Mafia 39... the kids take over.

ok, I am back, still a little busy but caught up on posts and wanted to respond. I will be back and forth through the rest of the night so.. I shouldn't be too long in between posts.

IceH2O said:
Man there is something I want to pull and show but I don't know the mafia have or will see it and I don't want to bring it to their attention.

At the same time I do want innocents to see it and come to their own conclusion.
Click to expand...
this is an oddity.... a first, never can I recall you holding information for the fear of the mafia seeing it.

Hooked Newbie said:
As expected... have a good crabbing trip.
Click to expand...
thanks, was not a good crabbing day though, I am guessing because they aren't hungry because of the amount of people out... there are also a pod of dolphins out on the navesink river that they are saying may have to do with it... We're gonna try again the 3rd week of September.... should be better then. No one usually goes out after labor day so they should be good and hungry by then :)

Hooked Newbie said:
Typo right? There are 2 NS, 1 OS. Unless I misunderstood Ogre.
Click to expand...
wow, another typo for Ice...

rbishop said:
DD, this is your explanation, after nightfall, on why you changed your vote to nano. Why did you state Nano can't be the doctor....what did you see, before nightfall that led you to that conclusion?
Click to expand...
what I saw was what I have already stated. NNano said he couldnt reveal his role because it was against the rules. That, is a clear newbie mistake. One that should go in the Mafia book of shame.
IceH2O said:
Well I guess I don't have to pull the quote and bring it to the front as RB has done it.
I didn't want to bring attention to it yet hoping that somehow if DD isn't the real Dr that the real would would give a clue. Now I have to decide if DD is lying or telling the truth.

There are only 2 ways DD could know Nano wasn't the DR. Either she is the DR or she is part of NS and they found the Dr through investigations. The NS had to get rid of 1 OS to win the game so thinking she would keep a tie and save a mafia player is out the window.


I'm going to post the vote tallies from the 1st 2 nights so maybe someone will see something I'm missing or just don't have the time to look at right now as I'm heading out to a friends in a bit.We know Jpap and IQ and Z were innocent.And we now know Nano is mafia. Known innocents will be green and known mafia will be yellow of course red is retractions.

Day 1

Gunslinger-0- HN(7)HI(179)

Fire-2-Chill(21)DD(193)

HN-0- Gun(22)Pix(114)

Ice-0- RB(48)

DD-3- Z(94)Fire(112)Ice(137)

Nano-1-Hi(97)Ice(113)HI(183)

Z-1- Jpap(99)

Hi-5- Gun(103)HN(118)DD(128)Pix(151)RB(155)Nano(190)

no votes:



Day 2

Fire-0-DD(205)

Gun-1- Pix(206)Nano(207)

Nano-5-Z(213)RB(228)Chill(242)Gun(245)DD(270)

DD-4- Ice(226)HN(249)Fire(252)Nano(263)

no votes:

One question I have for DD besides the DR comment is why her vote goes to Fire when I'm the one jumping down her throat. Seems like a better case for votes could be made for me then Fire.

Pix why did you want to go with the majority the 1st night instead of making your own decision? You didn't feel the need to do it on night 2 I see as you are a lone vote on Gun which was put in early in the day with no real reason.

Chill are you back yet? Are you going to contribute or do we throw some votes your way to get you to post?

Fires reasoning for voting DD is pretty weak IMO, its based on HN comment and a copy of the players. If DD is innocent then Fire is mafia IMO.

Gun could be NS. I'm pretty sure I know who Gun is,if its the same player that used the alias when I modded, I won't say who out of respect but I could see them sending in for players that have modded and know who they are which narrows it down to RB and me. I know its not me.

RB could be NS see Gun

HN could be OS but he refused to vote Nano both nights.He didn't want to vote him night 1 when we thought he'd be a UD, maybe didn't want to lose a team mate?

AS you see I have no trust in anyone right now. Nothing has cleared anyone IMO.
Click to expand...
The reason I didn't change my vote to you Ice, is because you are playing well investigatively but yes, you have been hard on my case. I have pondered voting you but am nbot ready to yet. Yes, I do see mistakes from you that I am not used to seeing you make because in my opinion, you play a tight game... but I just am not ready to call you mafia. I was moreso ready to vote fire because of her coming out of no where, riding on someone else's opinion and then voting me. Then I changed only because I was a lot more secure with voting nano.
 
pixl8r said:
Sorry, I didn't fully answer this question. I stuck with Gunslinger for two reasons.

1. HI IG led me to believe that gun was a probable bad guy.
2. I passed out, and spent time reclined, playing Go Fish with the kids.
Click to expand...
G didn't even get a chance to investigate anyone, how come you had such confidence in her? Using her faulted opinion of Gun for your advantage maybe?
 
Not good enough, DD, pure tap dance on your part and a wild guess..a newbie would think being an innocent is a role.....
 
I vote to lynch Dangerdoll...
 
IceH2O said:
I guess I need to read the rules too... I don't see that it says they do. I was basing it on the majority of games.

Ok well either DD is mafia and claiming the role to bring the real DR out or she is the Dr and came out to early.
Click to expand...
Either way I am out. I didn't state exactly why when I changed my vote last night to nano because I wanted to be here at least one more night. By stating my reason then, I definitely would have been hit. I explained myself before anyone even bothered to ask after night because I didn't want everyone coming down on me saying I jumped at the last second saying I was mafia and I was using it as a ploy to appear as an innocent because that is exactly what the mafia do in order to shield themselves. I changed my vote as soon as I saw Nano's comment and believing there was not time left, rushed it out there. It was at that point where I saw there were enough votes for nano to take him out so there was no need to put an explanation out there yet anyway.

rbishop said:
Not good enough, DD, pure tap dance on your part and a wild guess..a newbie would think being an innocent is a role.....
Click to expand...

Know something, I wasn't trying to be "good enough", rb... I was simply making my explanation. If I am not voted out tonight, I fully expect to be lynched anyway.
and a newbie would think saying they were innocent was against the rules? come on... not one person in all the mafia series ever thought it was against the rules to come out and say they were innocent.

since when did I become "Dangerdoll" to you, rb?
 
Dangerdoll said:
ok, I am back, still a little busy but caught up on posts and wanted to respond. I will be back and forth through the rest of the night so.. I shouldn't be too long in between posts.


this is an oddity.... a first, never can I recall you holding information for the fear of the mafia seeing it.


thanks, was not a good crabbing day though, I am guessing because they aren't hungry because of the amount of people out... there are also a pod of dolphins out on the navesink river that they are saying may have to do with it... We're gonna try again the 3rd week of September.... should be better then. No one usually goes out after labor day so they should be good and hungry by then :)


wow, another typo for Ice...


what I saw was what I have already stated. NNano said he couldnt reveal his role because it was against the rules. That, is a clear newbie mistake. One that should go in the Mafia book of shame.

The reason I didn't change my vote to you Ice, is because you are playing well investigatively but yes, you have been hard on my case. I have pondered voting you but am nbot ready to yet. Yes, I do see mistakes from you that I am not used to seeing you make because in my opinion, you play a tight game... but I just am not ready to call you mafia. I was moreso ready to vote fire because of her coming out of no where, riding on someone else's opinion and then voting me. Then I changed only because I was a lot more secure with voting nano.
Click to expand...


That isn't an explanation, it is a tap dance and trying to avoid the question...

Here, let me keep it simple for you blondies.....WHY DID YOU STATE THAT NANO COULDN"T BE THE DOCTOR????
 
You became Dangerdoll, when you tried to avoid answering the question...
 
Not hiding out, ill. I've a nasty stomach bug of sorts that has converted me to a worshiper of the porcelain goddess. It's really ruining my last few weeks of summer. And I know, 4 posts is low, even for me. All I can say is sorry, and offer up a list. (I do know how you all like to giggle).

10 is mafia, 1 is innocent

Gunslinger - 6 - There's something in your tone. IDK, though, because you voted for Nano, where I didn't....

Chill - 3 - Even if busy, I think that he would post more if mafia

DD - 1 or 10 - If you are the Doc, I am curious as to why Ice looks suspicious to you, because I don't see it. Also, I have to apologize for voting or you. I don't see her being on Nano's team and the Doc, because if she was she would have protected him, right? She could still be NS, or an evil Dr. NS, but I am not so sure anymore.

Hooked - 7 - Your quick turn on DD after the Doc post is worrisome. I find it hard to believe that you didn't see that slip, or even find it worth considering.

Ice - 2 - I think you are innocent. Just a feeling, but you're not screaming mafia to me.

pix - 5 - Again, just not feeling mafia here, but the last few posts are kinda odd to me...

RB - 8 - Stretching with the "innocent might be a role" and jumping all over DD even though there may be very good reason not to. Not a lot of questions going to her, just taunting and accusations. Also, possible distancing with the bickering with HN. And gut feeling.

I vote to lynch rb.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom