Seahorses are possible in a reef

LCP136

AC Members
Aug 7, 2008
51
0
0
If you , like me, have always dreamed of having these amazing creatures in your reef, unlike most people would say, I say it is possible. If you're dedicated and willing to make some sacrifices you can keep seahorses in a reef.

To accomplish this feat, you have to start by understanding seahorses, their basic needs, and their interactions with other fish and corals. Seahorses are a very interesting fish. Most live in areas with heavy eel grass or sometimes seaweed. This is because like monkeys and a couple other animals, they have prehensile tails that they wrap around the grass or seaweed and rest. They do this resting because they are not designed to do a lot of swimming. One reason is that their bodies are not particularly designed to swim well. The other is that from their mouth to their hindquarters is a very short distance and they have no real stomach. Because of this they don't absorb many nutrients from their food and they can't store much energy and anchoring themselves with their tail is a way to conserve energy.

There are a couple reasons they live in this vegetation, not among coral. The first reason is that coral usually lives in areas with a pretty strong current and the horses need a calmer area to rest as they will use up all their energy quickly if they are constantly fighting strong water movement. The other reason is that seahorses have no scales. If they wrap their tails around coral constantly, they will constantly be being stung. While most fish have scales to protect them, the horses just have skin. A good analogy to this is a bee stinging you on you palm versus a bee stinging you on your fingernail.

As I said in the previous two paragraphs, seahorses need vegetation and an area of low water movement. This brings me to the first sacrifice you need to make and the first challenge. Reef tanks are colorful and beautiful, but macro algae and fake plants aren't quite as pretty. The challenge is that coral needs high water movement and horses need low. The best way I can think of to solve this is to have power heads higher up in the tank near the top level of the live rock. You then arrange your LR in two lumps with a decent gap in the middle. This arrangement will make it so that the rock lumps have good movement at the top for coral, but the rock blocks the movement of water in the valley. In this valley you put macro algae, dead coral skeletons , and fake eel grass for them to grab onto. This allows both coral and horses to be happy.

The second sacrifice you need to make is with your fish. Many marine fish are very territorial and aggressive. Seahorses are very passive and easily bullied in a tank. Getting around this depends on your tank size. If your tank is below 75 gallons, my recommendation is to avoid all clownfish and tangs. If it is 75 or up you should max out at 2 clownfish and one tang such as a yellow, but nothing like a hippo. This to many people is a great sacrifice, but if your like me, it's worth it. The other sacrifice is that you have to stock your tank with half, at most, of the fish you would otherwise be able to put in it.

The last challenge to doing this is their feeding. Seahorses are very picky eaters. You should NEVER buy a wild caught seahorse. In the wild, they are in trouble and they are infinitely harder to care for. Buy tank cultured seahorses that are trained to eat frozen food, and before you purchase, ask to see them eat. If they won't show you, walk out. Anyway, seahorses need breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Make sure there is enough food in there to give the other fish their fill and still allow the horses to eat. A good strategy is to feed until the fish are full, then target your horses by dropping frozen myesis or brine shrimp right over them. Try to vary their diet. Myesis is the most nutrient rich, but when i was talking to my friend, who is a seahorse specialist at the new england aquarium, he said that on an all myesis diet, fish and horses died early due to very fatty livers. If you can't get your horses to eat, don't give up, but maybe exchange them for new ones that you could have better luck with.

This is all I could think to share about my favorite animals. Many of you i'm sure will disagree and many I'm sure already know this, but if someone can learn from this I'm glad.

LCP
 
lcp great write up just my 2 cents...

I'd never add anything with a seahorse..honestly they get scared WAY too easily for me and I'd rather have a nice school of them in like a 45 or even a 55
 
No doubt its tough and a bit risky. My point is its possible. I know that they get scared easily which is why I recommend keeping them with things like firefish, gobies, blennies, chromisis and other peaceful fish. Even though I am a beginner with SW, I have done a ton of research on seahorses and talked to people who are professionals. I forgot to say, I wouldn't recommend this for a beginner in saltwater fish.
 
I'm not a marine guy by any means, but do spend alot of time at the aquarium talking to the biologists. This (from my simple point of view) apears to be bad advice. What reef do Seahorses naturally inhabit? Everyone I've spoken to or read has stated that the only truly suitable tankmates are pipefish. I'll be sure to inquire at MACNA though, since you've made me curious.
 
I can't deny that this is a controversial write up. From my experience most, if not all, other write ups are opposite of mine. However, it is my experience that it is possible, and it is also the experience of some biologists that I know that it is possible. I believe that some do inhabit reef areas in vegetation, but i'll double check that.
 
I can't deny that this is a controversial write up. From my experience most, if not all, other write ups are opposite of mine. However, it is my experience that it is possible, and it is also the experience of some biologists that I know that it is possible. I believe that some do inhabit reef areas in vegetation, but i'll double check that.

I'd love further details if you can find some. While I haven't had the guts to keep SW myself, I do spend many hours living vicariously at the Aq and have spent literal hours chatting with the keepers of the 90K reef and the Sea Dragon habitat. As far as I know sea horses and reefs are totally incompatible on very basic levels. Temperature, Light, Water movement. Have YOU kept them in a reef environment?
 
Not in my home tank. However, I have spent much time speaking with the keepers of the seahorse and reef tanks in the Aq. I have seen and learned from reef tanks that have accommodated seahorses. My home tank now I have set up to accommodate them. I provided a solution for water movement in the original post. As far as light, its not much different, as most seahorses live in shallow water like corals. Temperature is the most difficult. Corals live in water that is a couple degrees warmer. In my experience, tank cultured h. erectus are very hardy. I have seen both them and corals thrive in water of 78 degrees. Have you talked to keepers of the seahorse exhibits? while similar, sea dragons and seahorses are different animals.
 
Not in my home tank. However, I have spent much time speaking with the keepers of the seahorse and reef tanks in the Aq. I have seen and learned from reef tanks that have accommodated seahorses. My home tank now I have set up to accommodate them. I provided a solution for water movement in the original post. As far as light, its not much different, as most seahorses live in shallow water like corals. Temperature is the most difficult. Corals live in water that is a couple degrees warmer. In my experience, tank cultured h. erectus are very hardy. I have seen both them and corals thrive in water of 78 degrees. Have you talked to keepers of the seahorse exhibits? while similar, sea dragons and seahorses are different animals.

There are no such exhibits here. They are different animals, but they belong to the same family (Syngnathidae). What Aq. are you speaking to people at? I'd love for some of the truly experienced SW folks to chime in here, as I said my info is all second hand. I do believe it to be accurate though.
 
I am talking of the New England Aquarium. Although some of my info is second hand, much of it is firsthand from the biologist that runs the seahorse exhibit actually teaching me first hand with the tank about seahorses and their needs. He actually helped me design my own tank to accommodate them. In my experience the NEAQ is a reputable place. I also have input on corals from a biologist from the catalina island marine institute.
 
I am talking of the New England Aquarium. Although some of my info is second hand, much of it is firsthand from the biologist that runs the seahorse exhibit actually teaching me first hand with the tank about seahorses and their needs. He actually helped me design my own tank to accommodate them. In my experience the NEAQ is a reputable place. I also have input on corals from a biologist from the catalina island marine institute.

Any info from someone else is by definition second hand. I spend many hours every month volunteering at the Ga. Aquarium and talking to the biologists. That is second hand information. I'll be looking for more at next month's MACNA conference. I've not kept SW personally, but am very concerned about potentially bad information being spread when it comes to sensitive animals.
 
AquariaCentral.com