Mafia 42: Assassin in the Palace (The Play)

[IceH2O]

Are we sure Mad selected the assassin and did not just draw names for the roles?

In a setup like this I myself wouldn't trust a random draw of players.I doubt Mad did either.

You either don't understand how this round works, or... well no or. This is not Mafia. The assassin is going to ride low and try to get us to give them information. Malbri was doing just that, and in this game we do not want a UD. By the time Malbri showed up they were to far along in the votes to get pulled out. Now by the statements you just made the assassin knows Malbri isn't the King. So therefore, Malbri is either a Guard or the assassin.

With one less person and still needing five votes to lynch today will be harder than yesterday. I suggest we lynch the person that jb has all but told the assassin is not the King.

I vote to lynch Malbri.

I don't see how JBs post shows Mal isn't King either. I think you are trying to out the King here Zsand. We could put 3 votes on the King easily. The 4th vote could be the assassin but there would still be a guard to vote the other player. Like Dawg said its all about tricking the assassin.

I retract my vote on JB and vote to lynch Zsand


Yes JB I am guessing, I did pretty much say that.Glad you're so observant.



I think we should keep the voting to 2 people per day. We need to mix it up and have the King,if we haven't already :evil_lol: in the loop of voting as to not give them away. With keeping to 2 players we never give out to much info and still have a chance at getting the assassin, never put more then 3 votes on 1 of the people. We could vote out 1 person then the next day use the person that was saved the previous day plus another player.

Like yesterday it was BKW and Mal....today Mal and Z...tomorrow Mal and Noodles then Mal/Noodles and JB etc....use whover in place of Noodles and JB just used them as an example,it could be whoever we decide at the time but you get the drift I hope.

 

[ZSandmann]

I guess no one understands my logic then.

 

[IceH2O]

I don't see how JBs post shows Mal isn't King either. I think you are trying to out the King here Zsand. We could have put 3 votes on the King easily.....

Today we could still put 3 votes on the King if we wanted, even if the 4th vote is the assassin today it would show a tie and we'd just need 1 Guard to move. Does this out the King? Sure, IF its the King. Could be just another Guard though, only we know and the assassin only gets 1 shot so they better be sure.

 

[IceH2O]

I guess no one understands my logic then.

If I trusted you I do understand the logic. But I don't trust you.

 

[noodles62]

I don't see how JBs post shows Mal isn't King either. I think you are trying to out the King here Zsand. We could put 3 votes on the King easily. The 4th vote could be the assassin but there would still be a guard to vote the other player. Like Dawg said its all about tricking the assassin.

I retract my vote on JB and vote to lynch Zsand

I am glad that someone else sees this! Something is just not sitting right with me regarding Z but I have not played enough to be certain. Like I said my current vote is subject to change!

 

[ZSandmann]

I figured that part out. All I'm saying is we are giving out too much info. That's all.

 

[ZSandmann]

Sorry that previous post of mine was to Ice not you noodles

 

[Madcrawdad]

Vote count thru post #146

Mal(3) - Z(121), LG(128), Noodles(140)
Z(2) - JB(113), Ice(141)
JB(1) - Dawg(133)

No votes from: Mal, Ogre

With 8 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch...

 

[dirtydawg10]

I am glad that someone else sees this! Something is just not sitting right with me regarding Z but I have not played enough to be certain. Like I said my current vote is subject to change!

Something is not sitting right for me either Noodles. Z already had votes and you say, I'm glad someone else sees that Z doesn't seem right. Well if that was the case why did you vote for Mal over Z?

 

[OgreMkV]

FYI everyone in case you missed it.

All guards and the king should lie and deceive as they please. The only person who will not know you are lying is the assassin. The rest of us will know. I don't think we will route out the assassin by seeing them implicate the king for a lynch.

1) I think Z has a pretty good point about Mal

2) I disagree with Dawg above in that we should hardly discuss anything at all. We all know who the king is. WE are the ones that need to keep quite and plug away until we discover the assassin. If we do that then the assassin has to either 1) make a guess when we get to them or 2) try to push to find the king.

3) I'll tie it up (I think this ties it up)... I vote to lynch Mal sorry girl, but I do think you gave too much info to the assassin... if you aren't yourself.