Mafia #41 The Play -- 50/50

oh my word! please, G... we may be on the opposite team, but that would mean you are admitting to being mafia...


it's all part of her game, Z...

Oh, Doll..you know I have nothin but love for ya, but I think I may have to disagree with ya here!
 
I'm not hiding. I've made posts last night after night fall and again this morning before I left for work.

I've stated I'm being set up. I didn't use Plant as a reason but since it was brought up. When have I ever hit the person I was arguing with if I were evil? Hits are to set up players. Again why would I risk 3 mafia on the chance to save Noodles?

Read my posts again and you'll see I was trying to force Dawg onto Noodles as the kill vote. If I knew Noodles was mafia why would I try and force Dawg onto her?


These are my thoughts:

C-Note was quick to jump to Dawg.

JM acting like she wanted to jump but if she had it could have ended up pointing to her if Noodles was found mafia. Then the "flub".

LG thought Noodles was innocent but not enough to try and save her?

Chill is to quiet, he is normally pretty vocal but when we were mafia together I told him its best to let the innocents lynch each other and stay in the shadows

Z I really don't like that he thinks I'm innocent, after todays posts I would understand but not Day 1 or 2.

Dawg not sure about him anymore,he wouldn't jump to Noodles to put the final nail in the coffin.


DD- the only thing about her I have to question is the attack of the list. At this time without going back through I can't say she has done anything to pique my interest.

Mal- pfft who knows. Out of everyone I'd lean her more innocent then the rest though.

The best we can hope at this point is that Pleco was mafia and its 5 mafia to 4 innocents.

I think my vote will go to either JM,Chill,C-Note,LG or Z.
 
I'm not hiding. I've made posts last night after night fall and again this morning before I left for work.

I've stated I'm being set up. I didn't use Plant as a reason but since it was brought up. When have I ever hit the person I was arguing with if I were evil? Hits are to set up players. Again why would I risk 3 mafia on the chance to save Noodles?

Read my posts again and you'll see I was trying to force Dawg onto Noodles as the kill vote. If I knew Noodles was mafia why would I try and force Dawg onto her?


These are my thoughts:

C-Note was quick to jump to Dawg.

JM acting like she wanted to jump but if she had it could have ended up pointing to her if Noodles was found mafia. Then the "flub".

LG thought Noodles was innocent but not enough to try and save her?

Chill is to quiet, he is normally pretty vocal but when we were mafia together I told him its best to let the innocents lynch each other and stay in the shadows

Z I really don't like that he thinks I'm innocent, after todays posts I would understand but not Day 1 or 2.

Dawg not sure about him anymore,he wouldn't jump to Noodles to put the final nail in the coffin.


DD- the only thing about her I have to question is the attack of the list. At this time without going back through I can't say she has done anything to pique my interest.

Mal- pfft who knows. Out of everyone I'd lean her more innocent then the rest though.

The best we can hope at this point is that Pleco was mafia and its 5 mafia to 4 innocents.

I think my vote will go to either JM,Chill,C-Note,LG or Z.

If that makes me look guilty somehow, fine. My vote was on Chill by itself and I thought dawg looked guiltier than noodles. I was wrong about guiltiER, but I think he's just as guilty.

Unless I see something really convincing my vote isn't changing.
 
Well Ice I don't remember that bit of advice from you. Not that I'm particularly good at taking or even remembering advice but as I remember it by the time you recruited me it was a vampire landslide and all talks of subtlety were gone out the window. There was even talk of everyone switching to the same avatar to screw with the townies. In the end though the advice to me was deny, deny, deny and we framed RB.

That's the 3rd time you've struck my radar. The first you looked like you were distancing from Noodles when she left you off her list. The second when you had the big push to tie up the vote on noodles.

I'm thinking Noodles was CM and there were 4 of you. You could afford to flex some muscle and push for a tie (or better if you could hook in an extra vote). No big risk it had plausible deniability. You could always claim you were set-up and explain you would never pull such an incriminating move. People tend to believe you, and if you were really bored it'd be a nice challenge to try and get away with. All I'm hearing though is deny, deny, deny.
 
So my main 3 suspects last night were Ice, Noodles and Chill. Since Noodles is gone and confirmed Mafia I can take them off the list and replace with Jmax because of that slip up. So this is what I have...

JMax - Is this a major slip up or a typo? I'm not sure yet to tell you the truth. I don't buy the apple wine defense but I still think it could be an innocent mistake. Time will tell but my vote is not for her right now.

Ice - Not much else to say. All fingers right now point to Ice being Mafia. He seems a little too obvious a choice right now though. Don't get me wrong...I will vote for him without much persuasion. I am thinking that usually when all the mafia plannets align on one person like this that it is more likely a setup.

Chill - I just don't think Chill is on his normal game right now. It could be RL getting in the way or more likely he is hiding something. After being nonexistant prior to nightfall he comes in after night with this post...



...and then disapears. Of course Ice seems to be the most obvious answer just after nightfall...but the part that gets me is when he says Ice is trying to save a teammate. Now wouldn't noodles be identified as a communicating mafia if they were one? Maybe RB can clear this up. Chill just has the hair on the back of my neck standing up right now. I vote to lynch Chill

That's funny at least once a game someone says Chill is not playing his normal game. I wonder what my normal game actually looks like?
 
Well Ice I don't remember that bit of advice from you. Not that I'm particularly good at taking or even remembering advice but as I remember it by the time you recruited me it was a vampire landslide and all talks of subtlety were gone out the window. There was even talk of everyone switching to the same avatar to screw with the townies. In the end though the advice to me was deny, deny, deny and we framed RB.

That's the 3rd time you've struck my radar. The first you looked like you were distancing from Noodles when she left you off her list. The second when you had the big push to tie up the vote on noodles.

I'm thinking Noodles was CM and there were 4 of you. You could afford to flex some muscle and push for a tie (or better if you could hook in an extra vote). No big risk it had plausible deniability. You could always claim you were set-up and explain you would never pull such an incriminating move. People tend to believe you, and if you were really bored it'd be a nice challenge to try and get away with. All I'm hearing though is deny, deny, deny.

It was your 1st game as evil and it was me you and I believe HN that I remember. Think you even were the leader.

Doesn't matter either way, I would never preach deny deny deny. If I'd preach anything it would be to lay low and wait for someone else to grab the heat. The less you say when cornered the better. Someone usually screws up and then the witch hunt switches over to them. Denying doesn't make the problem go away,it just keeps you in the limelight.
 
When did you start playing,what game number? I'll go back and see if I can pull anything up.
 
I can save ya some trouble there Ice...I was the Mod that game...Dawg was the leader, and you guys took Sploke, HN and Chill. Chill was the last on your team.
 
Think you got me confused with Dawg. He was the leader in Vampires - I came in on the end it was Dawg, Hooked, You, and possibly somebody else (Sploke??? not sure) when I got there.
 
Ok looking back it was Dawg who was the leader and recruited HN and me then you. My bad.
 
AquariaCentral.com