for short) and vote to banish Lady G from the island.

I am also hoping that there might be a slim chance that it is not a 3 - 3 - 3 player split.

This voting makes no sense, unless Lady G is in fact innocent, her failure to vote for GC and her distrust of me being innocent will most likely be the cause of the innocents losing. She brought the votes on herself.

The only thing that even comes close to making sense is if there are 2 more innocents. I felt the GC plan was very reasonable and in no way see her as a possible innocent, her claim to have investigated me is, well is plain old silly.

I am innocent, I can only hope to not get hit in the head with a coconut. It will suprise me if there is not a late minute vote change from HN or rb to me. Which will be insane, because HN has investigated LG and rb has been voting for her all along.

The way it sits, makes no sense if it is a 3 - 3 - 3 split.

If I have gotten played by HN and rb I 100% blame Lady G.
Click to expand...

LOL, you will blame me that is actually a quite funny to me, OBVIOUSLY RB or HN is playin ya!!! Don't worry, I'm sure their votes will stay.

As this is my last night (unless of coarse JLs little 3-3-3 thing happens) I just want to say I do not know what I think of anyone at this point, there are so many ways to look at things...John, you just seem to have to many points of interest, including this last post?? HN aside from your "investigation" against me I believed you to be innocent, RB is surely NOT playing the "innocent" he has in other games and Grace...well, I just don't know, many things scream evil from you, but then again as I said you are new I know my first time as a innocent actually all alone I was crazy (like I'm not now:eek:) LOL...so really I just don't know.
 
Wow, only a half hour till night fall and no one is posting...LOL, are we that confident in our vote this evening???
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom