Mafia #29 Biological Badlands #2

IceH2O said:
Just posting a thought.

I actually have you pretty low on the suspect list along with Grins. Plant hasn't tiffed me in either direction so I didn't feel the need to include her at all. Jpap and JL are the ones that really stand out the most along with Zig. I feel that if Zig is evil then it cinches that Ogre is also.
Click to expand...

I buy the highlighted part, but Zig's posts today have seemed more "townie" and Ogre hasn't really tweaked me since early on day one with the morse unrest.
 
Grins said:
I wanted to comment on this one in it's own post. I've been thinking about who might be on a team together since before nightfall yesterday. I'm having more luck tying who might not be on a team together. Maybe listing those will help everyone else that is as confused as me at this point.

Based on conflict coming from at least one side; aggressiveness of the conflict; the conflicts being recent (I'm giving a pass to some of the early first day stuff when it has been dropped since) I'm thinking that the following people are not on the same team. I hope this is self explanatory, if not ask me.

Cat: Grins
Cory: Jpap, Hook
Hook: Cory, Jpap, Ogre
Ice: Ogre, Zig
Jpap: Cory, Hook
Ogre: Hook, Ice, Plant
Plant: Ogre
Zig: Ice

I'm starting to consider that
Jpap isn't on a team with Ice or John as well.

I tried to go back and review some older posts to see one I might have missed but my eyes started to go cross-eyed. I think there are some others I'd not pair with Zig but help me out here, what else doesn't make much sense as possible mafia teammates?
Click to expand...


Good Lord, don't put something else in my mind to think about! I have enough trouble trying to link people together without having to try out who I don't think links together.


I tried but there are just to many possibilities, and not enough answers for me yet.
 
Oh good grief I figured a newbie would bring up me not listing myself, but then I thought an experienced player would roll their eyes when I said no one could be on a team with me since I know I'm innocent. Leave it to you to throw a monkey wrench into it by going with the more newbie like question. :silly: Sincerely though, I'd like to see some others make the list of who couldn't be on a team with me based on their own thoughts, I only listed Cat because he has so recently been on the offensive and it seemed silly to not list that one.

And You're right, I didn't list JL, I thought I did. I'd say he isn't on a team with Cory, Cat or Jpap. And no Hook, he isn't on with me either.

And as for my worst fear...I'm trying to decide if I'm happy or terrified that I suspect you and Ice both less than I did yesterday. Terrified would probably be the prudent thing.
 
Grins said:
Oh good grief I figured a newbie would bring up me not listing myself, but then I thought an experienced player would roll their eyes when I said no one could be on a team with me since I know I'm innocent. Leave it to you to throw a monkey wrench into it by going with the more newbie like question. :silly: Sincerely though, I'd like to see some others make the list of who couldn't be on a team with me based on their own thoughts, I only listed Cat because he has so recently been on the offensive and it seemed silly to not list that one.

And You're right, I didn't list JL, I thought I did. I'd say he isn't on a team with Cory, Cat or Jpap. And no Hook, he isn't on with me either.

And as for my worst fear...I'm trying to decide if I'm happy or terrified that I suspect you and Ice both less than I did yesterday. Terrified would probably be the prudent thing.
Click to expand...

Terrified is what I'm going with too. I do like the idea of ruling out who most likely is not teamed up, but we need to get one before any of that type of info can be used. It is definitely something to be looked at though. God help me, but I see it as a useful post. Retreating to paranoia now...
 
catfish69hunter said:
will some one tell me what is wrong with my vote i thought that was how you had to post it??
Click to expand...

Its correct now, JL was trying to make a point and we were showing him where he was wrong
 
IceH2O said:
I had decided at that time to vote Zig thinking that the evils piled onto JM to save him. Of the people on JM I wasn't sure who were the evils and who of the group was innocent. It couldn't be all evils on JM.
Click to expand...

Historically speaking, there probably wasn't more than two evils, maybe only one on JMax. I know when I played as the bad guy, we really tried to split the first round votes up as much as possible.

<snip>

The fact that Zig didn't vote JM to save himself puzzles me too unless it was because he already saw that JM had the lead and he didn't need to be the nail in the coffin.

Actually writing out that thought has made me lean Zig back towards being evil.
Click to expand...

Actually, I like that. The only (admittedly minor) hitch would that, as a newb (no offense), would he have that thought?

Grins said:
I wanted to comment on this one in it's own post. I've been thinking about who might be on a team together since before nightfall yesterday. I'm having more luck tying who might not be on a team together. Maybe listing those will help everyone else that is as confused as me at this point.

Based on conflict coming from at least one side; aggressiveness of the conflict; the conflicts being recent (I'm giving a pass to some of the early first day stuff when it has been dropped since) I'm thinking that the following people are not on the same team. I hope this is self explanatory, if not ask me.

Cat: Grins
Cory: Jpap, Hook
Hook: Cory, Jpap, Ogre
Ice: Ogre, Zig
Jpap: Cory, Hook
Ogre: Hook, Ice, Plant
Plant: Ogre
Zig: Ice

I'm starting to consider that
Jpap isn't on a team with Ice or John as well.

I tried to go back and review some older posts to see one I might have missed but my eyes started to go cross-eyed. I think there are some others I'd not pair with Zig but help me out here, what else doesn't make much sense as possible mafia teammates?
Click to expand...

I like this idea, but are you assuming that none of the arguments are started by and against a teammate? If so, then throw that out. Plenty of times teammates have fought, especially to not be associated.

That being said, I think the ones that would not be teams would be:

ice and zig
me and ice
jpap and catfish or zig


Possible teammates
zig and catfish
plant and ice?

IceH2O said:
Just posting a thought.

I actually have you pretty low on the suspect list along with Grins. Plant hasn't tiffed me in either direction so I didn't feel the need to include her at all. Jpap and JL are the ones that really stand out the most along with Zig. I feel that if Zig is evil then it cinches that Ogre is also.
Click to expand...

How so? I'm just curious, that last bit seems to have come out of nowhere.

Also, how does John stand out. I admit, I started with him, but it was mainly the morse thing. He hasn't really done anything to set off the twisted gene meter since then. Of course, neither has plantling, but she's so quiet and subtle, you can never tell with her.
 
Hooked Newbie said:
I buy the highlighted part, but Zig's posts today have seemed more "townie" and Ogre hasn't really tweaked me since early on day one with the morse unrest.
Click to expand...

I just can't shake the feeling that Ogre and Zig are evil.

I don't see in Zigs posts anything more then trying to save himself from a bad decision. I don't see why he didn't vote JM to save himself and sat on Z instead all by himself.

Ogres post on catfish was a bunch of nothing. He wrote all that and the only conclusion I can come to is that he thinks Cat is either innocent or evil.I can't fault him for forgetting someone was hit as I just did that in one of the last games.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom