Mafia #29 Biological Badlands #2
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
I had decided at that time to vote Zig thinking that the evils piled onto JM to save him. Of the people on JM I wasn't sure who were the evils and who of the group was innocent. It couldn't be all evils on JM.
Of the ones on JM I suspect you and Jpap the most followed by HN, then Grins. T
HN jumping off Zig onto JM to force the tie looks a bit suspect to me but if they are both innocents then it wasn't going to hurt him in either direction. There just seemed to be more evidence of Zig being evil then JM and I thought a 1st day vote and run wasn't a strong enough reason to vote JM. I didn't see HNs switch but since Ogre wasn't getting any votes and Zig was my 2nd suspect I was voting for him either way.
Grins doesn't seem as scummy after reading her posts today. I don't think she'd be the kill vote on an innocent when she could have just sat on me and let Zig vote for JM to save himself.
The fact that Zig didn't vote JM to save himself puzzles me too unless it was because he already saw that JM had the lead and he didn't need to be the nail in the coffin.
Actually writing out that thought has made me lean Zig back towards being evil.
You were because her post you quoted was in reference to Cats original vote that was worded I vote to test Grins
Like I said at the time, they were my top 2 suspects. Like I've said since, I hate that I helped vote off JM, but she looked evil to me. I tied the vote, others clinched it. I was pretty sure about Zig last night, but the posts since have been better. Either he's settling in and thinking before he clicks send or being coached. I doubt the later.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
rb posted and cat fixed it, more than 30 mins before grins post.
I wanted to comment on this one in it's own post. I've been thinking about who might be on a team together since before nightfall yesterday. I'm having more luck tying who might not be on a team together. Maybe listing those will help everyone else that is as confused as me at this point.
Based on conflict coming from at least one side; aggressiveness of the conflict; the conflicts being recent (I'm giving a pass to some of the early first day stuff when it has been dropped since) I'm thinking that the following people are not on the same team. I hope this is self explanatory, if not ask me.
Cat: Grins
Cory: Jpap, Hook
Hook: Cory, Jpap, Ogre
Ice: Ogre, Zig
Jpap: Cory, Hook
Ogre: Hook, Ice, Plant
Plant: Ogre
Zig: Ice
I'm starting to consider that
Jpap isn't on a team with Ice or John as well.
I tried to go back and review some older posts to see one I might have missed but my eyes started to go cross-eyed. I think there are some others I'd not pair with Zig but help me out here, what else doesn't make much sense as possible mafia teammates?
Just posting a thought.
I actually have you pretty low on the suspect list along with Grins. Plant hasn't tiffed me in either direction so I didn't feel the need to include her at all. Jpap and JL are the ones that really stand out the most along with Zig. I feel that if Zig is evil then it cinches that Ogre is also.
Look again Sherlock :silly:
Using EST times
1:16 Cat mis-worded vote to test me
5:44 I mentioned it to him
7:27 Cat fixed the vote to test me
Very interesting approach. I like reverse engineering things and haven't thought to do it in the game. I am curious, JL doesn't appear anywhere and has been pretty active (for him). According to that breakdown the only one you couldn't be teammates with is Cat? Should I be worried a Grins, Ice, JL, Plant team? Strike that, that's my worst fear.
