He felt that DD was the better choice. I was about to change to DD myself feeling that if he saw something that I was going to trust him. but you jumped and I wanted to see if lone voters were going to show up and change. I still feel piggy is evil.
Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
He felt that DD was the better choice. I was about to change to DD myself feeling that if he saw something that I was going to trust him. but you jumped and I wanted to see if lone voters were going to show up and change. I still feel piggy is evil.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
For the record, I would not have voted for DD. I would have went back to pig. If you look, I had DD as a day one suspect, but with the hit of eddie I didn't suspect her anymore. I did not post that, because defending her would have not helped, plus DD can defend herself. I am guessing she was not around at nightfall.
I think we can trust the fact that if cat is a communicating innocent, then pig is not.
I think we see a list of who his partner is not. At least I am going to assume that the list of 5 could not be his partner.
With that in mind, I am willing to vote with cat. If that means moving off of pig, I will.
I think we can trust the fact that if cat is a communicating innocent, then pig is not.
I think we see a list of who his partner is not. At least I am going to assume that the list of 5 could not be his partner.
With that in mind, I am willing to vote with cat. If that means moving off of pig, I will.
Well crap....sorry DD, I really thought I had you pegged.
I need to go back and check out a few things, but I will be looking into dawg and HN today. Piggy seems to be the popular choice right now,which will warrant some more research as well.
I need to go back and check out a few things, but I will be looking into dawg and HN today. Piggy seems to be the popular choice right now,which will warrant some more research as well.
Dawg,i'm not downing you for your vote against DD,i really thought she was evil,but you switching your vote at the last min seems fishy,also by you saying i vote for dawg to get the town to pitty you was a smart move,but a transparent one,then you want the coal,another ploy for pitty imo.
I don't need any pity...vote for me if you like. I have no problem with it. I screwed up big time and I'm ready to face the consequences if I have to. My plea for the coal was not for pity it was to help save the Town. I figured that was the least I could do after last night.
Ok Plant here is my 1 problem with giving out who I gave it to. If I gave it to someone who is evil there is a 67% chance that they will get the double vote. Now here is the thing, I gave it to a person that is high on my suspect list. I had asked for this person because I feel them evil. I am hoping that the 33% chance of turning them good will come up. I will tell who it was just before nightfall. This is an action to reduce risk to the town. This way if the double vote shows then the player who gets it will not have the chance to jump ship elsewhere and vote off someone else. Trying to prevent any more innocent losses.
The rules say the person has a choice whether or not to open the present. I really don't think that the person will risk switching sides to gain an extra vote, especially if they are evil. If they are innocent and secretly wish to be evil then they might, but let's hope not. I don't see why you cannot tell us their name and establish credibility for yourself in case Rudolph doesn't buy your story. Also if they deny getting the present then u will know they are evil, though some may not believe you then. For myself, in absence of other information I will assume u are telling the truth.
Argh... that night thoroughly sucked. Sorry I wasn't around (I'll not bore you with RL stuff you probably won't believe anyway). If I had been around, I probably would have voted for Cat though so that shows how good of a read I have on the game at this point. I'm fine with anything that will help the town at this point. Lynch me, Blitz me, whatever if it helps. I'm going to read back over the posts from folks on Cat's list since I think we have no choice but to believe him for now.
Cat, if you're evil and this is a ploy, it's the ballsiest one I've seen.
Cat, if you're evil and this is a ploy, it's the ballsiest one I've seen.
Lynch me,Blitz me,that's not gonna work,Dawg already played that card.laying low for a reason HN?
