Mafia #28: The Play

rbishop said:
In general it was to hook since I quoted his post....though many others have been on line since the swayde post and either chose to ignore the slip or didn't catch it. Hook was one of them that has viewed several times since then, and chose not to say anything, then questions why I didn't....pretty scummie, IMO.
Click to expand...

Keep posting.... I find it very interesting that you have stuck to one liners until put in the spotlight.
 
IceH2O said:
Plausible explanation but its going to definitely force me to watch you more closely. My only problem with it is that you made numerous other posts in the same time frame so obviously you had more then enough time to post. Then you again ask JM about her post in the quoted post. Why not question Lives vote for me? Seems like you are trying hard to stick to JM.
Click to expand...


My posts were all within 15-20 minutes of each other. I was reading, and commenting while I had a chance. Just as I am doing now in the free time I have before the raid starts. I really wouldn't expect you to not keep an eye on me, I'd be more amazed and very concerned if you let it slide.

Why would/should I question the vote for you? He/She said it was because you seem mafia to them. I vote because I believe someone to be mafia many times even if I can't actually build a case, just based on intuition and how I feel about them in general from reading all their posts. I may not agree with him/her, but it's how they feel. I definitely wish there was a better reason, but at least there is a reason. And I am certainly not going to defend you when I have absolutely no idea what you are.

Pretty big stretch to say I am trying really hard to stick to JM when all I did was mistake her with the post before it and show curiosity in something someone else brought up that she'd posted.
 
rbishop said:
In general it was to hook since I quoted his post....though many others have been on line since the swayde post and either chose to ignore the slip or didn't catch it. Hook was one of them that has viewed several times since then, and chose not to say anything, then questions why I didn't....pretty scummie, IMO.
Click to expand...


Who else was there that didn't say anything?
 
Well I gotta go, at least I was able to get in some time after dinner. Hopefully I've answered everyone's spoken and unspoken questions. I am going to hold off on voting until tomorrow when I've got some time to do some reviewing, but as of right now, RB is looking to be a likely candidate for me.
 
judgemax said:
your hysterical...before you try and throw suspicion on me, check your facts.

1) I AM FEMALE

2) i am not quiet, ask anyone who has played prior, or talks to me.

3) I have played many of these games with hooked and Ice, to know, that something is wrong with Their play starting that way.

4) I am not trying to sway anyones opinion, If i was, it would have been more obvious, i was just stating my own opinion.
Click to expand...


Oh, my apologies to Judgemax, I didnt know you were a she!!
--- Sorry ma'am!

But I still dont trust ya...
 
rbishop said:
just waiting to see who noticed first and who made note about it...it could be a big deal and it could be small and insignificant. More so, how you handle it and continue to handle it will be the deciding factors for me...and my vote.
Click to expand...


I actually would have liked this answer if it was to my question instead of getting the answer of the post below

rbishop said:
Why be the first to point it out and get accused of starting something over nothing?
Click to expand...



If we're going to be afraid to point things out then we may as well just all right now lay out the people we think are mafia and if any of us are correct on all of them then the innocents win.

This entire game is based on people pointing out inconsistencies. Well I guess for those who actually play and not those who just want to let others do the leg work while they sit back and reap the benefits or hide to not get connected to their team mates.
 
good point Ice.... I wasn't feeling good about that answer either and it goes against all I thought Rb was about but I just wasn't sure exactly what rubbed me wrong about it... I guess rb, just not used to you waiting for someone else to mention something because of the fear of being accused... like Ice said, pointing things out is what the game is about... isn't it? For someone who was a mod in plenty of the games, shouldn't you be the first to know that?
 
Swayde said:
My posts were all within 15-20 minutes of each other. I was reading, and commenting while I had a chance. Just as I am doing now in the free time I have before the raid starts. I really wouldn't expect you to not keep an eye on me, I'd be more amazed and very concerned if you let it slide.

Why would/should I question the vote for you? He/She said it was because you seem mafia to them. I vote because I believe someone to be mafia many times even if I can't actually build a case, just based on intuition and how I feel about them in general from reading all their posts. I may not agree with him/her, but it's how they feel. I definitely wish there was a better reason, but at least there is a reason. And I am certainly not going to defend you when I have absolutely no idea what you are.

Pretty big stretch to say I am trying really hard to stick to JM when all I did was mistake her with the post before it and show curiosity in something someone else brought up that she'd posted.
Click to expand...

You're not the least bit interested in why she thinks I'm mafia? Its her very 1st game,what does she have to go on besides the joke posts? She can't even claim intuition because she doesn't know how I play.

How can you be interested in why JM thinks HN and I are evil,she explained it, but not why Live thinks I am.JM actually had a good reason,though its wrong but possible.

So far you and Live are my top 2 suspects. I might keep Live around a 2nd day just to see if she accidentally tells us who the other team mates might be.
So with that for now I vote to lynch Sway.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom