Just something I was thinking about. Ok, we are going to loose an innocent too, the last evil can "hit" someone at night fall. I'm just thinking out loud here, so try to follow me. What if the person with the book has been turned, they say they changed DD, but really change someone else who will now be their team mate. We lynch DD and see innocent (if she is not already evil before) we know we have been tricked...BUT we do NOT know by who, and they now have 2 players. Granted the book can only be used once, if it is not used this night..we can assume the holder IS evil. If it is used and the game does not end, and we lynch DD it will say Innocent we will also know the holder is evil. Because if she was evil before the book was used the game would end if she was the only evil. Anyway what I am trying to say in a round about way is, IF DD is innocent and the evil one has the book, we will loose two innocents. They will gain an innocent also (if the evil one has the book) and uses it on someone else, so in the end we loose THREE innocents. We would then be at 5/2.
I think the best way to deal with this is to Lynch the one the book is used on, if the game doesn't end...so we will know FOR SURE the one with the book used it on who they were suppose to, if they did DD will show as evil when lynched.
Does this sound like a good idea to you guys??? This way we KNOW the book was used by an innocent.