Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville

No - I am certain I have played evil - just cannot put my finger on the Game # at the moment...





Past roles do not really hold much weight with me as it is a random draw.... you all are to be watched and to be considered evil until proven otherwise.....At the moment I do not have the time to pull previous games to prove what role I played (I did not keep game records) and I really do not see how/why it would factor in to the current game.....I feel that the task at hand is to find the curent evils and play accordingly - not worry about who did what last time...........

I was just interested at first and I already said I don;t really care that much at this point.

Very defensive there noodles62. Could you be part of the evil plague among us?

I'm not sayin, I'm just sayin.

That's got to be the most annoying thing ever posted...

Are you defending DD? hhhmmm; "much watch this".....

No but how odd is it that two of the newbs voted DD out of the gate?

I traced your IP address. No actually I came to a logical conclusion. Penguins fan = Steelers fan. No doubt about that. Yay I'm being lynched!!!

What statement? I'm a mafia noob. Or am I? Muhahahaha. Okay I really am a mafia noob.

Ok, for one that is just creepy, and two why are you trying to be confusing?

sh*** i know who is the grinch,dadadada ^^^^

Ummm...who and how?

Innocent until proven guilty. Isnt that the motto of the USA? And as you can tell I made a noob mistake. So I couldnt have a coach whispering in my ear.

Nope, guilty until proven innocent in mafia.

I didnt know there was an offical mafia rule book. Lynch me!! You could be killing a nice young man. Or you could be killing an evil young man. You will never know until you do. Unless you know. But then you would know. And that wouldnt be fun if you knew. So hopefully you dont know. Because I dont even know.

Precedence states that newbs who try to be crafty and unclear are usually mafia. You seem to fit that case.


Yes, Noodles...that was the plan :)

--------------------------

JPap, in your quote below, you mention that who played what role previously doesn't determine anything in this game. I agree wholeheartedly.


Here you admit to looking through past games to see what roles Noodles has played.


Then here you admit to doing some MAJOR digging through past games to determine what roles Noodles has played. The question I have, is 'Why'? You said in the quote above that past roles are irrelevant, so it's more than interesting that you'd go through old game so thoroughly (or maybe not so thoroughly, as you incorrectly reported her as having never played scum).

I wanted to see if she was at first, mainly because I was just interested then I checked because she didn't answer definitively and I wanted to see if she was telling the truth, then I went through again to make sure I didn't screw up, because if I did and I didn't correct myself people would be all over me for acting scummy, and I did make a mistake and admitted it. If you think its suspicious so be it but it was merely a simple question that turned into more trouble than it was worth.

Right now I have eddie and virt high up on my annoying players list, but I can't say anyone has actually been suspicious enough to warrant a vote.
 
I have a question.....several people keep referring to what roles others played in past games - is it pretty common for the mod to try to spread the love by making sure others get a chance, or is it just typically a random draw? Just curious and trying to wrap my head around it.........
 
I have a question.....several people keep referring to what roles others played in past games - is it pretty common for the mod to try to spread the love by making sure others get a chance, or is it just typically a random draw? Just curious and trying to wrap my head around it.........

Gah! Right after I hit "post" I see the quote from JP saying how it is a random draw.....never mind!
 
oops, I meant DD and not Grinch.
hmmmmm,coherts,you covering up for the slip about DD being the grinch.and in the sign up thread you and 3rd,suspicious imo!!!all evil,Piggy is watching you jl......
 
I was just interested at first and I already said I don;t really care that much at this point.



That's got to be the most annoying thing ever posted...



No but how odd is it that two of the newbs voted DD out of the gate?



Ok, for one that is just creepy, and two why are you trying to be confusing?



Ummm...who and how?



Nope, guilty until proven innocent in mafia.



Precedence states that newbs who try to be crafty and unclear are usually mafia. You seem to fit that case.




I wanted to see if she was at first, mainly because I was just interested then I checked because she didn't answer definitively and I wanted to see if she was telling the truth, then I went through again to make sure I didn't screw up, because if I did and I didn't correct myself people would be all over me for acting scummy, and I did make a mistake and admitted it. If you think its suspicious so be it but it was merely a simple question that turned into more trouble than it was worth.

Right now I have eddie and virt high up on my annoying players list, but I can't say anyone has actually been suspicious enough to warrant a vote.


My response was "I was certain" I was an evil in past games - in my book "certain" is well, certain!
 
Well, I gotta go now. My son is on his way home from work and hubby is totally grouchy - so I am sure he will want to hole up in this room and stay out of the bear's way......Thankfully it is not nightfall tonite - I will try to get back on later but no promises. Get to posting people, so I have something to go on tomorrow!!!
 
Yea, I can't recall the exact game ATM (my memory sucks = old age!) but I have been evil (will try to research later - but now I must shower...). I think it definitely is the turn of some of the older/returing players to be evil.....

That was what I was referring to. Not a big deal.
 
hmmmmm,coherts,you covering up for the slip about DD being the grinch.and in the sign up thread you and 3rd,suspicious imo!!!all evil,Piggy is watching you jl......

I'm pretty sure that was a sarcastic remark.


I think the people trying to find out who were who in other mafia games,probably are evil elfs,idk just my own opinion.

Thats just rediculous....thats been going on since mafia...2. Its just something people speculate on whether it is meaningful or not. It can help though, if you can identify differences in gameplay between when someone played as an innocent vs. how they played as a mafia/evil character.
 
AquariaCentral.com