Mafia 34-Time Crisis(the Play)

[IceH2O]

I think the town should discuss if we are okay with voting "No One" and if knowingly putting the town in a position that it votes a tie is anti-town or not.

Ice and ZS were unsure if HN or LG were guilty. Not real good company to be with.

As soon as I read this my 1st thought was if I was a terrorist and in cahoots with Z why would I hit him? I think JL thought since people are looking at me that he'd help throw some wood on the fire.

Ok, you guys can fry me for this later, but after reading back through I have a new list for my latest suspects.



Early to vote on BH on day 1.



I was wrong, it wasn't DD that was quick to cast doubt on Chill.



Here my day 1 pact wasn't a bad idea to him.



He feared a night time frenzy. Wow, did Rb tell you what he was going to do?



Wants to stay out of the HN vs LG thing. Now, we're his only suspects.



This is in response to Ogre saying that those with singleton votes should be looked at more closely. It does include me as well, but JL disagreed with wanting to look at those. Psst... go back and look at Ogre's post.



How were you sure of this? NM, I think I know how.




OK, he found where he wanted to vote.



Oops, he just changed his mind agreeing with LG.



Really like this idea huh?



Why do you like the idea of voting no one?


It's not much of a "case", but as often is the case the good players don't leave trails to be followed. With only 40 posts so far, it's no wonder why.

I'm also looking at the other low posters and leaning towards Rickets or Fire right now.

Lady G 171
Hooked Newbie 145
IceH2O 129
NeonJulie 109
jpappy789 103
ZSandmann 85
dirtydawg10 84
judgemax 72
rbishop 71
bkw1982 58
Madcrawdad 56
nickel652 44
johnlarson66 40
Chill 38
cap1384 33
Dangerdoll 23
FireDancer7905 22
[AC] BadHaggis 19
OgreMkV 18
[AC] RICKETS 16
cam191919 6

You Stole my thunder lol, after I read that post I was about to go back and look. I was thinking at work how JL would be a great turn for RB as he blends in well.

I retract my vote on Dawg and vote to lynch JL

I agree Rickets could be another especially if Mad is correct and its Coler. An innocent Coler would be all over the thread with good research.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

eh im pregnant and prolly just crappy and moody and sensitive...and all the other crap that comes along with it

In that case.... SORRY!

Cap- get your woman some pickle flavored ice cream!

 

[Madcrawdad]

Best answer I can give is thoughts change. If you read my post carefully though you will see that I said that we shouldn't get carried away and lynch people for dumb reasons (which is why I am hesitant to vote for dawg but interested at the same time). I didn't say that we should plan to tie all lynches. I was more worried about people going off on large missions to dig up any possible hint of scum they could find and end up lynching the bomb carrier early. After seeing how the terrorist/sniper hits have been so lucky at picking out PR's I don't think it is wise to just lay back.

The thing is JPap, it looks like you're waivering a bit on lynching or not lynching... After diving off of HN late yesterday, you said this when things got tied up between HN and LG:

so maybe all of this is going to happen for nothing...its tied but everyone has already voted.

Keep in mind that you helped tie things up late between LG and HN, and the post above makes it look like you were content to ride your vote into the night, whereby a tie would prevent any lynches.

Your seeming inconsistency on whether lynching or not lynching is best for the town really makes me concerned about you.

I vote to lynch JPap

 

[Lady G]

Alrighty then. If I gotta be lynched at least I'll have left some info instead of chaos. You sound really confident that you're totally safe. Maybe that's because no one has looked at you since you post so little. You sure did respond to my vote quickly though.



Rickets & FD for the other terrorist. OMGUT = Oh My God U Terrorist. I thought it was fairly obvious.

LMAO!! I though your OMGUT stood for Oh MY GUT:drool:

eh im pregnant and prolly just crappy and moody and sensitive...and all the other crap that comes along with it

Oh, man...I couldn't imagine me playing when I was Prego.....ya'll think my thoughts are crazy now erv:

I think you made a good case for John actually..Rickets well, half the time I forget he is even playing until I see a post from them.

I may end up voting John myself, but I'm still liking NJ...but for some reason others seem blind to her...although John did "protect" her a bit, in a post to me saying how he looks more terrorist then she does. DD and Pap are still good to me also though, and thinking about Rickets yep, so are they. I really wish we actually knew how many we are looking for, so many look guilty to me!!

 

[nickel652]

In that case.... SORRY!

Cap- get your woman some pickle flavored ice cream!

hahaha yeah i should have put a warning up to all players...caution preggo here! hahaha and pickel flavored ice cream....doesnt sound too bad...too bad hs at work ill have him pick someup on the way home...hahaha jk...

 

[Lady G]

OK, I vote to lynch John.....I think a good case has been shown for him. If I switched it would most likely be to NJ, Pap, DD or Rickets as they are the others that are really not setting well with me.

 

[NeonJulie]

LMAO!!

I may end up voting John myself, but I'm still liking NJ...but for some reason others seem blind to her...although John did "protect" her a bit, in a post to me saying how he looks more terrorist then she does. DD and Pap are still good to me also though, and thinking about Rickets yep, so are they. I really wish we actually knew how many we are looking for, so many look guilty to me!!

Maybe they know something you don't. Maybe they saw what you missed? Maybe John having a different opinion than you is simply that?


Also in general speaking, I find it hard to believe that a true mafia would post so little. It's probably something like the idea that... 'there are so many of us, so few left of them, my vote isn't going to matter much, I think I'll stay out of the drama and let the bored people do my work for me.' Apathy is the word that comes to mind, someone who's busy - but they're isn't a pressing need for them to maintain a presence.

I would think a mafiaperson might just stay in mid-range of activity level, not too much, not too few. (RB / BH.) Ricket's 4 posts a day (and thanks to HN for pulling all of them) which include 2 word responses... that's not someone with any role in this game to protect.

So who's pulling midrange and submarining topics...

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Maybe they know something you don't. Maybe they saw what you missed? Maybe John having a different opinion than you is simply that?


Also in general speaking, I find it hard to believe that a true mafia would post so little. It's probably something like the idea that... 'there are so many of us, so few left of them, my vote isn't going to matter much, I think I'll stay out of the drama and let the bored people do my work for me.' Apathy is the word that comes to mind, someone who's busy - but they're isn't a pressing need for them to maintain a presence.

I would think a mafiaperson might just stay in mid-range of activity level, not too much, not too few. (RB / BH.) Ricket's 4 posts a day (and thanks to HN for pulling all of them) which include 2 word responses... that's not someone with any role in this game to protect.

So who's pulling midrange and submarining topics...

This borderline protection and definitely making me curious. As for the bolded part, I posted everyone's post count. Feel free to look at it.

 

[NeonJulie]

Thanks. I wasn't asking for postcounts... I saw that... it's monologuing... you know. Thinking out loud.

 

[IceH2O]

Lady G,

Like I said in my post that you quoted, I could see more of a case for me being a terrorist than NJ (or pappy). I have them both leaning very innocent and do not think that rb's exit was planned nor was it in the best interest of the terrorist. I think he was upset about a rule and quit. I think the remaining terrorists are not as upset as rb is and decided to continue on with a new boss.

Just a quick question, if the Doc was turned. Would they still have the doctor powers?

My chioces for terrorists are:

Hooked Newbie
Lady G

I think HN was an original terrorist and Lady G was the turn (and could be the doc). I think their attitude towards each other is quite telling.

My vote stays on HN, but am willing to switch to LG.

Rickets has named a number of players

The posts are in HNs post but I'm going to pull the names. Rickets named the following players and the number of times he did it.

Chill 2
Jpap 4
HN 5
NeonJulie 5
Lady 2

I would say this clears HN Jpap and NJ as if Rickets and JL are evil they wouldn't keep them out front as often as they did.

Rickets go on to say:
Is a lot of votes sitting on onesies no ? Lynching Chill would sure help me think my way into the game a bit more. On balance I can't see a good case for his innocence. Then again I like HN & Jpappy for votes too.

This statement forced me back to look at night 1 to see who all were onsies votes. They are:RB(evil) JL DD NJ Fire. Only ones at that time pulling suspicion were DD and NJ, seems like a safe statement to make as in if we lynched DD and/or NJ and saw them innocent we'd most likely stop lynching them.

In case there are more then 2 left my suspect list is

JL
Rickets
Fire
Cap
Dawg
JM