Mafia #33 - Bruce Campbell Vs. Army of Darkness

[OgreMkV]

If DD slipped, then it could only be her. There are too many other ladies around and if DD was innocent, then she wouldn't know which is the evil one.

I'm now leaning that rb is innocent... well, at least as far as the game is concerned. He defended DD when it would be easy to jump on her slip.

John, what do you think about DD's 'slip'?

 

[OgreMkV]

1) Catfish
2) DD (moved up)
3) ???

 

[Chill]

Well, since DD is a lady, it may be more natural for her to choose the feminine choice.

Yes I thought of that too, but still thought it was a fair question to raise.

You could just as easily put Chill on the list for middle of the road posting and content, Lady G.

"Middle of the road" I'm new, I'm just getting my feet wet sorry if I'm not up to snuff. Or are you lining me up for the second night's vote as I cast suspicion at you?

What's the record for quickest Newb lynching anyway?

 

[Lady G]

I have no problem posting who my top three would be.

1.Pix
2.Plant
3.DD

Now I know this contradicts what I just said a bit, but after thinking while I was posting my last post, I just don't really see RB, DD well I'm not sure either at this point as the day goes on she may slide off the list for me...but if you want three at this time that would have to be my list. Nothing to do with posts really more of a I could see it thing.

 

[Lady G]

Now, I'm off here for a while have loads to do today.

 

[Chill]

I'm now leaning that rb is innocent... well, at least as far as the game is concerned. He defended DD when it would be easy to jump on her slip.

I waivered when I saw this as well. However I earlier said that it probably wasn't Cat as he defended RB and there was no potential gain for the Sole Evil in defending innocents. Once that idea was voiced once it would then make sense to defend an innocent to make it look like you weren't evil yourself. Man my thinker is getting sore.

 

[johnlarson66]

Well, since DD is a lady, it may be more natural for her to choose the feminine choice.

I have been on the same evil team as DD, she was no lady. :lipssealedsmilie:

If DD slipped, then it could only be her. There are too many other ladies around and if DD was innocent, then she wouldn't know which is the evil one.

I'm now leaning that rb is innocent... well, at least as far as the game is concerned. He defended DD when it would be easy to jump on her slip.

John, what do you think about DD's 'slip'?

I can see how DD would be a good choice to be the lone mafia. I don't think she made a slip and like rb's reason that I quoted above. I have been saying lone mafia, just because I have not liked the ash/ashly or ash/ly wording.

I have rb as more innocent. He, like yourself, is not that good at being bad.

 

[Rbishop]

Yes I thought of that too, but still thought it was a fair question to raise.




"Middle of the road" I'm new, I'm just getting my feet wet sorry if I'm not up to snuff. Or are you lining me up for the second night's vote as I cast suspicion at you?

What's the record for quickest Newb lynching anyway?

Nope, I am used to be on the chopping block and it doesn't bother me if folks suspect me.

I have modded a few of these games, and regardless of statements about random assignments, there is always some handpicking of assignments.

I can easily see Z giving us a twist in the assignmebt of the initial lone evil. I have done it myself. Your fine, no need to think you are not up to snuff. I just feel, for now, that it is more likely a new player or middle of the road poster is the lone evil.

 

[Rbishop]

If I had to pick 3 right now...early as it is....


Pixl8r
Chill
jl or DD

 

[Chill]

I don't know yet. I don't have the benefit of past games. I'd be curious has anyone's posting style changed from their ussual style of play?
My guts says RB but my brain is second-guessing. Best I can do on top three right now is 2nd and 3rd, going to RB and DD respectively. Purely gut instincts. Hopefuly I see something a little more solid before we have to vote.

1. Unknown
2. RB
3, DD

On the other end of the scale the least likely suspect would be Cat. I know I'm innocent and wouldn't expect the role to be trusted to the other Newb either. I think Jensons is probably innocent as well.