Mafia 38 "the revenge"

[ZSandmann]

[/color]

Well people would like me to post more with better information well here is the best I can offer right now.

First off no one is clear of anything just for voting RB. There are 2 different mafia teams that don't know each other. All are still evil until proven innocent in my book.

second hooked this really got my attention looking your way now. I mean really I know how long last nights nightfall was and how ooo SO many posts there were. For you to miss the fact that Dawg was the hit and died but yet he is still on your radar for possable mafia this is not like you.

So until farther notice and someone better to vote for.

I vote to lynch Hooked Newbie.

Wow, you jumped on that waaaaay to fast.

I vote to lynch narwhal.

 

[ZSandmann]

I could see DD or Chill reading the handwriting on the wall and adding their vote to RB. So, yes, I think RBs henchman may have voted for him and if so, then it's either chill or DD.

I could really see RB picking DD as a henchman... henchwoman... thug. Anyway, she's quiet and subtle. Chill is too.


Hooked's thing on Dawg... I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt on that. He just pulled an Ogre and no big deal. My thing is, why jump on him for it narwal? It's not something that a mafia would do.

So my top three list for now is narwal, DD, chill. Not neccesarily in that order.

I'll have to vote soon as I'm making a run to Houston and may not be back for nighfall.

Chill I could see, I think DD jumped too soon though, she may well be on the other team but I don't think she is on RBs which is all I was trying to think out earlier.

 

[jpappy789]

Did I know that rb was mafia? No. His gameplay could have changed for a number of reasons. Of all the people who voted for rb at the time I found yours most suspect because it was so quick and without much thought (IMO). How am I trying to train people to you DD? Show me one post where I specifically told someone or encouraged people to vote for you? I have directed questions at you and put you on my list, that is all. I haven't been pushing your vote at all and I doubt that I am going to vote for you today.

You said his style has changed but you said it has happened in the past games as well. I found that as contradicting yourself. I guess you see it differently. I am not going to bring it up again because I don;t see this going anywhere.

 

[jpappy789]

They didn't get added, they just weren't excluded. Ogre should be on the list. I missed him somehow.

Ok. But its a relatively long list of names with nothing to back it up so I find it really no help at all.

 

[jpappy789]

I vote to lynch Chill

Call it an OMGUS vote but I explained why I think he is guilty in post 208. I am going to be gone until later this afternoon anyways and I figured I might as well get a vote in on a suspect.

 

[ZSandmann]

Ok, I just want folks to remember how many times I have been Mafia as of yet. The last time I was Innocent was the game I missed the beginning (much like this one, lol) and was voted out by the town on Day 1. I don't want that to happen again. On Day 1 I got in late and decided i would lay back to try and slip past being hit or lynched right out of the gate. Success so far. But now I am here to win it and you can bet if you are Mafia I am going to sniff you out so get me if you can.

If the Detective is going to consider investigating me, please wait till after today as I want at least one other person to be totally sure of me. If I were the other Don my cover would be gone after tonight.

So all formality out of the way, I believe Narwhal is the New School Henchman.

I am thinking about the Old School now.

 

[ZSandmann]

Ok. But its a relatively long list of names with nothing to back it up so I find it really no help at all.

You are looking at it backwards pappy and that is probably my fault for the way I worded it. My point was to exclude the ones I did not think could be on RBs team and therefore narrow the suspects.

The list that matters is NJ, BKW, Me, and maybe Chill. The reasoning being that in a two team game we all have a 33% chance of being Innocent. If we can remove the possibility of being on one Mafia team that person is now 66% Innocent and moves from "Likely Mafia" to "Likely Innocent".

Example: I now believe that NeonJulie is "Likely an Innocent"

Did I explain that better to you?

 

[OgreMkV]

Ogre... has a nice twist and seeming confidence to try to get people to thinking his way.... nice try but not falling for it.

These are those who I suspect atm

huh?

I'm heading to Houston. I vote to lynch chill last voter on RB. I think it's a cover.

 

[pixl8r]

Narwhal: JP(35) Dawg(64) Ogre(136)
Z: HN(38) Z(66)
NJ: Ogre(39) Z(114) RB(116)
Dawg: Narwhal(65)
BKW: Chill(70) Ogre(98) Dawg(127) HN(148)
RB: BKW(99) NJ(110) DD (113) Chill(168)
DD: JP(119)

No vote from Pixl8r.

Now I'd like to be able to clear folks just based on votes, but with two Mafia teams that is impossible. However, I think it would be safe to say that BKW (First vote RB), NJ (2nd vote RB/RB's Votee), and myself (Followed on my heals to vote NJ) are not on the New School team. I might even add Chill to this list as his move from BKW was what broke the tie and sealed it for RB. I will conceed the case for my Innocence is the weakest of these explanations, but yoiu will have to choose to believe or disbelieve me.

Possible New School Mafia: (No particular order)
Hooked
JPappy
DD
Pixl
Narwhal

Of course there is no solid evidence to make likewise lists of Innocent/Old School. Can anyone add insight which might futher refine this list. Also, feel free to rebuff any I have excluded.

OK, Skimmy McSkimmer, did you bother to read this?
http://www.aquariacentral.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1532091&postcount=188

HA!

 

[[AC] narwhal]

LOL... yep, I made a mistake sorry. I was going by memory and flaked. My bad. If that's deserving of lynching in your eyes, go for it. I would have voted for you if you'd done that too so I can understand.

Ok here Hooked agreed that it was a mistake worth jumping on that he himself would have done in turn to someone else.

Wow, you jumped on that waaaaay to fast.

I vote to lynch narwhal.

So Z I jump on something that Hooked says himself that he would jump on. It was about 15-20 min after he posted and I jumped on it too fast?

I think your jumping on something to throw suspicion on me for it. In my mind that makes you up there with Hooked right now and yea maybe more than him. I feel the more I think about it that yes it was a mistake and yes anyone can make it. But it did provide the crowd with something to get moving on and its a suprize who jumped where.