Mafia #28: The Play
- Thread starter jpappy789
- Start date
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
So why did HN think Rb or Ice would hit him?
Rb said he would hit Ice, but what if they were on the same team.
I had expected more people to be posting but I guess a lot ran off for the night. I get home from work at 5:30 so I need to vote now in order to be safe from UD. I will hopefully find time tomorrow at lunch to post and see what others think.
I vote to lynch LOL (again).
Other suspects,
John
Swayde
And now I have to add Ice to the list based on DD and HN. I'm not solid on this will look back tomorrow.
I vote to lynch LOL (again).
Other suspects,
John
Swayde
And now I have to add Ice to the list based on DD and HN. I'm not solid on this will look back tomorrow.
I think it is pretty obvious why he thought Ice would hit him after their earlier exchange. And I guess he thought Rb was Mafia because of his bizarre posting. I'm inclined to think that neither would be the Don because they are both good enough players to know that the interaction they had with him would bring everyone down on them in a hurry. But then you get into the Princess Bride scenario I love to quote. If they think we will think that, then they will think we won't think they would do it so they do. Rb is playing like he has for the last few games I've followed including the one I hosted.
Sorry that was pretty circular logic, I don't think they are both Mafia, if one of the two are I would pick Ice over Rb.
Crap...
I also think the DR role should be given to another innocent due to a UD that was PMed in. If it was a normal UD I could see it not being swapped.
Well I said if DD showed innocent that RB was probably mafia so to avenge DD and HNs death I vote to lynch RB
With night fall at 7 PM EST and me never knowing what time I'll be home I'm placing my vote now. If I get home early enough to look over the thread and make comments the vote could possibly change.But something huge would need to happen or if the vote isn't going to help and needs to be placed on the suspects below:
JM- post 243 she was uneasy on voting DD, this is basically the same as saying she will show up innocent. JM why DD over anyone else with votes? You had 4 other people you could have voted for.At the time you could have voted Live or even helped put the nail in the coffin on Rb
Zig- what was the deciding factor in voting me last minute? You never looked my way the entire time. JM was the only one I saw you say you didn't trust.
Live- you need to start answering questions, the more you side step the more it looks like you are hiding something.
I also think the DR role should be given to another innocent due to a UD that was PMed in. If it was a normal UD I could see it not being swapped.
Well I said if DD showed innocent that RB was probably mafia so to avenge DD and HNs death I vote to lynch RB
With night fall at 7 PM EST and me never knowing what time I'll be home I'm placing my vote now. If I get home early enough to look over the thread and make comments the vote could possibly change.But something huge would need to happen or if the vote isn't going to help and needs to be placed on the suspects below:
JM- post 243 she was uneasy on voting DD, this is basically the same as saying she will show up innocent. JM why DD over anyone else with votes? You had 4 other people you could have voted for.At the time you could have voted Live or even helped put the nail in the coffin on Rb
Zig- what was the deciding factor in voting me last minute? You never looked my way the entire time. JM was the only one I saw you say you didn't trust.
Live- you need to start answering questions, the more you side step the more it looks like you are hiding something.
honestly, i thought she was the most likely candidate, i was uneasy with all the choices, and wanted to vote you or HN, i was sure one, or both of you were mafia. so, since HN showed as innocent, I am thinking, its got to be you
honestly, i thought she was the most likely candidate, i was uneasy with all the choices, and wanted to vote you or HN, i was sure one, or both of you were mafia. so, since HN showed as innocent, I am thinking, its got to be you
So then why didn't you vote me?
At the time of your vote it was:
Ice 1
RB 3
Cory 1
Live 2
DD 2
You would have moved me 1 away from tying RB and put me in a tie with DD and Live. Who knows what would have happened? A vote my way and a good explanation might have shifted others to me.
Weak excuse if you ask me, you should always vote who you think is mafia and only swap if needed to another mafia suspect.At the time of your vote you could have gone to me no problem. Did you go to DD to protect RB?
Here is the complete run-down for Day 1.
Night 1: Sunday 3/2 @ 6 PM CST
No Vote: Reef; Mee-Mee
2-LOL: Charlie(24) Zsandmann(155)
2-Ice: Hooked(33) LOL(66) Zig(278)
Swayde: Ice(150)
1-Cory: John(154)
3-Rb: Hooked(156) DD(200) Swayde(202)
JM: LadyG(181)
5-DD: Rbishop(184) Ice(203) Lady G(232) Judge(243) Cory(245)
[FONT="]MM: Cory(199) Lady(215)I am off to bed.
[/FONT]
Night 1: Sunday 3/2 @ 6 PM CST
No Vote: Reef; Mee-Mee
2-LOL: Charlie(24) Zsandmann(155)
2-Ice: Hooked(33) LOL(66) Zig(278)
Swayde: Ice(150)
1-Cory: John(154)
3-Rb: Hooked(156) DD(200) Swayde(202)
JM: LadyG(181)
5-DD: Rbishop(184) Ice(203) Lady G(232) Judge(243) Cory(245)
[FONT="]MM: Cory(199) Lady(215)I am off to bed.
[/FONT]
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
I would also put judgemax high on a list of mafia. I think her train jump on DD instead of voting Ice or HN, who she thought where both mafia is suspect.
OMG!!! That was a terrible nightfall!!! They took me Papi!!! DD, innocent and MM too....Niko, I hope all is ok with you!!!
Sorry guys but I am wondering more about Jmax now with all the joking that was going on throwing that "I'm the Don" thing in there...it a "cute" way to come out knowing no one would take it to heart.
RB now I am more uneasy about you, and Ice....well I said that if DD came back innocent I would worry more about you, but MM was innocent also...I find it hard to think you would of cared which way I voted if you were Mafia cause you would of known that they were both innocent don't think it would of mattered to you so much.
I also find it very interesting that both newbs went for Ice...did anyone else find that odd??
Sorry guys but I am wondering more about Jmax now with all the joking that was going on throwing that "I'm the Don" thing in there...it a "cute" way to come out knowing no one would take it to heart.
RB now I am more uneasy about you, and Ice....well I said that if DD came back innocent I would worry more about you, but MM was innocent also...I find it hard to think you would of cared which way I voted if you were Mafia cause you would of known that they were both innocent don't think it would of mattered to you so much.
I also find it very interesting that both newbs went for Ice...did anyone else find that odd??
