Mafia #33 - Bruce Campbell Vs. Army of Darkness

[catfish69hunter]

He will have many alibis this weekend as to why he couldn't be on the boards. Not sure how much weight to place on this just yet.



I highly doubt this is the case but it is tough to tell since Aqua has no posts from which to derive any information from.

Dawg as for alibis yes anyone can have one but a post here and there would prob still happen. See IMO I belive that he dropped back to protect himself from getting lynched.

As for the newb that is why I am worried they have no posts. See Ill use Chill as an example he is a newb to the game but if you look at his posts you'll see he has asked a lot of questions and posted a lot of good points for a newb. You have also posted quite a few posts and some good ones at that. The lack of posting from Aqua worries me as to if they are good or bad. Im not SURE that aqua is evil but i think that the lack of attempting to post and trying to look the game over(reading the rules) is very anti town and if you cant help the town what good are you?

 

[dirtydawg10]

Im not SURE that aqua is evil but i think that the lack of attempting to post and trying to look the game over(reading the rules) is very anti town and if you cant help the town what good are you?

I hear ya on that one. If you have an almost 94% chance of selecting an innocent...why not vote for a suspected player who if they turn out to be innocent would not have helped you much in the game anyway. Not fully on board with you yet but I understand your logic.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Sometimes if we are a bit harsh, people respond....that is usually when they slip up, in my experience.
Right Charlie...?

Why'd ya have to go THERE? lol

It is a crap shoot...but as RB stated it does bring out the discussions which is the only way to gain information. Talking about suspicions doesn't bring out as much as accusing someone outright (right RB ). Don't forget...you can change your vote at any time.

I hear ya on that one. If you have an almost 94% chance of selecting an innocent...why not vote for a suspected player who if they turn out to be innocent would not have helped you much in the game anyway. Not fully on board with you yet but I understand your logic.

Ok strange thought (maybe) here... we're looking at vets, low posting newbies, etc. What about a middle of the road posting newb?

Dawg- You seem to have a pretty good grip on the game and would be as reasonable a choice for Ash/ley as any. Why shouldn't I vote for you?

 

[Lady G]

Dawg as for alibis yes anyone can have one but a post here and there would prob still happen. See IMO I belive that he dropped back to protect himself from getting lynched.

As for the newb that is why I am worried they have no posts. See Ill use Chill as an example he is a newb to the game but if you look at his posts you'll see he has asked a lot of questions and posted a lot of good points for a newb. You have also posted quite a few posts and some good ones at that. The lack of posting from Aqua worries me as to if they are good or bad. Im not SURE that aqua is evil but i think that the lack of attempting to post and trying to look the game over(reading the rules) is very anti town and if you cant help the town what good are you?

I'm wondering if this was just to much for Aqua and they are giving up on the game?

 

[catfish69hunter]

G you may be right but I mean really the question of how do I vote is in the rules. If the game is too much thats one thing but hey anyone can read the rules. Or am I just overthinking this one?

 

[Lady G]

No, I don't think you are over thinking it...and who knows they very well may be the Evil Ash, but just a reason I can see Z NOT going with a brand new person for a lone evil....you really have no idea how they are going to play, or how they are going to respond...just to risky IMO for a LONE evil. Yes, if there were teams oh yeah, I can see newbs...but not in this case.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

G you may be right but I mean really the question of how do I vote is in the rules. If the game is too much thats one thing but hey anyone can read the rules. Or am I just overthinking this one?

If I were you, I would have reread your first game before posting. I did.

 

[catfish69hunter]

You know I never thought of that if a newb is lone evil and they quit. GAME OVER. Wow that would suck. Then maybe Z wouldnt do that .

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Ya think? lol

 

[Hooked Newbie]

In reality though, the role would probably just be "mysteriously" transferred like it will be if we get Ash/ley on the first night.